Tales from a Scenic Artist and Scholar. Part 982 – Scenic Artists and WWI Camouflage, 1918

Copyright © 2020 by Wendy Waszut-Barrett

A while back I explored the career of Gerald V. Cannon, of Joy and Cannon Scenic Studio in St. Paul, Minnesota. Although the life of the firm was brief, each co-founder certainly made his mark on the world.  At the time that I was researching Cannon’s life, I stumbled across multiple references to his military career and work for the US marines. Cannon organized the first unit to specialize in the brand new art of camouflage in 1918. He gathered together a group of scenic artists and once they learned the painting procedure, they were split up among the services. Cannon chose the marines.

Artists were tasked with painting large camouflage canopies during WWI.

Here is a 1918 article about Cannon’s project that I came across this week:

On February 27, 1918, the “Los Angeles Evening Express” reported “Scenic Artists to Mobilize as U. S. Aid in World Conflict” (page 12).  Here is the article:

“Scenic artists in Southern California theaters are included in a country-wide plan to mobilize all of their craft in this country for war purposes. The scheme is being worked out by G. V. Cannon – appropriate name – of St. Paul, Minn., and is understood to have the sanction of the war department. The plan is explained in the following letter from Mr. Cannon, which has been received by attaches of local theaters:

‘The English and French governments have organized the artists of the countries, especially the scenic artists, to work in naval yards, as well as in the fields with regular army, for the purpose of painting large tarpaulins and canvas covers to mask field guns, and they grasped the value of the scenic artist, with his experience, with his wide experience and talent and reproduction and color. They have taken these artists with their various color schemes and composition to completely mask a series of field guns, or paint the sides of a battleship in nature’s true colors and the ocean and waves, so that it has completely baffled the enemy’s submarines to as near as half mile, and, at that distance, in many cases, they have made such poor targets that the submarine has had to maneuver around until it was detected and fired upon. This plan applies to transports on which the American government will have to spend every effort available to guard the loves of its men. Another feature of painting boats is in the painting of a huge wave on the bow of a battleship, this is being the chief method of judging the speed that a boat is traveling. This gives the enemy the impression that the boa is traveling at half speed. There are possibilities too numerous to mention on the value of scenic backgrounds, or fooling the enemy with paint. This plan is being put up to the war department by some of our leading artists and naval men. Among some of the nation’s leading advocates is Joe Cannon, former speaker of the house representatives, who in past years was a decorator and who realizes the value of the work. He is at present working in our interests as a personal favor to myself. So let us hear from all scenic artists who are interested in helping Uncle Sam down the Kaiser, by sending their name, address and age along with past experience and ability to me. – G. V. Cannon, 378 South Wabasha street, St. Paul, Minn.’”

In 1950, Cannon was featured in the “Star Tribune” article, “Minnesota’s ‘Little Marine’ Just Keeps Growing” (5 Nov. 1950, page 21). I am also including this article in its entirety for context.

From the “Star Tribune,” 5 Nov. 1950, page 21.

“There’s a line in one of the censored verse of ‘Mademoiselle From Armentieres’ which goes ‘The little marine he grew and grew.’

The boys hereabouts seem to think that if a line ever applied to anybody in real life, it applies to Jerry Cannon.

More sedately, he’s Gerald V. Cannon, a scenic artist by profession who still makes up an occasional Marine Corps float or a spectacular sign. Its come to be a habit through 33 years of association with the corps.

Cannon will be present at the corps 175th anniversary dinner Friday night at the Nicollet hotel. Governor Youngdahl, Mayors Hoyer of Minneapolis and Delaney of St. Paul and various other functionaries also will attend, along with wives and mothers of marines now in service.

He now is national service officer for the Marine Corps league, the only veterans’ organization incorporated by act of congress. He is also state service officer under the auspices of the department of veteran’s affairs.

In that job, he is but carrying on a practice built up on his own time between two wars. Cannon was a marine in World War I. Prior to that he had been called upon to organize the first unit to specialize in the brand new art of camouflage. Cannon gathered together a half gross of scenic artists. When they had learned what they had to know, they were split up among the services. Cannon chose the marines and began an extra-curricular career from which he never since has been separated for long.

After the war he helped found three marine groups, each of which perished through inaction. But Cannon made it his business to keep in touch with marines and marine veterans and to pull what wires were necessary to help them.

He became a sort of special in veterans’ rights and made up for his small stature by fast talk and aggressiveness.

When World War II came along, Cannon had retired from the reserve as a captain with 100 per cent disability because of a heart condition. He went right back in, as a staff sergeant attached to the When Cannon enlisted in WWI he listed a health concern, there was foul-up; he got orders to report to Parris Island for boot training. A few days nearly did him in. Representative Melvin Maas rescued him by getting the orders changed and Cannon was shipped back to Minneapolis.

During the subsequent years, he indulged in his hobby of helping out marines and ex-marines. After being discharged he went to the Marine Corps league as a service officer.

His years of association with the marines have been a great help in cutting red tape. On his frequent trips to Washington, Cannon first-names big brass and walks right into offices which would be at least temporarily off-limits to almost anyone else.

Cannon through the years has loaded himself with Marine Corps lore, and documented a good bit of it by collecting relics.

He was a scene designer, for instance, for an Otis Skinner touring company of ‘Kismet.” Among the props was a handsome ivory-handled knife – no stage piece but a real article from Tripoli, dating back to their time the marines made their historic landing there in 1803.

After the tour ended, the knife was presented to Canon. He now keeps its tip sheathed in tape because it’s supposed to be made of poisoned steel.

The knife gave him some anxious moments a few years ago, when he was running a restaurant in the Midway district and had it on display with other relics.

Someone broke into the place and took, among other things, the knife. Both because it was a valuable souvenir and a dangerous weapon as well, Cannon left no stone unturned to get it back.

At length he and the police tracked it down. A bunch of kids were playing with it, using it in a game of cops and robbers. (The knife will be on display at the State Theater when the movie ‘Tripoli,’ depicting the Tripoli incident opens there Friday. The timing of the picture and the dinner is purely coincidental.”

An avid collector, Cannon often picked up books and relics in his travels as a scenic artist. In an old history of the Civil war he found a penciled map indicating a gunroom at old Fort Jackson, at the mouth of the Mississippi, had been sealed up.

He got a government commission to open it and dug through three feet of cement. In the room he found many rare pieces including a dozen large lamps. One of them, given him by the government adorns his home at Cleveland Avenue and Ramsey county road B. The house is li furnished with similar items.

Among them are a couple of hand-wrought nails from the home of Betsy Ross. A marine happened to be guarding the place when Cannon visited as it was being repaired, and a wink from one marine to another seems to mean something.

Busy as he has been, Cannon foresees an even busier time ahead. For one thing, veterans are in a peculiar position, as far as their rights are concerned; while theoretically convened by provisions involving ‘hazardous duty’ or ‘simulated warfare,’ the United States is not actually at was. This, he thinks, will affect claims coming out of Korea.

The men who appeal to him for help, however, are confident of his ability. The little marine, they think, grew until he knows as much about the Marine Corps and its procedures as anybody up or down the line.”

I have explored the Gerald V. Cannon of Joy & Cannon studios in the past. For more information, see past posts 797-800.

page 5.
Studio stencil for Joy & Cannon Scenic Co. on the back of a picture sheet at Triune Lodge in St. Paul, Minnesota.

To be continued…

Tales from a Scenic Artist and Scholar. Part 799 – Gerald V. Cannon of Joy & Cannon Scenic Co.

Boyd P. Joy and Gerald V. Cannon founded Joy & Cannon Scenic Co. The studio first appeared in St. Paul Directories in 1916. Yesterday, I explored the life of Joy. Today, I look at the life of G. V. Cannon, who was not only a scenic artist, but also the first camouflage artist of the United States Marine Corps. He held the world record for this work during his lifetime and was recognized for it.

I have uncovered very little about the Cannon’s early life. By 1915, however, he was living at 4144 38th Ave S. in Minneapolis, Minnesota. Much may have to do with the itinerant life of many scenic artists.

On Dec. 22, 1917, the “Dickinson Press” mentioned Joy & Cannon in the article “Stage Scenery is installed in New Rialto Theatre” (Stark City, ND Dec 22, 1917). The article reported, “The stage scenery and effects have been put in place in the new Rialto theatre during the past week of the personal supervision of the artist who painted the curtains, G. N. [sic.] Cannon of the Joy & Cannon Scenic Co., St. Paul. The drop curtains are as follows: Asbestos, advertising front curtain, street scene, rose garden scene, wood scene, parlor and kitchen curtains. The scenic work has been done in the new modern art, stippled urban effects, lately inaugurated in the scenic work of large theatres in the east. The effect is very odd, but highly pleasing to the eye.” This is the earliest mention that I have encountered to date about the contemporary spattering technique. I find it interesting that it was called “stippling” at the time.

Gerald V. Cannon featured in the “Star Tribune,” 5 Nov. 1950, page 21

Shortly after the Joy & Cannon Scenic Co. opened, Cannon on another project for the U.S. Government during WWI.  I came across and article that I find absolutely fascinating about not only Cannon, but also mentioned the history of camouflage painting. In 1950, the “Star Tribune” published an article on Gerald V. Cannon entitled, “Minnesota’s ‘Little Marine’ Just Keeps Growing” (5 Nov. 1950, page 21). I am posting the article in its entirety as it has great significance within the history of American scenic art.

“There’s a line in one of the censored verse of ‘Mademoiselle From Armentieres’ which goes ‘The little marine he grew and grew.’

The boys hereabouts seem to think that if a line ever applied to anybody in real life, it applies to Jerry Cannon.

More sedately, he’s Gerald V. Cannon, a scenic artist by profession who still makes up an occasional marine corps float or a spectacular sign. Its come to be a habit through 33 years of association with the corps.

Cannon will be present at the corps 175th anniversary dinner Friday night at the Nicollet hotel. Governor Youngdahl, Mayors Hoyer of Minneapolis and Delaney of St. Paul and various other functionaries also will attend, along with wives and mothers of marines now in service.

He now is national service officer for the Marine Corps league, the only veterans’ organization incorporated by act of congress. He is also state service officer under the auspices of the department of veteran’s affairs.

In that job, he is but carrying on a practice built up on his own time between two wars. Cannon was a marine in World War I. Prior to that, he had been called upon to organize the first unit to specialize in the brand new art of camouflage. Cannon gathered together a half gross of scenic artists. When they had learned what they had to know, they were split up among the services. Cannon chose the marines and began an extra-curricular career from which he never since has been separated for long.

After the war he helped found three marine groups, each of which perished through inaction. But Cannon made it his business to keep in touch with marines and marine veterans and to pull what wires were necessary to help them.

He became a sort of special in veterans’ rights and made up for his small stature by fast talk and aggressiveness.

When World War II came along, Cannon had retired from the reserve as a captain with 100 per cent disability because of a heart condition. He went right back in, as a staff sergeant attached to the Minneapolis marine office. Through a foul-up, he got orders to report to Parris Island for boot training. A few days nearly did him in. Representative Melvin Maas rescued him by getting the orders changed and Cannon was shipped back to Minneapolis.

During the subsequent years, he indulged in his hobby of helping out marines and ex-marines. After being discharged he went to the Marine Corps league as a service officer.

His years of association with the marines have been a great help in cutting red tape. On his frequent trips to Washington, Cannon first-names big brass and walks right into offices which would be at least temporarily off-limits to almost anyone else.

Cannon through the years has loaded himself with marine corps lore, and documented a good bit of it by collecting relics.

He was a scene designer, for instance, for an Otis Skinner touring company of ‘Kismet.” Among the props was a handsome ivory-handled knife – no stage piece but a real article from Tripoli, dating back to their time the marines made their historic landing there in 1803.

After the tour ended, the knife was presented to Canon. He now keeps its tip sheathed in tape because it’s supposed to be made of poisoned steel.

The knife gave him some anxious moments a few years ago, when he was running a restaurant in the Midway district and had it on display with other relics.

Someone broke into the place and took, among other things, the knife. Both because it was a valuable souvenir and a dangerous weapon as well, Cannon left no stone unturned to get it back.

At length he and the police tracked it down. A bunch of kids were playing with it, using it in a game of cops and robbers. (The knife will be on display at the State theater when the movie ‘Tripoli,’ depicting the Tripoli incident opens there Friday. The timing of the picture and the dinner is purely coincidental.”

An avid collector, Cannon often picked up books and relics in his travels as a scenic artist. In an old history of the Civil war he found a penciled map indicating a gunroom at old Fort Jackson, at the mouth of the Mississippi, had been sealed up.

He got a government commission to open it and dug through three feet of cement. In the room he found many rare pieces including a dozen large lamps. One of them, given him by the government adorns his home at Cleveland avenue and Ramsey county road B. The house is li furnished with similar items.

Among them are a couple of hand-wrought nails from the home of Betsy Ross. A marine happened to be guarding the place when Cannon visited as it was being repaired, and a wink from one marine to another seems to mean something.

Busy as he has been, Cannon foresees an even busier time ahead. For one thing, veterans are in a peculiar position, as far as their rights are concerned; while theoretically convened by provisions involving ‘hazardous duty’ or ‘simulated warfare,’ the United States is not actually at was. This, he thinks, will affect claims coming out of Korea.

The men who appeal to him for help, however, are confident of his ability. The little marine, they think, grew until he knows as much about the marine corps and its procedures as anybody up or down the line.”

If you unfamiliar with the hymn of the U. S. Marine Corps, is the oldest official song in the U.S. Armed Forces. Here is a link to a wonderful version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u2pFKyOO-7U The music for Marine’s Hymn originally came from the March section of Offenbach’s “Genevieve de Brabant.” When, or who, added the lyrics for the “Marine’s Hymn” to Offenbach’s music remains unknown. The first version of the song was copyrighted, published. and distributed in 1919 by “The Leatherneck,” a Marine Corps magazine printed in Quantico, Virginia.

The 1929 lyrics:

From the Halls of Montezuma
To the shores of Tripoli;
We fight our country’s battles
On the land as on the sea;
First to fight for right and freedom
And to keep our honor clean;
We are proud to claim the title
Of United States Marine.

Our flag’s unfurled to every breeze
From dawn to setting sun;
We have fought in ev’ry clime and place
Where we could take a gun;
In the snow of far-off Northern lands
And in sunny tropic scenes;
You will find us always on the job
The United States Marines

Here’s 
health to you and to our Corps
Which we are proud to serve;
In many a strife we’ve fought for life
And never lost our nerve;
If the 
Army and the Navy
Ever look on Heaven’s scenes;
They will find the streets are guarded
By United States Marines.

To be continued…

Tales from a Scenic Artist and Scholar. Part 798 – Boyd P. Joy of Joy & Cannon

Although today’s post is laden with details, there is a reason for it. As I briefly explore the emergence of two Minnesota-based scenic studios, Joy & Cannon Scenic Co. and Universal Scenic Studio stories, they represent a shift within the industry. The appearance of scenic studios during the second decade of the twentieth century, threaten the older and more established studios, such as Sosman & Landis. It is a time of great change.

Boyd Phelphs Joy was born on Feb. 20, 1873. The son of Berry P. and Lucinda Joy, He was one of three children and grew up in Winona, Minnesota. Throughout his life, Joy appears to have been a little here, there, and everywhere.  Described as short man with medium build, grey eyes and dark brown hair, Joy was quick to smile and had a magnetic personality.

Boyd P. Joy, pictured in the “Argus-Leader,” 22 March 1919, page 12

By the age of twenty, Joy left Winona and moved north to the Twin Cities. He was first listed in the St. Paul City Directory during 1893, working as a clerk for J. H. Sleeper and boarding at 1062 Ross with Benjamin P. Joy, his uncle. He continued to live with his uncle, both moving to 874 Beach in 1894. Joy was still working as a clerk when he moved to Minneapolis in 1895. He then disappears from city directories until 1901 when he reappears as a civil engineer, briefly starting a new career before turning to the theatre. Joy is again living with his uncle, just at a new location – 364 E. 9th St. in St. Paul. He started a new career as a civil engineer, living with his uncle again. This continued until 1902, when they moved to 1342 Brand. During this time, Joy’s employment is temporarily associated with G. N. Ry (Great Northern Railway). 1902 is the crucial moment when Joy transitions from the railway to the stage, without any indication as to how it happened.

Out of nowhere, he becomes the manager of a touring show that spring. The “Calgary Herald reports, “Boyd P. Joy, manager of the Rip Van Winkle company, called at the Herald Office this morning, and stated that his company, which would appear in the opera house tonight, has everywhere been having bumper houses. They will try to give the people the best possible play for their money. They will play tonight and tomorrow night in the opera house” (Alberta, Canada, 5 May 1902, page 4).

By spring of 1903, “The Superior Times” advertised, “Boyd P. Joy presents the romantic actor Bert C. Wood supported by the Girard Theatre Company in a repertoire of new plays, clever specialties, special scenery, [and] electrical effects” (Superior, Wisconsin, 18 April, 1903, page 3). That fall, Joy is managing and acting with Breckenridge Stock Company, a company featuring the comedian Charles Breckenridge. Among their repertoires is the 4-act comedy, ‘An Irish American,”  “Rip Van Winkle,” “Her Bashful Admirer,” “Guilty Without Crime,” and the military comedy-drama “Nebraska.”  While the company was touring Kansas, Joy was mention in the “Iola Daily” noting, “Boyd P. Joy, the manager, is a pleasant gentleman to deal with in a business way and is a capable actor” (14 Nov. 1903, page 3). By winter, “The Emporia” reported, “The principal characters were good, but it was Boyd P. Joy as the funny Irishman that received the greater part of applause”  (Emporia, Kansas, 22 Dec. 1903, page 5). Another role played by Joy with the Breckenridge Company was that of Spotted Chief Horse in their production of “Nebraska.”

Boyd P. Joy, from the “Concordia Press,” (Concordia, Kansas) Jan. 7, 1904, page 1

By 1905 Joy has returned to Minnesota, becoming the treasurer of the Metropolitan Opera House in St. Paul. He is now 32 years old and residing at 95 11th St. The next year he is also listed as a treasurer for the Met. Opera House and living at 125 Summit Ave in St. Paul, yet is back on the road. In 1906, Joy is touring with another production – “A Daughter of Colorado.” Advertised as “A complete scenic production,” the show is advertised as under the direction of Boyd P. Joy (Grand Forks Herald, 13 Sept. 1906, page 5). This new four-act romantic comedy featured Miss Laura Frankenfield.

Boyd P. Joy, from the “Grand Forks Herald,” Sept. 13, 1906, page 5

In 1907 Joy is listed as a playwright in “Dramatic Compositions Copyrighted in the United States, 1870 to 1916” –  “Panama – a tale of the great canal, a melodrama in 4 acts by B. P. Joy. [97] Typewritten. © Boyd. P. Joy. St. Paul; D: 10884, June 29, 1907; 2c. June 29, 1907.” He seems to have been trying his hand at a little bot of everything before settling on scenic production. Between 1907 and 1912, Joy focuses on scenic production. By 1912, Joy is credited with creating a new scenic production for the Huntington Players –  “In the Bishop’s Carriage” (South Bend Tribune, 9 Nov. 1912). This is where his transition from manager/actor to scenic artists begins and he is noted as “the Huntington artist.” Joy seems to have made the shift from performance to design while working for the Huntington Company.

In 1913, Joy is still listed as the Huntington Company’s scenic artist for “As a Man Sows.” The “South Bend Tribune” reported, “’As the Man Sows, which will be given by the Wright Huntington players at the Auditorium theatre all next week, was written by Henry Hamilton, one of the foremost English playwrights. It ran for one year at the Princess Theatre in London, and for a longer period at Wallack’s in New York…the scenery has been painted by Boyd. P. Joy” (8 March 1913, page 6). The scenes were laid in Scotland and Ireland, providing ample opportunity for beautiful stage compositions.

At the age of 41, Joy married Florence E. Fogerty (sometimes spelled Fogarty) in St. Paul, Minnesota, on Dec. 15, 1914. The 1915 St. Paul directory lists Boyd as now working as an artist at the Schubert Theatre. Joy and his wife resided at from 159 W. Summit Ave. Joy’s future business partner, Gerald V. Cannon, first appears in the Minneapolis city directory in 1915, living at 4144 38th Ave S. in Minneapolis. Although listed as an artist, he is not linked with any particular company. It is likely that both Joy and Cannon are sporadically working for the Twin City Scenic Co. at this time. Their combined experience might prompt them to go into business for themselves, opening Joy & Cannon in St. Paul.

In 1916, Joy & Cannon first appear as a scenic studio in the St. Paul Directory. Their address is listed as 378 S. Wabasha, an address will not change over the next six years. The 1917 St. Paul City Directories list Joy as residing at 128 E. Winifred and working at Joy & Cannon Scenic Co. Gerald V. Cannon is also listed in the city directory and associated with the firm, residing in Minneapolis.

Joy & Cannon stencil on the back of a roll drop at the Historic Triune Masonic Lodge in St. Paul, Minnesota. Boyd P. Joy was a Mason.
Joy & Cannon Scenic Co. paint bridge. Image from an undated Joy & Cannon catalog, owned by the Victor J. Hubal family.
Image from an undated Joy & Cannon catalog, owned by the Victor J. Hubal family.
Image from an undated Joy & Cannon catalog, owned by the Victor J. Hubal family.
Image from an undated Joy & Cannon catalog, owned by the Victor J. Hubal family.

By 1918, Joy was working on a project in South Dakota for the Sioux Falls Coliseum. The “Argus Leader” would later recall, “Thirteen years ago, Boyd P. Joy in the employ of a Minneapolis Scenic Studio, was busy at the new Sioux Falls coliseum, painting the scenery and curtains for the stage which had been erected of plank laid on horses….for thirteen years, the scenery which Mr. Joy built and painted has been in use.”

There seems to have been a split between Joy and Cannon that same year. In 1918, Joy is now listed as a scenic artist at the Schubert Theatre with his residence on 217 N. Cretin Street.  First of all, Cannon begins working for the military and serves during WWI. In 1918, Cannon is listed in the St. Paul city directory as the manager of “G. V. Cannon Scenic Co.,” residing at 351 Hope in St. Paul. Joy & Cannon appear to temporarily vanish; yet the firm will reappear in later directories during the 1920s. This is very perplexing, especially since Joy moved to South Dakota in 1919 and was listed as a scenic artist in the Sioux Falls Directory. In Sioux Falls, he is working for the Universal Supply Co. and living at 918 S. Duluth Ave.

By 1920, Joy returns to Minnesota city directories, now listed as the manager of Universal Scenic Studio and residing at 45 S. Lexington Ave, St. Paul, Minnesota. Two years later, Joy is listed as the president of Universal Scenic Studio, still living on Lexington in St. Paul. That year, however, the Joy & Cannon Scenic Co. and Universal Scenic Studio are BOTH advertised in the 1922-1923 Film Yearbook.  Joy continues to be listed with Universal until 1925. The only thing that changes is his home address, now at 1325 Grand Ave. The address of Universal Scenic Studios is 329 Van Slyke Ct. in the St. Paul Directory.

By 1928, Joy moves again, this time to Milwaukee where he established Universal Scenic Studio, Inc. He is still listed as the president of the company, living at 436 44th Street in apt. 33. The 1930 US Census confirms that Joy was still living in Milwaukee and was employed as a manufacturer of stage scenery. The story doesn’t end here, as I now want to look at what Cannon’s career as a scenic artist and studio founder.

Universal Scenic Studio stencil on the back of a drop delivered to Le Centre, Minnesota.

To be continued…

Tales from a Scenic Artist and Scholar. Part 797 – Victor J. Hubal and the Joy & Cannon Scenic Studio in St. Paul, MN

Victor J. Hubal (1888-1872) was a scenic artists and member of United Scenic Artists Local 350. He worked as a Chicago-based scenic artist during the early twentieth century before moving to Minnesota. In 1912, he was working at Sosman & Landis where he likely received most of his scenic art training.

Hubal worked for at least three Minnesota-based scenic studios during his career in the “Land of 10,000 Lakes” – Twin City Scenic Co. (Minneapolis), Joy & Cannon Scenic Co. (St. Paul) and Universal Scenic Studio (St. Paul). In terms of the Twin City Scenic Co., many of the stage designs are now part of the Performing Arts Collection at the University of Minnesota Libraries, including on identified as Hubal’s. Lance Brockman curated the 1987 University Art Museum exhibit “Popular Entertainment 1895-1925: The Twin City Scenic Collection.” It is a wonderful resource with essays by several people that look at multiple aspects of popular entertainment and the painted aesthetic. The catalogue is still available through Amazon.com and other used bookstore cites. I strongly encourage anyone interested in theatre history or scenic art to add this book to your collection. Here is link to a few used copies on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/gp/offer-listing/0938713019/ref=dp_olp_used?ie=UTF8&condition=used

Design by Victor J. Hubal in the Twin City Scenic Co. Collection at the University of Minnesota Performing Arts Archives.

The other two Minnesota-based studios that Hubal worked for are less known.  I’ll start with the obscure and short-lived firm, Joy & Cannon Scenic Co. of St. Paul. I have encountered this particular studio a few times over the past five years and the history of each studio founder is quite fascinating.

While researching Hubal, I discovered his WWI draft registration.  He listed his occupation as a “scenic artist” and in regard to his employment status the draft card noted “not employed at present.” However, there was one sentence scribbled below this entry that caught my eye – “Joy & Cannon Scenic Co. in St. Paul.”

Advertisement for Joy & Cannon Scenic Co. in Joy & Cannon in the Opera House reporter, 1916, page 5

Here is the tale of why that studio name was so familiar to me, as it is one more link in the chain of American theatre history that circles back to Masonic scenery.

In 2015, I reconnected with the current steward of St. Paul’s Historic Triune Lodge Building, Kit Cusick. Cusick has tirelessly worked on the preserviation of this building for quite some time. I visited the Triune Lodge building while working as the Curatorial Director for the Minnesota Masonic Heritage Center. My trip was to take pictures of a specific lodge room stencil for possible use at the Heritage Center. I first encountered the lodge room stencil when working on the 1996 touring exhibit, “Theatre of the Fraternity: Staging the Ritual Space of the Scottish Rite, 1896-1929.” My 2015 recommendation to replicate and use the stencil fizzled like many other things in Bloomington, and although my relationship with the Minnesota Masonic Charities ended, my relationship with Cusick did not. During another trip Triune Lodge, I looked at the stage area and encountered a Masonic roll drop with a  Joy & Cannon stencil. Coincidentally, my discovery was 100 years after Hubal listed the studio on his draft card.

Stencil in Triune Lodge Room
Historic Triune Lodge in St. Paul, Minnesota

“Joy & Cannon Scenic Co.  Metropolitan Opera House, St. Paul, Minn” was stenciled on the back of a picture sheet in the lodge room. This suggests that Joy & Cannon were renting the paint frame at the Metropolitan Opera House, and using that space as their studio.

Triune Lodge picture sheet stencil – Joy & Cannon Scenic Co.

The lodge’s picture sheet included a white center for projections that was circular in shape.  Vaudeville houses, lodge rooms, social halls and early cinemas used similar designs before defaulting to solely white screens. A comparable picture sheet was installed at the Minneapolis Scottish Rite Theater for glass slide projections during degree work. For projections and early films, vibrantly painted draperies, frames and architectural ornamentation surrounded the white center. One way to brighten up a black and white film, especially when the general public is used to colorful scenic illusion on the stage!

Joy & Cannon picture sheet at Triune Lodge, St. Paul, MN
Twin City Scenic Co. picture sheet at the Minneapolis Scottish Rite

Being completely unfamiliar with the history of Joy & Cannon, I immediately emailed Lance Brockman. On January 16, 2018 he responded: “This is (Boyd) Joy and Cannon Studios.  There were as many as 5-6 at one time in the Twin Cities (teens and twenties).  I first learned about them from Vic Hubal’s materials that his son shared with me.  There was a catalog amongst his memorial stuff.  As I was told by Bill Brown [Twin City Scenic Co.] that most of the studios were start-ups from disgruntled employees.  They would strike out on their own and come back once they had lost sufficient money.  Twin City Scenic Co. would intentionally bid projects under cost just to achieve those results.”  

The paint bridge for Joy & Cannon Scenic Co. pictured in their catalog.

I filed this little bit of studio information away and went on my merry way.  Brockman’s response gave me a few markers when combing through various databases online this week. First of all, having a visual and detail-oriented memory is an asset – except when it comes to looking for my car keys or purse where I seem to forget all pertinent details. However, once in a while that cartoon lamp lights up over my head lights up over my head. That happened when I saw “Joy & Cannon” on the draft card for Hubal.

Joy & Cannon was a scenic studio that appeared during 1916 and had a sporadic existence, as the founders filtered in an out of a few business entities and projects during the First World War.

Joy & Cannon was still being advertised in the Film Yearbook of 1922-1923, which surprised me, after looking at dozens of city directories and cross checking the employment of the two founders. By this time, Cannon was known for his camouflage painting for the United States Marine Crops. And Joy was president of Universal Scenic Studio.

During the second and third decades of the twentieth century scenic studios popped up like daisies across the country. It is hard to convey the scope of painted illusion produced for a variety of entertainments at the time, or those who founded scenic studios.

Here is a list of scenic studios listed in the 1922-1923 Film Yearbook: Acme Scenic Artists Studios (Chicago), Armbruster and Sons (Columbus), Atlanta Scenic Co. (Atlanta), Baker & Lockwood (Kansas City), J. H. Beaumont Velvet Scenery Studios (Kansas City), The Wm. Beck & Sons Co. (Cincinnati), Wm. Bradley Studios (NYC), Wm. Campf Studio (NYC), Cox Scene Painting Studio (Philadelphia), Geo. Davis Scenic Studio, (Philadelphia), Enkeboll Art Co. (Omaha), Excelsior Studios & Theatre Supply Co. (Kalamazoo), Fabric Studios (Chicago), Fetters & Fisher (Philadelphia), Fredericks Scenic Studio (NYC),  Gates and Morang (NYC), Hamilton Studios (NYC), D. C. Humphreys Co. (Philadelphia),  Irwin & Sparks Scenic Studio (Philadelphia), Joy & Cannon Scenic Studio (St. Paul), Kahn & Bowman (NYC), Kansas City Scenic Co. (Kansas City), King Scenic Co. (Dallas), J. B. La Touche (Clearfield, Iowa), Lee Lash Studios (NYC), Law Scenic Studios (NYC), Jos. P. McHugh & Son (NYC), Manhattan Scenic Studios (NYC), Herbert L. Messmore Co. (NYC), Murray Hill Scenic Studios (NYC), New York Studios (NYC), Frank Platzer Studio (NYC), Theo. Reising & Co. (NYC), St. Louis Float & Scenic Co. (St. Louis), Schells Scenic Studio (Columbus), Jno. A. Servas Studio (Rochester, NY), D. Sheek & Co. (Cleveland), Star Scenic Studio, Inc. (Omaha), O.L. Story Scenic Studio (Boston), Allan J. Turner Studio (NYC), Twin City Scenic Co. (Minneapolis). Universal Scenic Artists Studios (Chicago), Werbe Scenic Studio (Kansas City), and Young Bros. (NYC).

This list is only a small portion of studios in the United States during the early 1920s, yet paints a picture of how rapidly the industry was growing in the post-WWI period. Consider that some the major studios were not even mentioned in the Film Yearbook of 1922-1923, such as Toomey & Volland (St. Louis) or Sosman & Landis (Chicago). These well-known giants of the industry had enjoyed a secure position for decades of experience and a dedicated clientele. When they came into existence, there was more work than providers and the competition was friendly. The balance begins to shift by the 1920s, even before the great depression. In many cases, disgruntled employees started their own studio, hoping to retain a greater percentage of their profits for their work. Many were short-lived, as their previous employers targeted the same work and were prepared to take a loss. It was a loss they could afford while crushing the new competition.

But there was also a shift in the industry as the demand for painted scenes began to diminish. The call for fabric draperies and settings ushered in a new era. This combined with the popularity of film caused many studios to falter and eventually close. Even the largest scenic studios were not immune to the industry shift. Joy & Cannon Scenic Studio, as well as many other small firms, appeared at a time when they would encounter a series of challenges, most beyond their control. Embracing the new trends and technologies was the only way to weather the storm. As I continue with the life and times of Thomas G. Moses in the pre- and post-WWI era, the company faltered because of their focus on painted scenery and inability to embrace change. As company president, Moses placed all of his bets on the wrong horse.

Tomorrow, I look at the lives of Boyd Phelps Joy and Gerald V. Cannon, scenic artists and founders of Joy & Cannon Scenic Studio.

To be continued…