On November 30, 2022, I received a FB message from Robert Van Dillen, a St. Louis-based scenic artist. He asked if I would consider being guest speaker for an upcoming scenic art event in St. Louis, tentatively scheduled for the beginning of 2023. Van Dillen explained that there was a group of local scenic artists who wanted to see the St. Louis Scottish Rite scenery collection before the building was sold. Unfortunately, the tentative date coincided with my trip to the Galveston Scottish Rite. We looked at a couple of possibilities, and then scheduled the event to coincide with my March trip to USITT.
My last visit to the St. Louis Scottish Rite theatre also coincided with USITT in 2017. This is a remarkable scenery collection delivered by Toomey & Volland, of St. Louis. I spent much of the conference documenting the scenery, stage machinery, and building.
Tomoey & Volland Studio stencil on the back of a Scottish Rite backdrop.
Just prior to the conference, I documented the gridiron with Rick Boychuk and Richard Nix.
High above the St. Louis Scottish Rite stage with Rick Boychuk and Richard Nix in 2017.
One of many photos from my trip to the St. Louis Scottish Rite Theatre in 2017.
On this trip, I arrived at the St. Louis Scottish Rite by 9AM on Sunday morning, March 19, 2023. I was accompanied by my close friend and colleague, Jenny Knott. Alessia Carpoca, Mike Monsos, and Martha (University of Montana – Missoula) soon joined us, as they had an early flight to catch; one that prevented them from staying for the entire presentation. From 9-10:30 a.m., we shifted furniture, set up the power point, and double checked the lines. I wanted to make sure that everything was in working order for my presentation. This also provided Mike, Alessia, and Martha, with the opportunity to see some of the drops before their early departure. I am very grateful to Mike for handling the operating lines during this time!
At 10:30 a.m., I gave a quick power-point presentation to provide some context, placing what we were going to see within the context of American scenic art and theatre history. By “quick” I mean thirty minutes! Then we brought in one scene after another for the next three hours. By 2 p.m. I called it quits, due my impending flight and grumbling stomach. We grabbed a quick bit to eat and then I was on my way to the airport.
The St. Louis Scottish Rite Theatre is a sight to behold. It is a three-thousand-seat auditorium that boasts a 90’-0” wide proscenium opening.
The St. Louis Scottish Rite auditorium. Looking up into the flies at the St. Louis Scottish Rite. Scenery by Toomey & Volland Studios, c. 1923.
The size and scope of this Masonic scenery collection is almost unparalleled, with the McAlester Scottish Rite from 1929 being a major contender. There are 147 line sets, with stage machinery and scenery produced by the Toomey & Volland studio in 1923. There are a few drops that pre-date the building, a couple more that were delivered in later years.
The Scenic Studio where the St. Louis Scottish Rite scenery was painted in 1923.
Sadly, this may be the last time I get to visit and examine this remarkable scenery collection. Like many massive Masonic buildings, it is up for sale. Rumors of a sale had already begun in 2017. This is not surprising, considering a series of obstacles faced by many fraternal organizations; challenges that range from declining membership and insufficient funds to high utility bills and a long-term practice of deferred maintenance. My only hope is that when the building is sold, the scenery is somehow preserved for future generations. This collection really needs to be professionally documented, complete with lights and props, before it disappears.
Many thanks to Rob for organizing this event. I also want to thank his wonderful colleagues who so warmly welcomed me to St. Louis. I am grateful that we were able to share this experience together.
Here are a few pictures from our day at the St. Louis Scottish Rite.
A painted scene at the St. Louis Scottish Rite. Scene by Toomey & Volland Studios, c. 1923.Metallic strips that make the foliage sparkle under stage light.My host, Rob Van Dillen behind a section of theatrical gauze.Scenic artists at the St. Louis Scottish Rite. March 19, 2023.Scene by Toomey & Volland Studios, c. 1923.Changing scenes at the St. Louis Scottish Rite. March 19, 2023.A few of the scenic artists who gathered at the Scottish Rite on March 19, 2023.Scenic Artists at the St. Louis Scottish Rite on March 19, 2023.Painted detail from the carpenter shop scene at the St. Louis Scottish Rite. Landscape backdrop at the St. Louis Scottish Rite. March 19, 2023.Painted detail from a landscape drop at the St. Louis Scottish Rite. March 19, 2023.Painted detail from a landscape drop at the St. Louis Scottish Rite. March 19, 2023.Painted detail from a drop at the St. Louis Scottish Rite. March 19, 2023.The Camp Scene at the St. Louis Scottish Rite. March 19, 2023.Scene by Toomey & Volland Studios, c. 1923.
In January, I was contacted by Diane Nagy, President of the Kimmswick Historical Society. For geographical context, Kimmswick, Missouri, is a very small river town about 26 miles south of St. Louis. The Kimmswick Historical Society had recently acquired a large painting by J. U. Tschudi. Dated 1914, the artist titled the painting, “Early Days on the Mississippi River.” While searching for information about the artist, Nagy stumbled across my post about Tschudi at www.drypigment.net. Tschudi represented the Kansas City Scenic Co. in 1887. This firm was affiliated with the Sosman & Landis Scene Painting Studio in Chicago. The two firms shared projects and artists over the decades, remaining affiliates until the 1920s.
My trip to St. Louis for the United States Institute of Theatre Technology conference this month provided me with an opportunity to examine the Tschudi painting and meet Kimmswick Historical Society members. On March 18, I journeyed south, accompanied by my close friend and colleague, Jenny Knott. Diane Nagy and Nadine Garland provided shuttle service and conversation for the day. We spent most of the afternoon chatting about historical artifacts and the intriguing history of Kimmswick.
Our first stop was to see the oil painting, currently stored at the studio of Irek T. Szelag. Szelag is a Polish immigrant nearing retirement. In fact, this will be his last commission. We were joined at Szelag’s studio by a few other Historical Society members; they were curious to about hear about my knowledge of Tschudi and his work. The decision to preserve Tschudi’s work was hotly contested by half of the ten-member Kimmswick Historical Society Board of Directors, necessitating a tie-breaking vote by the president. Not everyone was keen to spend a large amount of money on this heavily damaged painting.
Painting by J. U. Tschudi at Szelag’s studio on March 18, 2023.
The Kimmswick Historical Society is a small non-profit organization that does not accept State or Federal aid. Their operating budget is obtained through donations and the sale of apple butter. The funding of every Historical Society project is translated into the sale of “jars” and “cars.” “Jars” refers to the sale of apple butter and “cars” refers to the sale of parking spots when thousands of people descend upon this small town of 146 residents for the Apple Butter Festival https://gokimmswick.com/apple-butter-festival-kimmswick/ . Each year, the Historical Society sells approximately 6000 jars of apple butter. Of this amount, 500 jars are still made on site, using a massive copper kettle over an open fire. By the way, each jar of apple butter sells for $6; a fabulous deal, considering the extensive amount of time is takes to prep, cook and can the apples.
The Kimmswick Historical Society stand at the Apple Butter Festival.Apple butter pot on display at the Kimmswick Historical Society.
Back to Tschudi’s artwork…
When I initially examined pictures of Tschudi’s painting, I was struck by his inclusion of a title and painted surround. It looked more like circus banner than an oil painting intended for a residential wall. In fact, it reminded me of early twentieth-century state displays at world fairs or other industrial expositions. Upon close inspection, I notice that the edges of the canvas had been hemmed, like early marketing banners that were intended to advertise a public entertainment. I am positive that this artwork was created to be tacked onto a wall, the side of a building, or fence; advertising some public event or spectacle.
Hemmed edge of the Tschudi painting.Title and painted frame of the Tschudi painting.
After leaving Szelag’s studio, we spent the remainder of the afternoon touring the Kimmswick Historical Society and enjoying a fabulous lunch at the oldest building in town. Designated, “The Old House” this structure was originally built in 1770. The reason for selecting tis particular eating establishment was that Tschudi’s painting once hung in a front room, near a fire place; a fireplace that never vented properly, hence the discoloration of the painting over time.
Wall where the Tschudi painting was once located in the Old House.Sketch of the Old House in Kimmswick, currently on display at the Kimmswick Historical Society.
In addition to lunch, our hosts gifted us Kimmswick Historical Society cookbooks upon our departure. It is one of the more interesting compilations of Midwest and Southern recipes that I have come across in recent year. Yes, the apple butter recipe is included too! Overall, I had a delightful time learning about Kimmswick and its history.
The Kimmswick Historical Society Cookbook includes the recipe for their apple butter.
While sitting in the St. Louis airport on March 19, I began to re-examine the life and career of J. U. Tschudi, searching for possible clues that might lead to the origin of his painting. This quest continued upon my return home. I arrived sick and began a week-long quarantine in the basement, desperately trying to keep my germs to myself. My son’s High School Orchestra was spending the first part of Spring Break in New York City. I really didn’t want him to catch this bug. Fortunately, my self-imposed quarantine provided me with an opportunity to re-examine Tschudi’s life and career. My previous post about Tschudi from 2020 was quite brief, intended as only a side story to my history about the Kansas City Scenic Company. Tschudi was associated with the Kansas City Scenic Co., working alongside B. F. Dunn and C. A. Oldham.
Here is my expanded tale about this fascinating artist and painting.
Like many nineteenth-century American immigrants, the story of Tschudi begins in Europe and ends in the Midwest. His tale could be called “From Switzerland to St. Louis,” was he passed away at 728 South Second Street, only a short walk from the Convention Center that hosted USITT. Both Tschudi and his son worked as scenic artists for the Kansas City Scenic Art Co. during the early Twentieth Century. Combined, they are responsible for hundreds of stage settings delivered throughout the United States between 1880 and 1940.
John Ulrich Tschudi was born on March 22, 1850, in Switzerland. Named after his father, he was the son of Johann Ulrich Tschudy (1822-1886) and Anna Margaretha Egli (1821-). In 1856, the Tschudi family emigrated to the United States with his family. They departed a ship named the Ocean Steed on March 22, 1856 – Tschudy’s 6th birthday. Passengers included John Ulrich Tschudy (34 yrs.), wife Ann Mary (35 yrs.), and children Cath (10 yrs.), Valentin (8 yrs.), Margaretha (7 yrs.), John M. (6 yrs.), Walter (4 yrs.), Tobias (11 mths.). Ann Mary’s father, W. Egli (59 yrs.) also sailed on the same ship. They arrived in the US on July 30, 1856, and soon settled in Burlington, Iowa. Two other Tschudy children were born after moving to Iowa- Minnie (b. 1856) and Lily (b. 1859).
I am going to take a moment to discuss historical records and reported names for John Ulrich Tschudi Sr. and John Ulrich Tschudi Jr. First of all, the family used both Tschudy and Tschudi as their surname in city directories, public records, and newspaper articles. This shift primarily occurred in the 1870s. For the purpose of this post, I will use both.
Secondly, the “U” for Ulrich was often misrepresented as an M, W, A, or even H. This is understandable when you begin to examine how a handwritten cursive capital U can look like other letters, especially in passenger lists and census reports.
To further muddy the waters, there was another Swiss emigrant named John Ulrich Tschudi/Tschudy (1828-1901) who settled in Minnesota. He is a completely different individual who has greatly confused many family genealogists. Minnesota Tschudi lived his life as a farmer, while the main characters of my story – John Ulrich Tschudi Sr. (1822-1886) and John Ulrich Tschudi Jr. (1850-1921) – who worked as a German Presbyterian Church pastor and scenic artist, respectively. With this little bit of information, here is the tale of scenic artist J. U. Tschudi.
In later years, Tschudi Jr. recounted that the Tschudi family only stayed in Burlington for two years before relocating to Memphis, Tennessee, where “he learned his business under the tutelage of his father, who was also an artist.” I can neither confirm nor disprove this statement, as evaded public record until the onset of the Civil War.
By 1861, Tschudi Sr. enlisted in the Union Army. Tschudi Sr. is listed in the “US Adjutant General Military Records, 1631-1976,” available at ancestry.com. The 1864-1864 report lists “John Ulrich Tschudy” of Burlington, Iowa, as a Private in Co. G. of the 57th Illinois Infantry. At the age of 38, he entered into military service on August 26, 1861. Co. G. rendezvoused in Chicago and was quartered at Camp Douglas. Tschudi Jr. was too young to enlist; the official enlistment age was 18 yrs. old. Again, to make things even more confusing, Minnesota Tschudi also fought in the Civil War (Minnesota Infantry, 2nd Regiment).
By 1867, the Tschudy family was living in Dubuque, Iowa. Between 1867 and 1869, Tschudi Sr. is listed as a student at the German Seminary. After completing his studies in Dubuque, In 1867, Tschudi Jr. is listed as a student. It is in Dubuque that Tschudi Jr. meets his future wife, Marguerite Merkes (1850-1931). Merkes is exactly the same age as, Tschudi Jr., was born on March 23, 1850, in Diekirch Luxembourg. Merkes was the daughter of Jean Pierre Merckes/John Peter Merkes (1811-1861) and Clara L. Abend/Abendt (1817-1895). The Merkes family emigrated from Luxembourg to Dubuque, Iowa in 1859, with John Peter Merkes passing in 1864. His widow, Clara Abendt Merkes, remarried in 1864. Her second husband was Michael Fohrman (1811-1894), also an emigrant from Luxembourg.
In 1867, Clara’s 17-yrs. old daughter, Marguerite Merkes, becomes pregnant. As an unwed mother, Marguerite is removed to Chicago where she waits for the impending arrival of her first born. On August 1, 1868, Marguerite gives birth to a son whom she names John, after the baby’s father John Ulrich Tschudi, Jr. It is important to note that the actual birth year of baby John’s birthdate vacillates over the years, ranging from 1867-1869.
Two things happen at this point; decisions that were very characteristic when a child was born out of wedlock. First, the baby is born, but then raised by a grandparent. In this case, baby John returned to Dubuque where he was raised by his maternal grandmother, Clara Abendt Merkes Forman, and his, maternal step-grandfather, Michael Fohrman. John Merkes name instantly becomes John J. Fohrman, and he is clearly listed as the son of Michael and Clara Fohrman. It is only in Michael Fohrman’s will that John J. Fohrman is listed as an “adopted son.” Despite the eventual marriage of John’s parents, Marguerite Merkes and John Ulrich Tschudi Jr., their son is never returned to their care.
In the meantime, Tschudi Sr. completes his training at the Germany Seminary in Dubuque and answers his first call in Platteville, Wisconsin (1870),where he relocates with his wife and four daughters (Margaretha, Lucy, Minnie, and Lillie). Tschudi Jr. and Marguerite remain in Iowa. In 1869, Tschudi Jr.’s occupation was listed as “cigar maker” in the Dubuque Directory; this was when he was living with his father at “Couler av bet Nineteenth and Twentieth.”
By 1872, Tschudi Sr, answers a call to ministry in Memphis, Tennessee. During this entire time, Rev. J. U. Tschudi is associated with the German Presbyterian Church. He is repeatedly listed in the newspapers. During this period, Memphis struggles with yellow fever, losing thousands of its citizens to five major outbreaks. On Oct 15, 1873, “The Central Presbyterian” of Richmond, VA, reported, “Another Bereavement – Rev. J. A. Tschudy, pastor of the German Presbyterian church in Memphis, lost his son, Walter, Oct. 6th, in his 23rd year of his age, of yellow fever” (page 2). This was part of the fourth Yellow fever epidemic in Memphis, where 2500 people passed away between Aug and Oct of that year. At the time it constituted the largest yellow fever outbreak in any inland city. A few months later, the Tschudi family is able to celebrate the marriage of Margaretha Tschudi to minister, Henry A. Grentzenberg. I have yet to locate any mention of Tschudi J. in Memphis during this time. Rev. J. U. Tschudi is last mentioned in Memphis newspapers during 1878. At the time, he was associated with the First German Presbyterian Church, located on the corner of Venice and DeSoto streets. I have yet to uncover any information that links Tschudi Jr. to Memphis. Although he likely traveled throughout the country painting scenery, he married and celebrated the birth of two children in Iowa between 1871 and 1875.
In later years, Tschudi Jr. suggested an alternative story, explaining that from 1868 to 1873 he studied art in Europe. This is highly suspect, especially since he married Marguerite Merkes in Dubuque, Iowa in October 1871 and began raising a family in Iowa by 1873. Daughter Lucy was born in the spring of 1873, with her younger sister, Minnie Lillian, arriving in the spring of 1875. Later newspaper articles about Tschudi Jr. purported, “After his school days he studied with his father and assisted him with his work and soon developed such an artistic taste in landscape painting that the father concluded in 1868 to send him back to France to finish his studies. ‘After five years,’ says Mr. Tschudi, ’I returned to America and took a fancy to large work and consequently went to theatrical scene painting, and have since that time worked in many of the finest theaters both in this country and abroad.” I have yet to locate any information that suggests his father ever worked as an artist, but you never know.
Here is what I have tracked down about Tschudi Jr.’s scenic art career; a tale compiled from city directories, historical records, and newspaper headlines.
By the late 1870s, Tschudi begins working with Cincinnati fresco artist, William Theodore Blomberg (1829-1909). Tschudi Jr. has several relations in Cincinnati, including his older sister Margaretha (Margaretha Tschudy Grentzenberg). In 1880, Tschudi and Blomberg head to Kansas, where they work as itinerant artists throughout the region that year. Blomberg returns to Cincinnati in 1881, with Tschudi remaining in Kansas.
The first line of Tschudi’s biographical listing entry in “Cutler’s History of Kansas” is “JOHN U. TSCHUDI, fresco and scenic artist, came to Kansas in July 1880.” He arrived a bit earlier than that as Tschudi is mentioned in a Kansas newspaper advertisement that June. On June 16, 1880, the “Augusta Republican” of Augusta, Kansas, reported, “Messrs. Tschudi & Blomberg, painters and frescoers are on hand according to promise and ready to do any kind of fancy work in their line at reasonable rates. Call and leave your orders” (page 3).
Tschudi initially settled in Wichita, before relocating to Emporia. His initial tie to Wichita was to the newly constructed opera house; he and Blomberg were credited with the scenery, as well as their ties to Cincinnati. They were mentioned in letter published in the “McPherson Republican” on August 12, 1880:
“Elk Falls Letter.
Elk Falls, August 9th, 1880.
Editors Republican:- Since leaving McPherson two weeks ago we have taken in the counties of Marion, Butler, Sedgewick, Cowley, Sumner, and now we are now in Elk. From Florence we ran down the Eldorado Branch to Eldorado, the county seat of Butler, and from thence to Augusta by stage. In this town, situated on the St. Louis & San Fransico line to Wichita, we were somewhat surprised to find a regular opera hall, and our surprise was somewhat increased in visiting the hall, to find everything first class. In the construction of the stage, etc., Mr. Israel Zimmerman, the stage carpenter proved himself to be a master of his profession. Messrs. Tschudi & Blomburg, the scenic artists, whose headquarters are at Cincinnati, Ohio, were completing the advertising drop curtain when we were there. They will have one forest scene, six wings, one street scene, one rustic kitchen scene, four wings; one garden and landscape scene, two wings; one prison scene, four wings, and one scenic drop curtain. The stage is arched and the arch is frescoed. The work when done will give them an opera hall to be envied by many towns double their population…” (page 2).
On October 16, 1880, the “Cowley County Monitor” of Winfield, Kansas, reported, Messrs. Tschudi & Blomberg, the fresco artists, are at work on M. L. Robinson’s residence. They also have engagements with J. C. Fuller and M. L. Read. Our citizens who want fresco work cannot do better than secure these gentlemen” (page 3).
On Nov. 25, “The Sumner County Press” of Wellington, Kansas, reported, “Messrs. Tschudi & Blomberg, the artists who did scene painting and fresco work for the opera hall here, also did some fresco paintings on the dwellings of M. L. Reed, S. H. Myton and M. L. Robinson. They have now gone to Wellington to fresco the hall of the PRESS building. On their return they will commence work on Mr. Fulton’s fine dwelling. If the Presbyterians and the Methodists would have their churches frescoed in first class style it would be worth bragging about. Tschudi and Blomberg have done the best work in the State.- Winfield Monitor”(page 3).
Despite their success, Blimberg returned to Cincinnati in 1881, with Tschudi settling in Wichita. It remains unclear as to when Tschudi’s family joined him in Kansas. However, in 1881, Tschudi was living in Wichita. On Oct. 31, 1881, “The Daily Leader” of Wichita reported, “John W. Tschudy, the artist of Wichita, went to Emporia yesterday to paint the scenery in the new Opera House in that town” (page 4). A month later, his ties to Cincinnati were mentioned in an Emporia newspaper. On Nov. 29, 1881, the “Emporia Daily News” reported, “J. W. Tschudi, a scenic artist of much merit from Cincinnati, Ohio, is superintending the painting of the scenery for the Whitley Opera House” (page 4).
Tschudi soon partnered with stage carpenter, J. W. Morris, to deliver scenery and stage machinery to the Whitley Opera House. On Dec. 1, 1881, “The Emporia Ledger” reported “Messrs. John W. Tschudi, scenic painter, and J. W. Morris, stage carpenter, the gentlemen who have the contract to furnish and fit the scenery and stage trappings of the Whitley Opera House, commenced work yesterday. They will put in a complete set of scenes and all the latest improvements in stage equipment. They say they find everything about the house in excellent shape for their work, and that they will be able to compete their contract in six or seven weeks. Their work will be so well advanced by the first of January that the house may be used at that time, of desired” (page 3). That same day, the “Emporia Weekly News” reported, “J. W. Tschudi, a scenic artist of much merit from Cincinnati, Ohio, is superintending the painting of the scenery for the Whitley opera house” (page 3). Tschudi was repeatedly mentioned in Emporia newspapers.
Tschudi continued to work in Emporia. On Jan. 26, 1882, “The Emporia Weekly News” reported that Tschudi was painting scenery for Ed White’s touring production of ‘Fantanitza,’ scheduled to visit Emporia in March, detailing, “He left an order with Mr. Tschudi, the scenic artist who has been employed for some weeks past at the Whitely opera house, for some scenery to be used in bringing out the grand illumination tableau in ‘Fantanitza” The article also mentioned Tschudi’s current work at the Whitley reporting, “There is also a water main behind the drop curtain on the stage with sufficient hose attached to reach over the flys. The scenery has been done by that skillful and well-known artist, John Tcheudy of Switzerland, and is a marvel of beauty…The scenery is sized with fireproof sizing and cannot be kindled into a blaze…” Tschudi’s work at the Whitley certainly boosted his career. On Feb 2. 1882, “The Emporia Weekly News” reported “The stage, one of the best in the west, is 30-x60 feet and is furnished with all the accessories of a metropolitan theatre. These include a variety of excellent scenery suitable for the preparation of all classes of drama; complete and secured appliances for shifting lights, and an exquisite drop curtain representing a charming scene on the Rhine, painted by Mr. Tshudi, one of the most talented scenic artists in the country” (page 3).
The Whitley Opera House in Emporia, Kansas, featured scenery by J. U. Tschudi and W. T. Blomberg.An interior view of the Whitley Opera House in Emporia, Kansas, c, 1898.
Tschudi’s success in Emporia soon prompted him to relocate there from Wichita. Initially, he set up a studio at the Whitley Opera House. On March 22 and 23, 1882, “The Evening News” in Emporia announced, “You will find John W. Tschudi at the Whitley opera house ready to do all kinds of house painting, kalsomining, frescoe decorating, plain and fancy sign writing, etc. First-class work at reasonable rates, guaranteed” (page 4). He continued to place one advertisement after another in local papers, securing a variety of local projects that ranged from private residences to commercial signs. On April 8, 1882, the “Emporia Daily News” reported, “Two of the handsomest signs in town were placed in position this morning at the entrance of Robert Jeff’s tobacco ad cigar emporium on Commercial street. They were painted by Mr. Tschudi, the scenic artist at the Whitley opera house and cannot fail to attract attention” (page 4). On April 20, 1882, The Weekly News-Democrat” reported, “A very handsome altar recently completed by the Roberts Brothers has been placed in the upper room of the Franciscan convent, which is used at present as a place of worship for the congregation. The painting, which is beautiful and highly artistic, was done by John Tschudi, scenic artist at the Whitley opera house.” (page 4).
Tschudi landed so many projects at this time, that it became necessary to hire an assistant. On April 15, 1882, “The Evening News” (page 4) reported, “W. S. Walborn, a sign painter, lately of Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, is assisting Mr. Tschudi, the scenic artist at the Whitely Opera House” (page 3). This announcement was also published on April 20, 1882, in “The Emporia Weekly News.” In later years, both Tschudi and Walborn worked as scenic artists as the Kansas City Scenic Co.
Tschudi’s work was drawing other prospective theatre proprietors to Wichita to see his work. . On April 22, 1882, and on April 27, 1882, “The Emporia Weekly News” reported, “Friday evening we had a pleasant call from Mr. Samuel Smith and a Mr. A. W. Barker, both of Ottawa, Kansas. These gentlemen were in the city for the purpose of viewing the Whitley Opera house, more particularly the stage appointments and scenery. Last evening the opera house was lighted, and they were shown through it, and expressed themselves as much pleased with the result of their inspection. The new opera house in Ottawa is about completed, and it was with a view to gaining some points as to scenery, etc., that these gentlemen visited Emporia. They were greatly pleased with the Whitley opera house stage scenery, and it is not unlikely that Mr. Tschudi, the artist, will secure a contract of the same at Ottawa” (page 3).
All the while, Tschudi continued to run a series of advertisements in local newspapers. Here are a few of note:
On July 27, 1882, the “Emporia Daily News” announced, “John Tschudi, the Whitley opera house scenic artist, sent a number of ornamental signs to Colorado yesterday.”
On July 29, 1882, Tschudi’s advertisement in the “Emporia Daily News” stated, “Signs! Signs! —In Japanese, East Lake, Queen Anne, and Oriental styles by Tschudi, the artist. Leave orders at Moore’s drug store.”
By summer, Tschudi had customers placing orders at Moore’s Drug Store. An advertisement in the “Emporia Daily News” on July 29, 1882, announced “Let the work speak for itself,” is my motto, Tschudi, Artist, Fresco Decorator, Ornamental Painter, and Sign Writer. Leave orders at Moore’s Drug Store” and “Why not have a neat sign when it costs you no more than a poor one? Tschudi, the artist, can guarantee you work and figures that cannot be beat. Leave orders at Moore’s Drug Store” (page 4). Tschudi’s ads ran continuously until October 1882.
On Aug. 15, 1882, and the “Emporia Daily News” reported, “Why not have a neat sign when it costs you no more than a poor one? Tschudi, the artist, can guarantee you work and figures that cannot be beat. Leave orders at Moore’s drug store” (page 4).
His association with Moore’s drug store, meant that Tschudi needed someone to take orders, while he traveled for work. This ensured a constant stream of income when he returned from out-of-town projects. On Oct 18, 1882, “The Evening News” reported, “John Tschudi, the scenic artist, returned to-day from Wellington, where he has been painting the scenery for the new opera house at that place” (page 1). Despite his absences, Tschudi would advertise, “Remember that Tschudi, the artist, is still here, and will do you the highest and latest artistic style, and at bottom figures. Leave orders at Moore’s drug store” (Emporia Daily News, Oct 18, 1882, page 4). On Dec 21, 1882, “The Emporia Weekly News” reported, “Tschudi has made a large transparent street sign which will be placed in position soon and bear the letters ‘Ice cream and oysters.’ The same artist prepared the beautiful parlor screen upon whose surface are painted six different attractive designs in oil” (page 3).
By 1883, Tschudi was included in the Emporia Directory. Interestingly, his listing suggests pervious work in Tennessee, and not Wichita or Cincinnati: “Tschudi, John U., fr Tenn., ornamental frescoe scenic painting, and sign writer, shop 197 Commercial st, res same.” His wife was also listed in the directory at the same address. Marguerite began going by Margaret.
Painting projects for 1883 included G. T. Carlton’s Billiard Hall and Fithian’s Ice wagon in Emporia. On Feb 20, 1883, “The Evening News” reported, “Mr. G. T. Carlton to-day opened to the public his handsome new billiard parlor in the Soden building on Fifth Avenue. Tschudi. The artist has been busy for several weeks past frescoing the walls of the room and the result of his skillful hand is seen in the excellent effects he has produced…” (page 4).
On April 19, 1883, the “Emporia Weekly News” reported “A Thing of Beauty. Fithian’s ice wagon made its first trip for the season Thursday, and it attracted as much attention as a circus chariot as it rolled along the street resplendent in brilliant colors and decorations by the brush of Tschudi, the scenic artist. The arctic sketches on the sides are excellent works of art, and it will be refreshing to even look at them when the mercury begins to crawl up into the sky parlor of thermometer” (page 1).
However, he continued to paint stage scenery for a variety of venues throughout the region. On March 22, 1883, “The Emporia Weekly News” reported, “John Tschudi has received an order to paint a set of scenes for the Amateur Dramatic club of Newton” (page 4).
On May 17, 1883, “The Weekly News-Democrat” reported on the dedication of the Welsh Congregational Church on Merchants Street” (page 1). Of the new auditorium, the article reported that sections of ornamental plaster work were “artistically frescoed by Tschudi, the scenic artist, whose happy combination of complimentary colors and agreeable shades proclaim him an artist of superior merit…”
On October 19, 1883, the “Iola Register” reported, “Mr. J. N. Tschudi has been at work in the opera house all week and has made quite a change there. In addition to the business cards which adorn the front of the stage, Mr. Tschudi has been painting a new and elegant drop curtains which he expects to have ready by Saturday night. He has also made new and larger wings, to correspond with each scene, and before he leaves will paint the woodwork on the front of the stage. He expects to finish his work sometime next week, and the opera house will certainly ne much handsomer for his having been there” (page 5).
On Dec. 1, 1883, “The Humboldt Union” of Humboldt, Kansas, credited Tschudi with delivering scenery to the Germania Hall. The article reported, “The scenery [described in detail] and the arch of the stage is handsomely decorated. The artist, John W. Tschudi, of Kansas City, has performed his work in first class style” (page 3).
As in the past, Tschudi was not working alone, nor was he simply hiring local amateurs. A variety of skilled personalities were working for Tschudi in Emporia, including Charles Stebbins. On May 2, 1883, “Emporia Daily News” and “Evening News” reported, “Charles Stebbins, who is employed by Tschudi, the artist and painter, has returned from Hartford, Michigan, where he recently fell heir to a legacy of $1,000” (page 1).
Tschudi began to secure an abundance of scenic work for stages throughout Kansas. On Jan 25, 1884, “The Weekly Kansas” of Independence reported, “Of all the improvements made during the past year in Independence there are none in which so much interest is felt as in the Opera House block erected by Mr. Payne….The stage is large and commodious, it being 24×66 feet, with four dressing rooms, and the footlights are fixed with a lever so they can be shut off or put in place at will. It will be supplied with good scenery. Mr. John Tschudi. The artist, is now here for that purpose. He comes highly recommended as a scenic painter. There will be thirteen sets of scenes and fifteen set scenes” (page 4). While working on a theater project, however, Tschudi would land a variety of other painting projects. Such was the case in Chanute, Kansas. On Aug. 28, 1884, the “Chanute Blade” of Chanute, Kansas reported, “The Chanute Bank is being neatly frescoed by John U. Tschudi, and will be one of the nicest finished rooms in the city when completed” (page 3).
Tschudi’s comings and goings were announced in a variety of small-town newspapers, making it easy to trace his travels. For example, On Oct. 16, 1884, “The Chanute Blade” reported, “John U. Tschudi went to Kansas City last Tuesday, to paint some new scenery and drop curtains at Kansas City. He painted two very beautiful scenes for Williams’ Hall in this city, last week. He will return here in about two weeks to paint the scenes and drop curtain for the new opera house now being erected here” (page 3). Tschudi was also working on the new stage setting for an opera house in Red Cloud, Nebraska. On October 16, 1885, the “Webster County Argus” of Red Cloud reported, “The proprietors of the opera house expect to have the same opened on Monday, the 26th inst. A good dramatic company has been engaged for the occasion. The house will be seated with six hundred chairs. Prof. Tschudi, the scenic artist, with a force of carpenters in making and placing the scenery, which will consist of eight complete settings, besides a handsome drop curtain.”
Sometime between the fall of 1885 and 1886, Tschudi moved to Kansas City, By 1887, he was associated with the Kansas City Scenic Co. The firm’s offices were located in the Gillis Opera House.
The Gillis Opera House in Kansas City, Missouri.A photograph of the Gillis opera House in Kansas City, Missouri.
This is where it gets interesting, and a little confusing. Sosman & Landis Scenic Studio outfitted the Gillis, with L. L. Graham and W. P. Davis working as the scenic artists on the project, while representing the firm. Sosman & Landis. Sosman & Landis opened a branch office in Kansas City in 1884; it was headed by L. L. Graham. At the same time, Graham and Davis also operated a studio, known as Graham & Davis, frequently working as subcontractors for Sosman & Landis. Sosman & Landis’ work for the Gillis was well-known and mentioned in a variety of newspapers. For example, on April 21, 1887, “The Times” of Clay Center, Kansas, reported that Sosman & Landis had “fitted the Gillis Opera House, Kansas City, and the Grand at Topeka.” Graham’s Studio in Kansas City, the Kansas City Scenic Co. and Sosman & Landis’ scenic studio were not directly competing in the region, they were divvying up work and sharing artists. Even in 1888, Dunn was listed as not only a scenic artist at Graham’s Studio, but also on staff at the Kansas City Scenic Studio. By 1890, an new iteration of the Kansas City Scenic Co. opened, solely under the management of Dunn and J. C. Bronaugh. On July 13, 1891, the Kansas Patron commented that Bronaugh was “the traveling member of the Kansas City Scenic Co.” Bronaugh secured the contracts and Dunn painted the scenery. This new iteration of the firm still maintained a close business alliance with the Sosman & Landis until the 1920s.
In 1887, Kansas City Scenic Co. advertisements list J. U. Tschudi, B. F. Dunn, C. A. Oldham and C. J. Lorella. On March 22, 1887, the “Wichita Star” reported “A reporter was shown the number of samples from scenic-artist work from the brush of Kansas City Scenic-Artist company, in which company figures, as an artist, Mr. J. W. Tschudi, formerly of the city. The work is artistic and ranges throughout the entire term of scenic work. Landscapes, rocky passes, woods, streets, palaces, parlors, chambers, kitchens, hovels – in fact every known term of scenic effects were painted in the highest style of art. The JOURNAL congratulates Mr. Tschudi on the excellent work of the firm in which his brush is prominent” (page 4).
On June 16, 1887, “The Little River Monitor” of Little River, Kansas, reported, “The carpenters’ work on the new opera hall is going on at a lively rate, Canfield & Co. are doing the work in good shape. Messrs. Tschudi, Dunn and Oldham, of the Kansas City Scenic company, are painting a set of scenes for the hall, and are doing a fine job.” On June 18, 1887, “The Little River Monitor” reported, “Messrs. Tschudi Dunn and Oldham, of the Kansas City Scenic company, are painting a set of scenes for the hall, and are doing a fine job. The mammoth drop curtain is a beauty. It is ornamented with the business cards of our merchants and others and will be first class in every particular.”
On May 20, 1887, “The Lyons Daily Democrat” in Lyons, Kansas, reported, “Mess. Tschudi, Dunn, and Oldham, scenic artists from Kansas City, are preparing a very fine new drop curtain for Tom’s Butler’s Opera House. Tom very properly thinks the public would be pleased to have a brand new curtain to gaze at between acts. The gentlemen represent a firm of scenic artists who are furnishing many of the finest Opera Houses in Kansas with stage settings, and our citizens must admit, when their work is first shown, they understand their business thoroughly and are first-class artists in every respect. They will furnish scenery for the fine new opera house at Wichita, and when Lyon’s new Opera House looms up, they will probably again have an opportunity to display their artistic powers” (page 3).
On October 22, 1887, “The Caldwell News” of Caldwell, Kansas, reported, “Judge J. G. Woods is now moving into his new building this week. The lower story is occupied by the Woods bank, This room is elegantly fitted up in solid walnut. The south room is occupied by C. E. Flaudro’s clothing house. The opera house occupies the second story. It is the same size as the Crawford Opera House at Topeka. The stage is 50 feet wide and 25 feet deep and is furnished with fifteen complete sets of scenery including an elegant drop curtain painted by the artist John U. Tschudi…” (page 1) [reprinted on Oct 12, 1922, p 1].
On Dec. 1, 1887, “The Kingman Courier” reported, “Prof. John W. Tschudi, of Kansas City, will have completed the scenic work at Garfield Opera House by the 6th of December. The scenes painted by this talented artist display true genius, combined with the highest-class conceptions of the true and beautiful. When completed the Garfield Opera house will surpass anything of a similar character in Kansas” (page 6).
Tschudi also painted scenery for the Garfield Opera House in Kingman, Kansas. The time he was traveling with a stage mechanic named Mr. Foreman. On Dec. 7, 1887, “The Kingman Daily Courier” reported, “Tschudi, the scenic artist, and Foreman, the stage builder of the Garfield Opera House, will be given a benefit by the amateurs of Kingman Saturday night. They are worthy gentlemen and the entertainment in their interest should be ell attended” (page 3). On
On Dec. 12, “The Kingman Daily Courier” reported “Messrs. Tschudi & Foreman desire to return their sincere thanks to the ladies and gentlemen who so kindly assisted at their benefit on Saturday evening last and thereby insured its success, And they also hope that those who by their presence graced the auditorium enjoyed a peasant evening” (page 3).
Dec. 22, 1887, “The Kingman Daily Courier” reported, “Prof. John Tschudi, artist at the Garfield Opera House, will pass the holidays with his family at Kansas City” (page 3). This indicates that Tschudi moved his family from Emporia to Kansas City when he became associated with the Kansas City Scenic Co. in 1887.
By 1888, Tschudi had left the Kansas City Scenic Co. and had established Tschudi, Loffing, & Roberts at 400 East 12th in Kansas City. His new business partners were Albert Roberts and Antoine Loffing. Tschudi’s residential address was listed as R. 1731 Walnut.
On Feb. 1, 1888, “The Kingman Daily Courier” of Kingman, Kansas, reported, “Prof. Tschudi is, beyond all doubt, the thorough, classical scenic artist in Kansas. His fine conceptions of mountain and sea, of glen and valley, of hill and dell, when spread upon canvass by his deft hand, are gems of beauty on which the eye fondly hangs. The COURIER heartily commends Prof. Tschudi to the managers of the Greensburg Opera House.” (page 5).
The Tschudi’s relocated to Omaha, Nebraska, by 1890. Tschudi is working as the scenic artist at the Eden Musee, living at 1108 Farnam. Interestingly, John S. Tschudi, artist, also listed 1108 Farnam as his address for 1890 and 1891. This may be a double listing, or John S. is actually Tschudi Jr.’s son, John Fohrman; the baby that was born out of wedlock and raised by maternal grandparents, Clara and Michael Fohrman. By 1890, John is over 21 years old. It is very possible that he reunited with his biological father and began working as an artist. The Tschudi Family continued live in Omaha, with Tschudi’s daughters also securing employment.
The 1892 Omaha Directory listed:
Tschudi John S, scenic artist Eden Musee, res. 612 S 18th
Tschudi Lucy Miss, folder O Ptg Co, res 612 S 18th
Tschudi Minnie, candy stand Eden Musee, res. 612 S 18th
The 1893 Omaha Directory listed:
Tschudi John U, scenic artist, Wonderland, res. 612 S 18th
Tschudi Lucy, clk Candy stand Wonderland, bds 612 S 18th
Miss Minnie, folder Klopp & Bartlett Co., res 612 S 18th
Tschudi’s 1892 connection with Eden Musee also makes Indiana’s newspapers. On Jan 25, 1893, “The Indianapolis News” reported, “No Chance for an Eden Musee. For two weeks past T. U. Tschudi, a scenic artist, who has been in the museum business for some years, and Mme. L. Brouillard have been staying at the Circle Park Hotel. Together they have been looking for a suitable building in which to start Eden Musee in New York. The only building in the city that seemed available was the Speigel & Thomas building on Washington street, but Mr. Tschudi was unable to agree on the amount of security that he should give for the lease, and could not make a satisfactory arrangement with the owner” (page 2).
This particular moment signals a shift for Tschudi Jr. and his family, possibly indicating a temporary separation from his wife. His family returns to Kansas City where Tschudi rejoins them in 1897.
During the mid-1890s, Tschudi Jr. heads east, traveling throughout Indiana and Kentucky.
On Aug. 28, 1895, the “Richmond Item” of Richmond, Indiana, reported, “Beautiful Scenery. The Phillips Opera House Greatly Improved and There will be a pleasing surprise to those who attend ton-night. Manager Dobbins has not been idle this summer. He has one of the country’s finest scenic artists at work in the Phillips Opera House for several months, and to day there is completed one of the most elaborate outfits of scenery to be found in the state. Artist Tschudi’s taste in this line of work is not to be equaled, and he has painted thirteen beautiful sets of scenery for the theatre, which must be seen to be properly appreciated. Last night a display was made of new property, and the few persons who were given special invitations to be present were more than delighted. There is nothing which adds more to the enjoyment of first-class performance than appropriate scenic effects and this year the patrons of the Phillips will find that all stage settings will be elaborate. Besides this plentiful supply of new scenery Manager Dobbins has gone further. Another new drop curtain has been painted by Mr. Tschudi, and it is a rare specimen of his artistic skill. The big curtain is rich in its coloring, and almost perfect in its execution. The central figure is a splendid reproduction of Turner’s celebrated painting of “The Harbor in Venice,” and it is a picture the eye does not tire to look upon. The stage of the Phillips, which is one of the largest in the state, has been thoroughly renovated and painted and it presents a neat and clean appearance. The entire auditorium will be re-frescoed within a few days, this portion of the work not having yet been completed. The opera house is now in better trim than ever before and the patrons who are in attendance at the opening this evening will not be long in distinguishing this fact” (page 3).
On Aug 24, 1895, “The Richmond item” reported, “Almost finished. Scenic artist Tschudi who has been in Richmond all summer will still be ‘one of us’ for a considerable time. His work of painting the Phillips opera house scenery will be finished next week and then he will begin work at the Grand. Mr. Bradley has given him the contract to paint the entire set of new scenery which will be of the finest and it is probable that he will get started on the work the last of next week” (page 1).
On Sept. 5, 1895, “The Richmond Item” reported, “The plasterers will soon be at work on the opera house. Scenic artist Tschudi has his scaffolding all arranged for painting the scenery for the Grand theatre” (page 4).
Tschudi was still in Richmond at the beginning of 1896. On Feb 26, 1896, “The Richmond Item” reported, “An Item reporter visited the room of Prof. Tschudi, the artist, this morning and took a hasty inspection of a number of his water-color paintings which are to be exhibited the remainder of the week. The collection represents about four years’ work, and some of the pictures re original while others are copies from celebrated paintings. Arranged as they will be at Stigleman’s studio, they certainly will be well worth the inspection of the people, whether they contemplate purchasing or not” (page 4).
In the same newspaper, Tschudi’s name popped up in a court case: “In ‘Squire Jessup’s court a judgement has been rendered against John U. Tschudi for $16 in favor of J. H. Dobbins. The suit was on account.” Whether this signaled a financial downturn or something else, Tschudi soon left town.
By summer, he was working in Lexington, Kentucky. On July 13, 1896, the “Lexington Herald-Leader” reported:
“Magnificent.
Will be Lexington’s Opera House this season.
Scenic artist Tschudi Now Hard at Work. How House will appear.
Everything is business and bustle at the Lexington Opera House, and when the coming theatrical season opens the citizens of Lexington will see one of the handsomest interior of a theatre in the country. Manager Scott will spare neither time or expense in refitting and refurbishing his house. The scenic artist, Mr. J. U. Tschudi, of Chicago, assisted by the old reliable John Uttinger, is already hard at work and has completed a number of handsome places. None of the old scenery will be used, but everything on the stage will be brand new. There will be sixteen new sets, all beautiful and fresh. The new drop curtain is going to be one of the very handsomest in the country, as Mr. Tschudi told a Leader reporter this morning that he was going to try his hand on this especial piece of work and make it guilt edge, so that our theatre goers can expect something beautiful. The work already completed by Mr. Tschudi is magnificent and shows him to be an artist of high rank. Redecorating the auditorium of the Opera House will be commenced at once, as the scaffold is now being erected for the frescoe painters” (page 5).
It was in Lexington, that Tschudi received what may have been the greatest publicity of his career. There were two extensive articles about Tschudi that I am sharing in their entirety. The first was published on Aug. 15, 1896, in “The Daily Leader” of Lexington, Kentucky (page 3). Again, not everything adds up.
“Mr. J. R. Tschudi who painted the New Opera House Drop Curtain.
An artist of some fame.
J. W. Tschudi, of Chicago, the famous scenic artist who has just completed the scenery and the magnificent drop curtain of out Opera House, was born in Switzerland (the land of William Tell) in 1852, and emigrated to America with his parents in 1857, and from childhood, was fond of painting and drawing. While at school he very often got punished for drawing cartoon on his slate, which kept the scholars laughing. After his school days he studied with his father and assisted him with his work and soon developed such an artistic taste in landscape painting that the father concluded in 1868 to send him back to France to finish his studies. ‘After five years,’ says Mr. Tschudi, ‘I returned to America and took a fancy to large work and consequently went to theatrical scene painting, and have since that time worked in many of the finest theaters both in this country and abroad. My father was a famous fresco artist (in relief); he studied under the old masters in France for ten years. His work can be seen in France, Italy, Switzerland and America at the present time. He died in his 69th year in 1886 in New York.’ Mr. Tschudi is an extensive traveler and had been to all the principal parts of the world. The Leader called on him at the Opera House yesterday, and was shown a beautiful collection of sketches and paintings from all parts of the globe. The artist’s works both in oil and water color, but the last three years there has been no sale for oil paintings, and he has devoted his time entirely to water colors. He says he will give the people of Lexington an exhibition of water color paintings at one of the prominent down-town stores. Mr. Tschudi has been frequently asked why he did not change the spelling of his name, so it would be easily pronounced. He simply answers; “I have no reason to be ashamed of it, as it is famous in Swiss history, being the name of one of the oldest royal families on record, and was borne by artists, generals and men of high rank, and at the present time there are a number of recognized artists in the family. Mr. Tschudi will remain in Lexington until October painting twelve sets of scenery for the new Parkersburg W. Va., theater, which opens about the middle of that month” (page 3).
Another article published in Lexington’s “The Daily Leader” on Aug. 24, 1896, described Tschudi’s scenic art process. I am including the article in its entirety, as this is a wealth of information for future generations:
“Scenery,
And how it is painted by the Theatre Scenic Artist.
Mr. Tschudi Tells the Leader Some of its Mysteries.
Painting a drop curtain.
How the immense canvas is stretched for the work.
A scenic artist’s life a hard one at times.
Mixing paints in buckets.
Few people are acquainted with that part of theater commonly referred to a ‘back of the scenes,’ and fewer persons have a well-defined idea of how scenery for a modern playhouse is painted. A Leader man recently called upon Mr. J. U. Tschudi, who has been busily engaged in painting new scenery for the Lexington Opera House and who is now engaged in painting some for a theater soon to be opened in Parksburg, W. Va. Mr. Tschudi has remained in Lexington to do his work as the facilities here are the very best, and then he has become conveniently settled and likes Lexington. Mr. Tschudi’s drop curtain painted for the Lexington Opera House some weeks ago is certainly a thing of beauty, a masterpiece of scenic art, and has called forth expressions of extreme admiration from all who have seen it. Personally, Mr. Tschudi is a charming man to converse with, always interested in his work and ever ready and willing to impart that interest to others. To the question, ‘where were you born,’ put by the Leader man, Mr. Tschudi said, “I was born in Switzerland in 1852, but am an American artist. I came to the United States in 1857. My father was an artist in France and I, only one of eight children, am an artist. I was fond of it from childhood. When I was a boy, I sometimes got punished for drawing comic sketches on the walls, and I would neglect my lessons to draw those pictures and frequently get kept in school on that account.’
‘Tell me something, Mr. Tschudi about the scenic artist.’
‘The scenic artists,’ said he, ‘do not wear long hair and work with a palette and brushes as most people imagine. He is an ordinary looking man, pleasant in his conversation, and if you see him at work on the paint bridge, you will see him dressed in a neat suit of white overalls and jacket, surrounded by buckets, tomato cans, tin cups, etc. containing the various tints and colors and brushes, some of them as large as our whitewashers use Every large theatre, such as the one here in Lexington, which is well up to the average in modern equipment, is provided with a paint bridge and frame of enormous size. The paint bridge is built at the back wall of the stage, reaching from one fly gallery to the other, all the way from twenty to forty feet above the stage floor, according to the height of the stage, and ranges from four to six feet in width. Between the bridge and the wall there is a paint frame, reaching from one end of the bridge to the other and ranging from 20 by 30 to 40 by 60 feet. Looking at this frame you would think it impossible to move it because of its enormous size and weight, but when you hear the artist say, “Let’er down or up Charley (Charley is the artist’s helper or paint boy) you will see Charley go to the end of the bridge where there is a windlass, take hold with one hand or turn it and the frame is moved up or down as the artist wishes.
‘It may seem strange to you that this paint boy can with ease turn the crank and raise or lower the 40 by 60 feet frame which alone weighs half a ton without the scene that may be on it, also mounted as you see it when finished. However, it is very simple, this monster being hung precisely as a window sash is hung in your house. There is a counterweight attached that balances the frame, and instead of pushing it up like you would a sash, the paint boy turns the crank, and she goes up or down. So, you see, the artist stands on the stationary bridge and can paint a scene by 40 by 60 feet without having to climb up or down a scaffold as you may imagine on seeing some of the enormous scenes in large theaters in cities.
How the artist works.
‘Now, if you will follow, I’ll tell you how the artist works. Stretched on this frame here is, as you see, a canvas 24 by 30 feet, and ‘sized’ as the artist calls it. That is, ready to paint on. With this piece of charcoal tied to a stick, which, I suppose, is about five feet in length. He commences to sketch or outline a scene, which, by the way, is a puzzle to make out at first. Presently, after having mixed all of his colors in his buckets, cans, etc., you will see him apply the colors with large brushes, giving a slap and a dab of color here and there, and before you realize what he is trying to do, you will see the bright sunny sky, the distant hills, the rippling brook, the foliage of trees, and each appear and gradually grow as if by magic until there is a beautiful and finished landscape before you.
‘And all to aid the work of the players,’ suggested the Leader man.
‘Yes, indeed, without the scenic painter’s brush what would the play amount to? The scenic effects carry the principal productions of the present day, as you know.
‘Yes, it was pretty hard at times on the artist, still we had times when we were in not rushed, as some of the scenery which we called stock, such as wood scene, modern street, kitchen, prison, plain, chamber, garden and landscape could be used in some of the modern plays. Sometimes we would have it very easy for a week or two and then again it would be a case of rush.
Artist in a rush.
‘I remember one instance in particular, while getting up the scenery for the Coleen Bawn, there was a tremendous amount of all special scenery to get up. The play was to be put on Monday afternoon matinee. On Saturday night I found myself way behind with the work. The manager came to me, excited and said: ‘Mr. Tschudi, you have been with us for six years and always ready when the time came. By heaven, I am afraid you will not get through in time.’ I said, ‘I never mind, there is lots of time between now and 2 o’clock on Monday, and I will get here just the same.’ I went on the paint bridge Saturday evening after supper and never left until Monday at 11:30, when I had all the scenery finished. It was pronounced by the manager and public as being the grandest production of the Colleen Bawn that had ever been staged. It was pretty hard on me. I went to bed after dinner Monday and slept until Tuesday at 9 o’clock a.m. There are, however, more pleasant things in an artist’s life. Our work is not a burden, it is a life’s study and a pleasure, and I may say I love it. It is the artist who dazzles and deceives the eye and carries you imagination to every part of the globe. When you witness the grand spectacular production, for if you would take the scenic effects away it would be like taking the feathers from the peacock. The bird would be left, but its glory would be gone. Mr. Tschudi will remain in Lexington several weeks while finishing up his work for the Parksburg theater. He may open a temporary studio in Lexington while here, where he will exhibit some of his studies in water colors. A display of his work can now be seen in the show windows of Brower, Scott & Frazee, and they have attracted considerable attention since being put there a few days ago.” (page 3).
By 1897, Tschudi was again listed in the Kansas City Directory, living with his family at 10 East 16th St. His son, also going by John Tschudi, was living with him. He and his son soon had embarked upon a new adventure, traveling with a new form of entertainment – Edison’s warograph. On Dec. 2, 1898, the “Keytesville Chariton Courier” of Keytsville, Missouri, reported, “The Messrs. Tschudi of the ‘War Graphic Co.’ exhibited their moving pictures at Dickenson’s hall, Tuesday evening. The entertainment was well attended, and the illustrations were both instructive and amusing” (page 8). For clarity, this was a moving picture show.
Two years later, Tschudi was still promoting the warograph. On Sept. 18, 1899, “The Evening Kansan-Republican” of Newton, Kansas, reported, J. U. Tschudi, with the warograph, who will give war pictures every night at some corner on Main street on a monster screen.”
On Oct. 2, 1899, “The Evening Kansan-Republican” went into detail about the attraction in an article entitled, “Warograph in Black Tent.” The article described:
“A very interesting attraction for this week will be the Warograph exhibition in the black tent. This exhibition presents life and action nearly all the battles fought in Cuba and the Phillipines. There you will see the charge of the Rough Riders, battle at San Juan Hill, Evacuation of Havana, Grand Parade of troops at Camp Alger, Destruction of Cevera’s fleet, the Kansas boys fighting before the trenches at Candabar and many other interesting scenes.” The article then quote the Hastings, Nebraska, Republican: “No attraction has commanded a greater patronage nor received more complimentary words than Edison’s Moving War Scenes. This feature of the carnivals has been a ‘hit’ and is certainly worthy of the good words and patronage it has been daily received. It is worth several times the price of admission charged and it is one of the attractive features at the Greater American Exposition at Omaha. The men conducting it are all affable and courteous gentlemen” (page 4).
On Oct. 3, 1899, “The Evening Kansas Republican” published a testimonial about Tschudi’s popular warograph attraction: “Don Kinney received a letter yesterday from E. D. Kipp, a friend of his in Marshal, Mo., who wrote from Fort Scott as follows: ‘I am here looking for attractions and find that your town and Fort Scott have the most of them. The Warograph, handled by J. H. Tschudi, is first class and I can highly recommend it” (page 1).
By 1900, the Tschudi family was living at 2631 Holmes. The household included John Ulrich Tschudi, Marguerite Tschudi, son John Tschudi, and daughter Lucy Tschudi. Their second daughter, Minnie Lillian was no longer part of the household, having married James Edward Brady in 1893. The Brady’s also lived in Kansas City.
Tschudi was still traveling with his warograph. On September 11 and 13, 1900, the “Sedalia Sentinel” of Sedalia, Kansas, published the following article:
“The Pictures are Here.
Splendid Scenes from the Boer War a feature.
Mr. J. U. Tschudi, who was here last year with the warograph pictures in the Ilgenfritz building on Ohio street, returns for the street fair again this year, with a much finer apparatus and a lot of new and interesting pictures, among which are fine views of the Boer war. His location is the leader building, opposite the court house on Ohio street. This is the best and cleanest show going for old and young, and the reputation Mr. Tschudi left last year insures him a splendid patronage. Open day and night” (page 1).
Tschudi traveled all over the country with his entertainment, yet still completed a variety of painting project. On Dec. 27, 1900, the “El Paso Herald” reported, “J. W. Tschudi, the scenic artist, arrived in the city with his wife this morning and will remain here until the carnival week. He has had a great deal of experience in decorating floats and his services can be secured by those who wish to put out floats and have not made arrangements” (page 5). He was in town for the live stock exhibit and parade the morning of the 18th].
By 1910, Tschudi had relocated to St. Louis, Missouri; his family remained in Kansas City. Tschudi now lived by himself, listed as an artist and residing at 726 S 2nd Street, St. Louis. The 1910 census report listed him as a widower. The same census report listed his wife as married.
Tschudi’s son and wife continue to live together on Holmes Street in Kansas City for the next two decades, although they moved from 2631 Holmes to 2751 Holmes. Tschudi’s son returned to using his adoptive name – John Fohrman. The 1910 Census listed Fohrman’s occupation as an artist in the Scenic Co. industry. He continued to work as a scenic artist until his passing, frequently working for the Kansas City Scenic Co. Nothing really changed for Fohrman or his mother until 1928. On October 13, 1928, Fohrman married Florence Lee Smith; Smith lived just down the street at 2709 Holmes. Marguerite continued to live with her son until 1931, when she passed. Her obituary made no mention of any former husband:
“TSCHUDI – Mrs. Marguerite Tschudi, 81 years old, died last night at the home of her son, John Fohrman, 2751 Holmes Street. Mrs. Tschudi was born in Luxemburg and came to Kansas City from Europe in 1885. Also surviving are a daughter, Mrs. Lucy Armbruster, wife of Benjamin G. Armbruster of the advertising department, Harris-Goar Company, who lives at 2711 Holmes street; a brother, John Merkes, Dubuque, Iowa and a sister, Mrs. Anna Miller, St. Louis.” It appears that Marguerite altered a little of her own history too– or it was an honest misprint.
After his mother’s passing in 1931, John and Florence Fohrman relocated west to California, settling in Los Angeles. In 1946, they moved to Culver City. Fohrman passed away on Jan 29, 1952. His obituary announced:
“John Joseph Fohrman Rites Set Tomorrow.
Services will be held tomorrow at 11 a.m. at the chapel of Smith & Salsbury for John Joseph Fohrman, 83, of 4208 Lafayette, who died Wednesday morning. He leaves his widow, Florence, and a daughter Lucia Fohrman. Born in Chicago, he had lived in Culver City for six years. He was a scenic artist. Rev. Eldred Charles, of the Cardiff Avenue Christian Church, will officiate. The remains will be cremated.”
In regard to the passing of his father, John Ulrich Tschudi, Jr.; Tschudi never left St. Louis. His career began to fade away, and his name no longer made headlines. Until his passing in 1921, Tschudi continued to work as an artist and live at South Second Street. His death certificate listed that he was 70 yrs. old, an artist, and a widower. Tschudi passed away at 614 N. 2nd in St. Louis, His death certificate listed his parents as John Tschudi and Margaretha Egli – both born in Switzerland. The informant listed on Tschudi’s death certificate was Wm Deven. A small note at the bottom indicates that he was buried in Kansas City. I have yet to locate his grave.
Seven years prior to Tschudi’s passing, he painted “Early Days on the Mississippi.” This may be his only extant painting, as I am unable to locate any other easel artworks by Tschudi;. “Early Days on the Mississippi” may be Tschudi’s sole artistic legacy; the only artwork that marks the life and career of John Ulrich Tschud, Jr.
However, it is the 1914 date and the Mississippi subject matter that is also significant.
In 1914, St. Louis commemorated the 150th anniversary of its founding; as part of the celebration, the City commissioned a two-part civic spectacle. The Pageant and Masque of Saint Louis was presented on the slop of Art Hill in Forest Park from May 28 to June 1, 1914. The pageant used an enormous stage built on pilings in the Grand Basin, measuring over 500 ft. wide and 200 ft. deep. The pageant featured a cast of 7500 volunteers. Some records suggest that there were 75,000 people in attendance on opening night. Three hundred years of local history were presented over the course of five hours, including many scenes from early years on the Mississippi River. Many historic photographs of this spectacle remain, depicting the incredible grandeur of the event. Some are digitally accessible through the St. Louis Public Library as part of the Pageant and Masque of St. Louis Collection.
I firmly believe that Tschudi’s painting was one of many, commissioned advertise the event; advertisements that depicted various scenes from the pageant. This is why the edges of Tschudi’s painting are hemmed, include a painted frame, and title. This artwork was intended to be tacked to a wall, as any advertisement. This painted composition was most likely part of a series depicting significant historical events reenacted at the Pageant and Masque of St. Louis in 1914.
I congratulate the Kimmswick Historical Society’s decision to invest in the preservation of Tschudi’s artwork for many future generations to come.
In June 2021, I posted about the life and career of J. C. Blaine (1853-1935); he was Sosman & Landis employee No. 30. Blaine not only worked with Joseph S. Sosman in 1875 (before the establishment of Sosman & Landis) but also was part of the Sosman & Landis staff in 1891. Recently, I stumbled across additional information about Blaine’s early career with Sosman and contacted a few of his descendants. His grandchildren have been quite generous with their own genealogical research, sharing both family photos, stories, and a few private letters.
Photograph of J. C. Blain, posted to www.geni.com
I am going to start with the Blain/Blaine surname discrepancy. Early in his career, Blain added an “e” to his surname. This explains why he was listed as J. C. Blain in 1875, and J. C. Blaine in 1891 – same person. Blaine changed his last name about the same time that James G. Blaine gained national recognition in the 1884 presidential race. James G. Blaine ran against Grover Cleveland and lost. Keep in mind that name recognition was key to the success of any nineteenth-century scenic artist. J. C. Blaine even named his second son, born in 1883, James G. Blaine. James G. Blaine followed in his father’s footsteps as a decorative painter, but also went by the nickname Pete. An article about the name confusion between politician James G. Blaine and painter James G. Blaine was published in the “National City Star-News” on October 27, 1955 (page 17). There was a family connection mentioned in the obituary of Joe’s father, John R. Blain: John was a second cousin of politician James G. Blaine.
Here is how J. C. Blaine fits into the Sosman & Landis puzzle. I will start with the 1875 Joseph S. Sosman prequel, providing a little context for Blaine’s scenic art work in 1875.
Sosman’s scenic art career began only a few years earlier, in 1873 when he assisted Thomas B. Harrison. The two painted scenery for the new Chandler Opera House in Macomb, Illinois. Sosman had resided in Macomb for eight years, and was well-known as a sign painter by this time. Harrison was a well-known Chicago-based artist who hired Sosman to help paint scenery for the 600-seat venue. The stage at Chandler’s Opera House measured 50’ wide by 20’ deep. “Jno. B. Jeffery’s Guide and Directory” for theaters listed that the Chandler’s Opera House had six sets of scenery, meaning six different stock scenes that were available for touring productions.
Between 1873 and 1875, Sosman transitioned from a local sign painter to an itinerant scenic artist. 1874 was a transition point for Sosman, as he redirected his focus to scenic art opportunities. In the mid-1870s the demand for painted illusion was greater than the supply of scenic artists to paint it. This meant that an ambitious and talented painter could make an incredible amount of money, especially if he was willing to travel, and not settle down in any one place for long. Scenic art projects for the stage were considerably larger and much more lucrative than any sign painting and decorative painting project.
The beginning of 1874, found Sosman on the road, delivering scenery for a new stage in Mount Sterling, Illinois. On Jan 7, 1875, “The Macomb Journal” reported, “Joe Sosman, Macomb’s artistic painter, has gone to Mount Sterling to do some fine painting on a new hall in that place” (page 4). Mount Sterling, Illinois, was approximately 40 miles due south of Macomb, along the Wabash, St. Louis & Pacific Railroad. Sosman was starting to secure scenic art contracts throughout the state.
On September 23, 1875, “The Macomb Journal” reported, “Joe Sosman, Macomb’s talented young artist, left the city Monday last for Fairfield, Iowa, where he goes to paint scenery for a new hall erected there. He will be gone about three or four weeks, and will do a job that will suit the Fairfieldians to a T.” (page 3). Sometime between January 1874 and September 1875, Sosman partnered with Blaine.
On Oct. 14, 1875, Semon’s New Opera House in Fairfield, Iowa, opened to the public. The venue was similar in size to Chandler’s Opera House in Macomb, and described on opening day:
“STAGE AND SCENERY.
The stage is 44×20 in size, ample space being given for dressing rooms. There are two entrances to the stage from the audience and one by the outside stairway. It is circular in front, and the foot-lights, of which there are about 15, give plenty of light. The scenery was painted by Mr. J. S. Sosman, of Macomb, Ills., and bears evidence of the work of a master painter, and a man skilled in his profession. It consists of a magnificent drop curtain, representing the Bay of Naples. At the right and in the foreground of the scene is a ruined arch covered with ivy, the whole being surrounded by beautiful Etruscan border sixteen inches wide. The parlor scene is a representation of gorgeous panel work, and the flat is supplied with practical doors on either side of which are beautiful columns with handsome arches extending above the doors and resting upon the pilasters. The street scene presents a brick residence and a garden in the foreground, while in the distance appear business houses, churches, residences, &c. In the wood scene is a heavy wood, with a beautiful lake in the perspective. The kitchen shows us a dilapidated room with rough plastering and a number of holes in the wall which have a natural appearance, and various articles of household use. At the sides of the drop curtains is more panel work, the entire curtain being surmounted by rich crimson and garnet drapery, giving a perfect finish. The drawing is on canvas fastened on the flats which are 10×16, sliding in grooves, and the wings are 4×10 in size. The painting is a great credit to the artist and all pronounce Mr. Sosman a painter of ability.”
On October 21, 1875, “The Macomb Journal” reported, “From a Burlington Hawk Eye, recently received, giving a description of the finishing of an Opera House in Fairfield, Iowa, quite a lengthy description is given of the scenery painting, and great praise bestowed upon the artist. The design and execution is pronounced first class in every particular, and we believe every word of it, and so will you, reader, when we inform you that our talented young friend, Joe Sosman, did the job” (page 2)
Blaine’s contribution to the new stage scenery was later mentioned on Oct. 28, 1875, in the “Fairfield Ledger” when he assisted Sosman on another Fairfield project (page 6). The article reported, “Very Pretty. We mean that bulletin board painted by Messrs. Sosman & Blain, the artists who painted the scenery for the new opera house. The bulletin board is about 10×20 feet in size, and contains the cards of a number of our enterprising business men. It will be put up on the southeast corner of the Park, and will prove handsome and attractive advertisement. The work is a credit to Messrs. Sosman & Blain.”
Sosman & Blain, artists. Published in the “Fairfield Ledger” on Oct. 28, 1875.
On Nov. 4, 1875, the two were mentioned again in the “Fairfield Ledger”:
“Business Chart. – The most beautiful and attractive business chart ever seen in Fairfield is the on now on the north side of the P. O. building. In size it is 8×16 feet, and contains the business cards of about twenty of Fairfield’s business men. The chart is made of wood, securely fastened to the wall. The cards are beautifully and artistically finished in oil. The work is very creditable to the artists, Messrs. Sosman & Blain, who handsomely painted the scenery at Semon’s Opera House.”
Sosman & Blain were also credited with painting scenery at Everson’s Hall in Washington, Iowa. On Nov. 24, 1875, the “Washington Evening Journal” published the following advertisement for the pair: “SIGN PAINTING. Messrs. Sosman & Blain, the Scenic Artists who are now at work painting the Scenery for Everson’s Hall, will, on completion of their work at the Hall, take orders for Sign Work. Fine Signs and Window Curtains made a specialty.”
On Dec. 17, 1875, the Washington Gazette listed “Sausman & Blaine – New style of advertising” in the “New Advertisements section (page 3). The article about their endeavor reported:
“New Style of Advertising.
The center attraction to the crowds who visit the post office is the new and elegant advertising bulletin recently put three by Messrs. Sausman & Blaine, the scenic artists and commercial advertisers who have just completed the painting of the scenery for “Everson’s Opera Hall.” The work throughout stamps them as first-class artists in their line, and the bulletin is certainly the handsomest, neatest and most attractive thing we ever saw in the line of advertising. It is painted on canvas, in oil colors, and in size is 8 x 16 feet. The cards. Twenty-five in number, are beautifully and artistically designed and are ornamented with the names and businesses of twenty-five of Washington’s most enterprising and wide-awake businessmen. The whole number of cards were taken the first day, and numerous applicants for cards were made after the required number was obtained, which pointedly shows that our business men know how to appreciate a good thing when they see it, but Messrs. S & B have made an imperative rule to take as advertisers but one firm in each distinctive branch of business, and erect but one bulletin of twenty-five cards in each city, and have adopted as their motto ‘first come, first served,” hence but first-class advertisements have or will be taken. In conclusion, we can heartily endorse Messrs. Sausman & Blaine as gentlemen who fulfill their contracts satisfactorily in every respect, and we wish them success and bespeak for them the liberal patronage which their work deserves, wherever they go.”
The partnership of Sosman & Blain lasted for less than a year. The reason for their parting may have had to do with Perry Lands. In 1876 Sosman partnered with Landis, the two raising enough funds to establish a studio in Chicago by 1879. If Sosman had not met Landis, the trajectory of Blaine’s career may have had a very different outcome.
Like Sosman, Blaine completed a variety of projects, working as a decorative painter, paper hanger, scenic artist, and a stage carpenter. Each traveled from town to town throughout the Midwest, completing a variety of projects during the 1870s. The greatest difference between the two occurred in the 1880s. Sosman established a business partnership, remained single. Blaine stayed solo, married in 1881, and raised a large family. In the end, the two became polar opposites.
James Culley Blaine was born on Sept 4, 1856 in Goshen Center, Elkhart, Indiana. He was part of a large family; one of several children born to John Roan Blain (1811-1890) and Hanna Nye (1816-1876). His parents were married on Dec. 11, 1835, in Elkhart County, Indiana, celebrating the birth of the following children over the course of two decades: Jasper (?-d. 1837), Mary Blaine (b. 1838), Francis J. “Frank” Blaine (b. 1842), Agnes (?-d. 1843), Henry Clay (1846-1885), Emily H. “Emma” (b. 1846/9-1908), Susanna (b. 1847), Corwin (?-d. 1850), Mary (d?-. 1878), Augusta (1853-1928), Joseph Culley (1856-1935), James Harvey Blaine (1858-1862), and Robert Blain (n.d).
By 1850, the US Federal census listed the Blain residence in Leesburg, Kosciusko, Indiana. The Blain household at this time included the following children that year: Mary (12 yrs.), Francis J. (8 yrs.), Henry C. (6 yrs.) Emily H. (4 yrs.) and Augusta (infant). Leesburg was only 18 miles south of Goshen where Joe was born in 1856. The 1860 US Federal Census listed the Blain family living in Goshen. At the time the household included Hannah (43 yrs.), Frank (18 yrs., painter), Henry (15 yrs.), Susanna (13 yrs.), Augusta (11 yrs.), Joe (7 yrs.) and James H. (3 yrs.). James Harvey Blain, passed away two years later, on March 3, 1862.
Joe’s father, John R. Blain, made the regional news a few times during the Civil War. On May 28, 1863, John R. Blain sent a letter to the “Goshen Times” about the Butternut War in Leesburg, Indiana (p.3), writing, “Butternut War in Kosciusko County. Leesburg, Ind., May 26, 1863. Dear Sire: – I will inform you how things stand in Kosciusko Co. Last Sunday there was a great battle fought three miles northwest of Warsaw, at a church. A young lady came to church with a Butternut breast pin on and a lady of the Union stripe walked up and took it off and fight ensued thereupon. About twenty engaged in the fight, the Federals came off victorious and the Butternuts retreated a little worse for wear so closed the fight. Yours Truly, John R. Blain”. A few years later, John Blain divested himself of Goshen property too. On Nov. 16, 1865, the “Goshen Times” reported, “Mr. Chas. Grosspitch has bought the John R. Blain property on Maine Street, containing a little over one lot, for about four thousand dollars.” By this time, Joe Blain was nine years old and the family was preparing to move west.
The 1870 US Federal Census listed the Blains living in Maroa, Macon County, Illinois. At the time Joe was 17 yrs. old. Maroa is located approximately halfway between Chicago and St. Louis. In Maroa, the Blain household included: John R. Blain (58 yrs., tin smith), Hannah (54 yrs.), Henry C. Blain (24 yrs., farmer), Emily (21 yrs., music teacher), Augusta (19 yrs., music teacher), Joe (17 yrs., works on farm) and Stephen (8 yrs.). Interestingly, all of the Blain children were born in Indiana, except Stephen, who was born in New York. In 1870, brothers Joe and Henry Blain purchased a 500-acre farm in Madison Township, Polk County, Iowa. For geographical context, their farm was approximately twenty miles northeast of Des Moines, Iowa. However, this was quite a distance from Maroa. For geographical context, Madison Township is approximately 325 miles northeast of Maroa. This move brings Blaine to Iowa, where he later meets Sosman.
After partnering with Sosman in 1875, Blaine continued west to Larned, in central Kansas. For geographical context, Larned is located Pawnee County. I have yet to pinpoint when Blaine moved west. However, he is well known in town by 1879. On April 2, 1879, “The Larned Eagle-Optic” of Larned, Kansas announced, “Mr. J. C. Blaine has taken a quarter section of school land in this township and erected a house thereon. We wonder who is coming from the east to occupy it with Joe” (page 2). Blaine had purchased land in an area known as “South Pleasant Valley.” This was the same area where his future wife lived with her family. Their meeting may have prompted Blaine to secure better employment. On August 9, 1879, “The Larned Eagle-Optic” mentioned Blaine in the “South Pleasant Valley” Section of the paper: “J. C. Blaine put in appearance in this part of the first week. He has accepted a job in the paint department of the Atchison, Topeka and Santa Fe railroad at Topeka” (page 3). Blaine moved to Atchison, Kansas.
On June 25, 1880, “The Larned Eagle-Optic” announced, “J. C. Blaine, formerly of this place but now of Atchison, was visiting friends here week before last” (page 3). Years later, Blaine was remembered in the Atchison newspapers, still owning property in town. On June 15, 1905, “The Atchison Daily Globe” reported, “J. C. Blaine, formerly an Atchison painter and decorator is in town. Blaine owns property in South Atchison. He has not been in Atchison before in ten years. He says he has been all over North America and South America. He formerly worked for A. B. McQueen. He located in Atchison some twenty-five years ago” (page 2). A. B. McQueen was a well-known individual who consistently placed advertisement in Atchison papers over the decades. In 1879, he primarily worked as a painter and glazier.
A. B. McQueen advertisement, 1879.
He was still living and working in Atchison in 1895, when Blaine last lived in town. That year, McQueen advertised as a house and sign painter, with paper hanging as a “specialty.”
A. B. McQueen 1895 advertisement, 1895.
Between 1880 and 1881, Blaine relocated to Ottawa with his new bride. On August 13, 1881, Joseph Cully Blain married Fanny W. Douglas Orrell (1860-1954). At the time, Fanny was 21 yrs. old, the eldest child of seven children in the Orrell household. Their mother, Mary Ann Montgomery Orrell, had passed away four years earlier, on Sept. 11, 1877, and was buried in the Larned cemetery.
As was the case with most nineteenth-century painters who secured work in larger metropolitan areas, Blaine headed to Kansas City. Anticipation of their first child may have been the cause. In the early 1880s, Kansas City bustled with opportunity. Theaters were rapidly being constructed throughout the region. Sosman & Landis even opened a branch office there in 1882. Numerous studios were hiring, offering ample opportunities to those willing to travel for work.
Ottawa is approximately 60 miles southwest of Kansas City.
On Dec. 22, 1881, Joe sent a letter to Fanny from Kansas City:
“My Dear Wife
I rec’d that nice long letter from you yesterday – was glad to learn that you were all well. I did think that I could get off this week but it don’t look much like it now. I have done well since you left. If I could have worked steady but it seems as if it all goes for board. I have only got myself a hat and boots and it seems as if that is all I can get. I have got the “blues” awful bad – you know how I act with them. I can make a living easy but that ain’t the thing. I want to get out of here so bad that I am nearly crazy. It would be nice if I could come there and live but you know there is nothing for me to do in the winter. I wish your father would go to Cali. Nothing would suit me better for that is a grand country. My tooth don’t hurt no more. I had to cut my boot in the instep in order to wear it. I will write another letter soon. Your friend Mrs. Murphy is dead. She was raving crazy for two weeks before she died. She suffered very much. It is snowing very hard. Let me hear from you soon.
From your husband”
What makes this letter significant is that it places Blaine in Kansas City at the same time that Sosman & Landis open a regional office in there. It also mentions California, where many Orrell family relations relocate, including Fanny by 1904.
Joe and Fanny celebrated the birth of first child, Mark, in 1882. It does not appear that he survived past infancy. Their second child, James G. Blaine, was also born in Ottawa the following year. On a separate note, T. B. Harrison (Sosman’s scenic art instructor and friend) painted scenery for the Ottawa Opera House in 1882. On July 26, 1882, the “Ottawa Daily Republic” announced, “Mr. Harrison, the scenic artist of the new Opera House had begun work on the large drop curtain, and it promises to be one of the handsomest pieces of art in the state” (page 1). In a small town, it is unlikely that Harrison and Blaine didn’t meet, especially since both had worked with Sosman.
For historical context, between the summer of 1881 and 1882, Sosman & Landis delivered scenery to the following opera houses:
Opera House, Detroit, Minnesota
Academy of Music, Minneapolis, Minnesota
Hill’s Opera House, Ann Arbor, Michigan
Humblin’s Opera House, Battle Creek, Michigan
Opera House, West Bay City, Michigan
Opera House, Grass Lake, Michigan
Opera House, Hancock, Michigan
New Opera House, Howell, Michigan
Union Opera House, Kalamazoo, Michigan
Arbeiter Hall, Ludington, Michigan
Opera House, Montague, Michigan
Edsell Opera House, Otsego, Michigan
Russell’s Opera House, Bonham, Texas
Brownsville Opera House, Brownsville, Texas
My Theatre, Fort Worth, Texas
Opera House Gainsville, Texas
Opera House, Mexia, Texas
Leach’s Opera House, Somerville, Tennessee
Kahn’s Opera House Boliver, Tennessee
King’s Opera House, Jackson, Tennessee
Vicksburg Opera House, Vicksburg, Mississippi
McWhinney’s Opera House, Greenville, Ohio
Yengling Opera House, Minerva, Ohio
City Hall, Athens, Ohio
Opera House, Nevada, Ohio
Bennett’s Opera House, Urbana, Ohio
Krotz’s Grand Opera House Defiance, Ohio
City Hall, New London, Ohio
Freeman’s Opera Hall, Geneseo, Illinois
Opera House, Hoopeston, Illinois
Opera House Cambridge, Illinois
Turner Hall, LaSalle, Illinois
Opera House, Greyville, Illinois
Opera House, Carthage, Illinois
Masonic Hall, Macomb, Illinois
New Hall, Good Hope Illinois
Temperance Hall, Seneca, Illinois
Opera House, Lockport, Illinois
New Opera House, Rockford, Illinois
Holt’s Opera House, Anamosa, Iowa
King’s Opera House, Hazleton, Iowa
Opera House, Denison, Iowa
Opera House, Jefferson, Iowa
Opera House Nanticoke, Pennsylvania
Opera House Athens, Georgia
Stummer’s Hall, Washington, Georgia
Opera House Reidsville, North Carolina
Opera House, Wilson, North Carolina
Opera House, Newbern, North Carolina
Opera House, Goldsboro, North Carolina
Stouch Opera House, Garnett, Kansas
Germania Hall, Blair, Nebraska
Klaus’ Opera House, Jamestown, Dakota
Opera House, Westville, Indiana
Grand Opera House, Richmond, Indiana
Odd Fellows Hall, Peshtigo, Wisconsin
Hyde’s Opera House, Lancaster, Wisconsin
Klaus’ Opera House, Green Bay, Wisconsin
Storie’s Opera House, Menominee, Wisconsin
Opera House, Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin
City Hall, Mineral Point, Wisconsin
Kolter’s Opera House, Wausau, Wisconsin
Opera House, Waupaca, Wisconsin
Soldiers’ Memorial Hall, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Music Hall, Eau Claire, Wisconsin
Opera House, Stevens’ Point, Wisconsin (drop curtain, landscape with advertisements)
City Hall, Lewisburg, West Virginia
Opera House Moberlv, Missouri
Opera House, Unionville, Missouri
Opera House, Eutaw, Alabama
Opera House Demopolis, Alabama
Grand Opera House, Cheyenne, Wyoming
Cosmopolitan Theatre, Miles City, Montana Territory
Opera House, Harrodsville, Kentucky
Sosman & Landis were taking the nation by storm. No other scenic studio in the country was producing the sheer volume of work. And in 1882, the operated studios in Chicago, New York, and Kansas City.
Joseph S. Sosman (top) and Perry Landis (bottom) pictured in their 1889 company catalogue.
Blaine maintained a permanent residence in Ottawa, where he and Fanny celebrated the birth of ten children over the course of 22 years: Mark Blain (1882-?), James “Pete” Gillespie Blain (1883-1955), Dana Charles Blain (1886-1927), Lowell Henry Blaine (1889-1955), Mary Lena Blaine (1890-1966), Nelson Theodore Blain (1894-1914), Dorothea (b. abt. 1896), Kathryn Mae Blain (1898-1925), Orrell Maxine Blain (1901-1988) and Janice Meredith Blaine (1904-1974). A large family kept Blaine somewhat close to home. His name repeatedly appeared in Ottawa newspapers throughout the 1880s. Blaine began to focus more on decorative and sign painting. Here are a few newspaper announcements about Blaine’s painting projects:
On July 5, 1883, the “Independence-Journal” of Ottawa, Kansas, mentioned Blaine’s ornamental work. The article reported, “Have you noticed the water color decoration in the parlors of the Centennial House? This work was done by J. C. Blaine. Notice it” (page 3).
On Oct. 31, 1883, “The Ottawa Daily Republic” announced, “Mr. J. C. Blaine, who had the job of painting John Pollock’s new residence has completed his contract” (page 4).
On Nov. 23, 1883, “The Ottawa Daily Republic” reported, “One of the finest jobs of house decorating that we have observed in Ottawa is that which has just been completed by Mr. Blaine at Doc Bowles elegant residence. Mr. Blaine is evidently an artist, as well as a practical workman. The various rooms are finished in the most exquisite taste, and while no two are alike there is general harmony which makes a wonderfully complete whole. The library is a very handsomely finished antique style, and the ceiling of the front parlor in Renaissance. The side walls of this room are in graded paper of silver metal. An Adjacent bed-room is also a marvel of beauty and artistic effect. There is a gradation of tints from the ceiling down the walls, which only the mind and hand of an artist could conceive and execute” (page 4).
Blaine still maintained connections with Larned in Pawnee county. His 1884 listing in the Ottawa Directory includes the ties: “Blaine, J C, fr Pawnee Co, Kas, painter, res es Locust 3 d s 5th.”
On April 10, 1884, “The Ottawa Daily Republic” reported, “No better evidence of the progression of things material in Ottawa could be produced than the growth of the aesthetic in her private homes. The artist, not the ‘painter,’ is now in demand in our city, and this fact is evinced by the superb character of the work being done in most of our residences, When decorative artists of genius and skill, such as Mr. J. C. Blaine find it profitable to locate in our city, it speaks with emphasis undoubted for the growing taste and wealth of the community. We have already a vast number of beautiful homes, and many more are being added rapidly. Take for instance, the magnificent residence of Mr. T. J. Warren, corner of Cedar and Seventh streets, which has just been artistically completed internally by Mr. Blaine, in black and white walnut; the handsome residence of Mr. Simpson, on Cedar Street, also finished by Mr. Blaine and his corps of artists, in beautiful chestnut grain, and almost completed residence of H. J. Smith, on Elm and Fifth, where Mr. Blaine has just completed the decorating. Nothing more attractive or artistic can be imagined than is the work in these elegant homes. Mr. Blaine, however, does not confine himself to residences; business houses and offices are also finished and decorated by him in the highest style of art, As witness the just completed work in the Goodin Bank, well worth a call to see. Here is a magnificent counter, finished in French and American walnut, lined up with gold, red-lake and ebony, in exquisite style. Mr. Blaine is an artist well deserving extensive patronage.”
By 1884, Blaine was running his own studio and hiring assistants. As the newspaper article stated: “Mr. Blaine and his corps of artists.”
In 1884, Blaine also decorated the local jail. On April 21, 1884, “The Ottawa Daily Republic” listed his invoice for painting and papering the jail; it was submitted to the Franklin County Board of County Commissioner, totaling $64.74 (page 2). He submitted additional amounts on April 24, 1884 (page 4).
On April 22, 1886, the “Ottawa Daily Local News” reported, “J. C. Blaine, the favorite painter, has engaged the services of Allan McElroy, late of Indianapolis, as assistant. Mr. Elroy is a first-class decorator and artist. Mr. Blaine is now better prepared than ever to do the best of work with dispatch” (page 3). That June, the “Ottawa Daily Local-News” reported, “Mr. J. C. Blaine has finished a very handsome job of painting on the Agricultural hall in the west died of Forest Park.” (9 June 1886, p. 3).
On May 26, 1887, “The Ottawa Herald” reported, “J. C. Blaine has the contract for painting the names of the street on boards to be placed on the street corners. The price is ten cents apiece. Mr. Blaine is an excellent workman, and the HERALD can vouch for the correct and prompt execution of the work” (page 5).
On March 30/31, 1888, “The Ottawa Daily Republic” published the following announcement: “Parties desiring plastering, patching work or flue repairing, can have their orders promptly attended to by leaving word at the office of J. C. Blaine, east side of Public Square. Signed F. M. Kirkham” (page 4).
During the spring of 1889, Blaine was hired to work on the Hamblin’s College Addition as a decorative painter (Ottawa Weekly Republic, 21 March 1889, p 3).On June 27, 1889, “The Ottawa Herald” reported, “J. C. Blaine has gone to Atchison on business” (page 5). He submitted invoices to the City of Ottawa for $2
On July 4, 1889, the “Ottawa Weekly” reported, “In rescuing one of the horses which was in danger of suffocation, Mr. J. C. Blaine, painter, was struck in the stomach, but the injury does not appear to be dangerous. He was able to sit up last night and is no worse today” (page 3).
In 1890, Blaine shifted his focus back to theatre. On Nov. 20, 1890, “The Ottawa Herald” reported, “Sam Rohrbaugh has converted the old skating rink into a modern opera house and will open it about Christmas. J. C. Blaine will be manager” (page 5).
This shift coincided with his father’s visit, and the timing is just odd. Prior to managing the new opera house, Joe’s father arrived in town for a visit. He never left and soon passed away.
On September 8, 1890, “The Ottawa Daily Republic” announced, “J. R. Blain arrived last Friday from Decatur, Illinois, on a visit to his son J C Blaine. The old gentleman will be 79 years old Sept. 9 tomorrow, and is hale and hearty” (page 4). John’s health soon deteriorated. On Dec., 4, 1890, “The Ottawa Herald” reported, “J. C. Blaine’s father is very sick and not expected to recover” (page 5). On Dec 10, 1890, the “Chicago Tribune” published the obituary of Joe’s father (page 6): “Monticello, Ill., Dec. 9. – [Special.] – John R. Blaine, a cousin of James G. Blaine, died recently at the home of his son, Joseph Blaine, at Ottawa, Kas., aged 80. He has long been a resident of Central, Illinois, where he was well known. The remains were taken to Indiana, his former home, for burial.” On Dec. 11, 1890, the “Ottawa Herald” reported, “Mr. Blaine, father of James C. Blaine, the painter, died last Thursday of Heart disease at the residence of his son on Poplar St. His remains were sent to Decatur, Illinois for Burial. Mr. Blaine was a second cousin of J. G. Blaine, of national fame” (page 5).
Less than a year later, J. C. Blaine was working at Sosman & Landis. What remains unclear is if Joe was working for the Kansas City or Chicago office; however, it was likely the KC branch. On October 9, 1891, the “Salina Weekly News” reported, “Scenery Here. The new scenery for the Salina Opera House is here. It is elegant in design and finish. Mr. J. C. Blaine of the house of Sosman & Landis is also here as stage carpenter and at work. He was given notice while at Sulphur Springs, Arkansas and came on immediately. The work will require one week to finish as the plans for carpenter work in the hanging did not come in time for Contractor Gilbert to complete before the arrival of Mr. Blain. The chairs are elegant and comfortable and are now being lined upon the floor in a large Semi-circle” (page 4). Now this was quite a trek, as Salina was approximately 320 miles northwest of Sulphur Springs, Arkansas; no short jaunt.
By 1893, Blaine was working in Decatur, Illinois. His older brother, Henry C. Blaine, also lived in Decatur, having lived there for quite a few years. Already in 1889, Henry C. Blaine had been listed as an employee of Haworth & Sons in the Decatur City Directory, residing at 1366 N. Water. Joseph C. Blain was listed as a painter in the 1893 Decatur City Directory, living at 241 E. Edmond. Blaine’s trips to and from Illinois were often announced in “The Ottawa Herald.” For example, on June 29, 1893, the newspaper reported, “J. C. Blaine is back home from Illinois” (page 5). When Blaine returned to Ottawa that summer, it was likely to celebrate the birth of another child. On July 20, 1893, “The Ottawa Herald” announced, “J. C. Blaine has a new baby at his house” (page 4).
Around this time, Blaine begins to faulter, both with work and in his home town. On August 2, 1894, “The Ottawa Herald” announced, “J. C. Blaine was arrested by Ed Chenoweth for using harsh language. Blain was taken before Judge Robb and fined. He took an appeal to the district court” (page 5). Despite the bad press, Blaine remains in town for a while and begins to take on a variety of decorative projects again.
On Sept. 18, 1895, “The Ottawa Daily Herald” described another of Blaine’s Ottawa projects – decorating the Star Clothing House (page 3). The article reported “The store room (the one vacated by the Skinner establishment) has been in the competent hands of Mr. J C Blaine, and has been put in magnificent condition; it has been repapered and re-painted throughout, and is marvelously attractive.”
Sometime between 1895 and 1900, the Blaines move from Ottawa to nearby Harrison Township in Franklin County, Kansas.
The 1900 US Federal Census list the Blaine family residence in Harrison Kansas. The Blaine household included: Joseph C. (45 yrs.), Fanny (37 yrs.), James G. (son, 16 yrs.), Charles D. (son, 13 yrs.), H. Lowell (son, 11 yrs.), Mary Lena (daughter, 9 yrs.), Nelson (son, 6 yrs.) and Catherine M. (daughter 2 yrs.). Two more daughters were born in the next few years; Orrell M. in 1901 and Janice in 1904. This meant that there was a 22-yrs.-age gap between the oldest child, James G. Blaine, and the youngest child, Janice Blaine.
Blaine continued to work as a paper hanger and painter. In fact, Joe C. and his two sons, James and Dana, were both listed as painters in the 1905 Ottawa City Directory. Joe’s address was 1212 E. 7th, with James’ address as 724 E. 6th, and Dana’s address was 831 E. 8th. Son Lowell was listed as a student at 1212 E 7th, and daughter Dorothy was a stenographer, boarding at 418 W. 2nd.
Life was about to radically change for the Blaine family over the next few years,
The 1905 State Census that year listed Fannie and Joe Blain living with their children: Lowell (16 yrs.), Lena (14 yrs.), Nelson (11 yrs.), Catharine (7 yrs.), Orrell (4 yrs.) and Janeth (1 yrs.). However, Fannie was no longer living in Kansas. She moved to National City, California in 1904. According to family records, she left with her two youngest children, Orrell and Janice, to get away from Joe. Blaine’s grandchildren explain, “She was 44 and tired of having children.” Joe purportedly suffered from alcoholism too. Fanny would not return for seventeen years.
Why did Fanny pick California? Because of extended family. The Orrells had settled in National City during the 1880s. In later years, Fanny’s obituary remembered, “she came to California in 1904 to join her sisters and a brother. They were the late Mrs. Ida Jennings, San Diego, and Fran Orrell, National City, and Mrs. Al Addis, who still resides in National City. The 1900 US Federal Census listed Fanny’s father, William B. Orrell, living with his daughter, Ida B., and son-in-law Fred M. Jennings in San Diego, California.”
Joe and the older Blaine children remained in Kansas until 1910. In 1907 Joe Blaine was listed in the “Painter and Paperhangers” section of the Ottawa City Directory. His place work and home address were both listed as 1212 E. 7th. Other Blaine family members who were listed in the City Directory at that same address in 1907 City Directory included sons Dana Blain (paper hanger) and Henry L. Blaine (student at Ottawa University). In 1907 Dana moved to Cherryvale, Kansas, where he was listed as a painter in the Cherryvale City Directory. In Cherryvale, Dana worked for J. B. Bricker, a paperhanging and decorative painting firm located at 106 N. Depot. By 1910, Dana relocated to Wichita, Kansas, where he continued to work as a decorative painter. That year, Dana worked for Young Bros. Decorating Co., 142 N. Main, Wichita. However, Dana continued to sporadically appear in the Ottawa Directory. Both Joe and Dana Blaine were still listed as paperhangers in the 1910 Ottawa City Directory, before Joe and the kids joined Fanny in National City. Dana Blaine, however, remained in Wichita until his passing seventeen years later, in 1927.
According to Blaine descendants, there were numerous letters written from Joe and the children, pleading for Fanny’s return to Kansas. One of the letters that Blaine family descendants shared is dated March 16, 1908. Joe wrote:
Dear Wife,
Well I thought I would try it again. This is Mon. Morn 5:30” o’clock. So you see we rise early. Early spring is sure here. This month has been just like summer. We only use the kitchen stove. The grass is up the elm buds are out fruit trees ready to bloom. Even the Red birds & Robins are going around in their shirt sleeves. Our hens are beginning to lay. Even the duck (the only one left) lays a big egg every other day. You asked whether I have changed my underclothes or not. Yes I have except my drawers. There is enough in the legs to make another pair of socks by turning them down so I thought I would wear them a week or two longer. Just as soon as we are sure the cold weather is over we will expect to start. Don’t you think there is a danger of your wearing your welcome out? Just as soon as you want to come we will try to raise the money. We are all about worn out roughing it. We would like to see the girls and of course I would like to see the old girl to for absence makes the heart grow fonder.”
Some of the letter is illegible at this point and was not successfully transcribed’ it continues:
“Well this is spring and of course the young man’s thoughts turns to love & pastry. I bought a davenport lounge with a pale green velour upholstering with a design of art novau [sic. nouveau] in it. Also a nice stand for the parlor. Tink has more in the Miller house across the river. Well work has commenced. I am doing the Christian Church also the inside of the Catholic Church. Residence outside work has open up. This has been the dullest winter we ever passed through. Well I will close to go to work.
Your Joe
Don’t forget to arrange about settling for the property for if we get anything, we will want to remodel the house this summer.”
In a, Aug. 1, 1910, letter from Joe to a child, nicknamed “Sam,” he provides a little insight into his current projects and observations regarding the painting industry. I have a gut feeling that “Sam” was Joe’s pet name for daughter Orrell. She would have been 8 yrs. old at the time, and likely wondering why her father didn’t want to come to California. Joe explained a few reasons, writing:
“Dear Sam
Received your letter was glad to hear from you and hear you was well. Things are very dull here. I am working on the Washington School am doing it all through. Will amount to $500.00 so you see it is a big job. There is lots of work in my line…I found 15 men for every job of painting. When I came here I found 15 jobs for every man (in my line). So you see I am not very favorable impressed with the country. Your mother seems to think that anybody can do well there. She throws it up to me. How well your Aunt May is getting along on 60.00 per month. Well they may do it, but it cost me over $9.00 for their short stay there. So you see there is the difference…Write soon.
Your Father,
Joe Blaine”
The Blaine House at 1107 National City Ave., National City, California.
That same year, Joe and the rest of their children joined her in National City, California. The 1910 US Federal Census listed the following Blaine family members living in National City: Joseph C. (50 yrs.), Fanny (49 yrs.), Lena (19 yrs.), Nelson (16 yrs.), Kathryn (12 yrs.), Orrell (8 yrs.) and Janeth (6 yrs.). James G. Blaine also ventured west, relocating from Tioga, Neosho Cty., Kansas, to National City, California. James “Pete” Blaine continued to work as a painter in California.
In 1912, Joe Blaine partnered with another California artist named Jamison, establishing Jamison & Blaine. Their firm was located behind the news offices in the W. T. Johnson Building. Home of the local Masonic Temple. On June 8, Jamison & Blaine were mentioned as sign painters, tenants at the W. T. Johnson building during a renovation. The article mentioned that other businesses in the lower level of the building included the News office, electricians Lozier & Blanchard, realty brokers Stinsman & Nioble. The Masons occupied the second story of the building (page 1).
On June 15, 1912, Jamison & Blaine placed an advertisement in the “National City Star-News” for paperhanging and sign painting services (page 4)
Advertisement for Jamison & Blaine, 1912.
Work was not as successful for Joe in California as Fanny predicted. The Blaine’s began to fall behind and were unable to pay their property taxes. In 1914, J. C. Blaine was listed as delinquent in property taxes for three lots. On Feb. 14, 1914, the “National City Star-News” (page 4) published the following notice, identifying J. C. Blaine as delinquent for city taxes in the year 1913-1914:
Blaine, J. C. – Lot 1, Blk 1. Kimball’s sub 10 acre lot 4 qr sec 154, National Rancho.
Blaine, J. C. – Lot 2, Blk 1. Kimball’s sub 10 acre lot 4
Blaine, J. C. – Lot 3, Blk 1. Kimball’s sub 10 acre lot 4 qr sec 154, National Rancho.
Overall, 1914 was a very difficult year for the Blaine family. On Oct. 28, son Nelson T. Blaine died from injuries sustained during a railroad accident. On Oct. 31, 1914, the “National City Star-News” reported, “Nelson Blaine was fatally injured as a result of an accident which threw him head first from the Santa Fe locomotive, on which he was working, near Pomona.” The boy was picked up and hurried to Los Angeles, where he died Friday evening, at the Santa Fe hospital. Relatives were summoned from this city to his bedside, but he never regained consciousness” (page 4).
Joe continued to seek work.
By 1915, both Joe and James were still listed in the San Diego Directory:
James G. and his wife Ethel lived at es 1st av 1 s of 12th
Early in 1916, Joe and James headed back to Kansas, hoping for more work. Although Joe returned to California by winter, James did not. On Dec. 23, 1916. The “National Star-News” announced, “J. C. Blaine has returned to this city after spending some time in Kansas” (page 1). From 1916 until 1924, James G. Blaine was repeatedly listed in the Wichita City Directory. Both he and his brother, Dana, continued to paint. It was not until 1925, that James and Ethel returned to California.
Photograph of James “Pete” Blaine.
James’ return to National City was announced in the “National City Star-News on Aug. 22, 1924 (page 4). The announcement read, “Mr. Pete Blaine, a former resident of National City, but who has not been here for ten years, arrived from Kansas recently and is visiting his parents, Mr. and Mrs. Blaine of National avenue and Eleventh street.”
It was not until 1925 that Fanny returned to Kansas. On May 15, 1925 the “National City Star-News” announced:
“TO VISIT OLD HOME TOWN.
Mrs. J. C. Blaine and daughter Janice, are leaving next week on a three months visit among friends and relatives in Wichita, Kansas. Mrs. Blaine will visit one son she has not seen for seventeen years” (page 1).
Another version was published the next week – On May 22, 1925, “The National Star-News” reported, “Mrs. J. C. Blaine’s went back to Wichita wich is sum town in Kas. To see her son wich she ain’t seen in 17 years so I bet they will have a good time talkin about old times, Janice went also. For company I gess to stay 3 munths.”
Fanny’s son, Dana, passed away in Wichita two years later.
In regard to Joe, he continued to scramble for work in National City after his return in Dec. 1916. Blaine was listed in an article entitled “Board of City Trustees,” published in the “National City Star-News” on June 30, 1917. Blaine’s labor invoice was listed as part of an audit: “J. C. Blaine, printing St. Sign….2.50” (page 1). Not a big project.
Blaine couldn’t pay his taxes again in 1917. He was again part of the delinquent tax list in the “National City Star-News” on Feb 16, 1918, for “Lots 1,2 and 3, Block 1, Kimball’s Sub in 10 Acre, Lot 4, ¼ Sec. 154, National Rancho” (page 2). This problem continued into the 1920s, with matters getting worse. On Feb. 11, 1927, Blaine was again listed as a delinquent taxpayer for the same three lots (page 4).
In regard to political party, Joe Blaine consistently listed himself as a Republican until 1918, when he became associated with the Socialist. He was again listed as a Socialist in the in California Voter Registrations in 1920. Throughout the 1920s, J. C. Blaine was listed in San Diego Directory as a decorator.
Joe and Fanny Blaine in National City, California, 1920s.
Interestingly, the 1920 US Federal census listed Blaine as a decorator in the hotel industry. Blaine was the resident painter at the Coronado Hotel. That year, the Blain household included Joe, Fanny, and children: Katherine (21 yrs.), Orrell (18 yrs.), and Janeth (15 yrs.), all residing at the same home on 1107 National Ave. In 1920, the San Diego Directory listed Joseph working as a painter, Janeth as a student, Kathryn Mae as a telephone operator, Orrell as a nurse, and Lowell (unemployed).
By the onset of the Great Depression, Blaine shifted from “decorator” to “Painter.” The 1930 US Federal Census listed Blaine as a painter, and living with Fanny, Lowell (40, guard at prison camp), Mona (27) and lodger, Sarah M. Hanold.
The 1931-1933 San Diego Directories listed Joseph and James G. Blaine as painters. Joe, Fanny, Lowell H. and wife Mona Indy all lived at 1107 National av. James G., Ethel and son, James G. Jr. lived nearby at 1228 4th Av.
Joe C. Blaine passed away on April 27, 1935, in National City, San Diego County, California.
Blain’s obituary was published in the “National City Star-News” on May 3 1935 (page 1):
“Joe C. Blaine Dies After Long Illness.
Saturday morning Joe C. Blaine, a resident of this city for the past 25 years, died in his home on National Avenue after an illness covering several months. Mr. Blaine was well known to the residents here and his family went to school and were married and live in the city. Funeral services were conducted Monday by Mr. Dawson Funeral Home, Rev. Mr. Royer of the Methodist church officiating. Mrs. Olive Requa accompanied at the piano while Verna Hawkins sang. Burial was made in the family plot at Greenwood. Mr. Blaine leaves, besides his widow, Mrs. Fannie Blaine, three daughters, Mrs. O. D. Kelly [Lena], Mrs. Lyle Duncan of this city, Mrs. Ernest Gibbs of San Francisco, and James G. and Lowell Blaine of this city.”
No mention of any past successes or ties to Kansas. His life was so much more than the twenty-five years spent in California, but you would never know it.
Joe Blaine with his grandkids and Fanny near the end of his life.
In 1988, Blaine’s granddaughter briefly jotted down a few small snippets about her Grandpa Joe. They are also posted to geni.com. I feel compelled to share a few, as these memories paint a pretty vivid picture of Joe Blaine through the eyes of a child:
Called Joe most of the time, but also went by Cal other times.
He always wore a dark suit, white shirt and black shoes.
He sang some songs to us when he visited
One of the songs he sang was, “The moon went down, to take a peek. Oh Talollie hoo, Oh tallollie hoo.”
He chewed tobacco
He talked in a kind of brittle mid-eastern drawl
He slept in the back bedroom off of the kitchen. His bed was in a corner.
He walked with a stoop and kept to himself.
He liked dogs and he owned a greyhound, a tall skinny dog.
He poured his coffee in a saucer to cool, and always drank with his little finger poised out.
Fanny outlived her husband by almost two decades. She continued to live at their home on National Avenue throughout the 1940s. By 1950, however, she moved in with her younger sister Mary and brother-in-law Albert Addis at 1532 E. Ave. in National City.
Fanny Blaine.
Fanny passed away on Nov. 4, 1954 in San Bernardino, California. She was 94 yrs. old at the time. I wonder if there was ever any regret about relocating to California, or any reflection that Joe’s greatest successes were left in the Midwest.
Painted detail from the Twin City Scenic Co. drop curtain delivered to Shieldsville, Minnesota, c. 1914-1915.
My relationship with the Church of St. Patrick in Shieldsville, Minnesota, began in 2015. That fall, the office administrator, Tracy Velishek, contacted me about preserving an historic backdrop.
She wrote:
“Wendy, Attached is our old social hall which will be torn down in December. The other is the backdrop we would like preserved. I got pictures of the other backdrop but am not very techy and cannot figure out how to send it to you from my phone. I will have my son help me later today. It is our understanding that the building was an opera house in its early days. We are trying to find out what we can about it. Thank you for your time. I look forward to hearing from you. I have the backdrop we want to save in our new social hall rolled up so after Thursday I will know a timeline as to when we will be doing something with it.”
Picture of old St. Patrick’s social hall sent to me in 2015.
Musicals and dramas were presented in the Church of St. Patrick’s parish hall under the ministry of Father John J. Molloy (1866-1962). He served at the Shieldsville parish for 52 years, from 1909 to 1961. By the way, this was the first Irish Catholic parish in the State of Minnesota, founded in 1856.
Rev. J. J. Molloy was responsible for purchasing scenery from the Twin City Scenic Co. in 1914.
Molloy’s service was included in Margaret Hagerty’s 1940 publication “Meet Shieldsville: The Story of St. Patrick’s Parish Shieldsville.”
Hagerty’s entry for Rev. J. J. Molly:
“Rev. John J. Molloy was born in the County Mayo, Ireland, and was educated at St. Patrick’s college in Kildare. He was ordained at Maynooth in 1891 and a few months later came to America. He was assistant pastor at St. Patrick’s in St. Paul from October 1899 to April 1900 and then spent one year at St. Mary’s in St. Paul. The next three years he was assistant pastor at St. Anthony’s in Minneapolis. He then organized St. Joseph parish in Montevideo and was in charge there three years. The next two years were spent at St. George’s parish at Glencoe and then nine years were spent at St. Mary’s, Wilmar. He came to Shieldsville in 1909 and for the last thirty years has made a splendid record. “Father Molloy faced a tremendous task when he arrived in Shieldsville. The place was sadly run down and in need of repairs, so he astounded us all by taking off his coat, rolling up his sleeves and going to work. Up to that time none of us knew that a priest’s coat or a Roman collar were removable, He had the house remodeled, cleaned, and painted. The church too was redecorated, and the landscape worked over and improved. A new fence was built around the cemetery. To keep the young folks near home for entertainment a pavilion as built in the grove, and it proved to be such a success that Father Molloy was encouraged to build St. Patrick’s hall. Much of the work on the hall was donated and every man in the parish was busy. The women raked their brains to think up ways and means to pay for the lumber and furnish the kitchen. It was a delightful change for the ladies of St. Patrick’s parish to have a spacious kitchen to work in and to have a dining room large enough to serve 100 people at a time.”
In 1961, Father Molloy was observed as the oldest priest in the St. Paul Archdiocese and the priest with the longest service, serving under four bishops. He passed away on June 29, 1962, and is buried in St. Patrick Cemetery at the site of the Crucifixion monument, erected in the 1950’s.
Molloy’s dramatic contributions were again remembered in “History of Our Parish,” written by Catherine Spartz in 1971:
“Father Molloy loved people around him and believed in having the social life of his parishoners inherent with their religion. Musicals and dramas were presented in the hall during Father Molloy’s ministry, with the principal performers, members of the parish. St. Patrick’s day in March and the Feast of the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin in August were special times in Shieldsville, Father, who himself had a beautiful speaking and singing voice, organized an outstanding choir.”
The St. Patrick’s Hall stock scenery collection was delivered by the Twin City Scenic Studio, c. 1914-1915, and included a drop curtain, two painted grand tormentors, a garden roll drop, a rocky mountain roll drop, four folding wood wings, a double-painted interior set (center door fancy/rustic interior), and an advertising curtain.
Painted detail from garden drop.Painted detail from folding wood wing.Drop curtain detail with Twin City Scenic Co. signature.
Over time, the stage fell into a state of disrepair and much of the stock scenery found its way to an attic where it was subjected to water damage from roof leaks and stains from bat guano.
Two interior flats brought to the new social hall while I was working on site in 2017.
In December 2015, the old social hall was torn down, but the scenery survived. At the time, Tracy’s son (Andy Velishek )was running a local theatre troupe and hoped that the flats could be repaired and used for upcoming productions. Despite the filth that covered the scenery, Velishek rescued the scenery and stored them in a barn.
There, they sat in relative safety for the next two years.
Conversations with the Church of St. Patrick resumed during the spring on 2017 when I was contracted to restore the ad drop and install it in the new social hall.
Restored Ad Drop. 2017.The new social hall is pictured on the right side.
While working on site that summer, Andy Velishek brought over some of the other salvaged scenery, including the two other roll drops, the woods wings, grand tormentors, and some interior flats. Despite the extensive damage, their beauty was unmistakable.
Before and after restoring the Drop Curtain. 2018. The greatest challenge was identifying the original colors, as so much of the composition had dusted off and was faded.Painted detail showing before and after restoration. 2018.
Studio stencils and shipping tags clearly indicated the collection’s artistic provenance.
The backside of stock flat delivered to Shieldsville in 1914.Shipping tag clearly noting Rev. J. J. Molloy as recipient.
By the beginning of 2018, I restored the three remaining roll drops – drop curtain, garden drop, and rocky mountain pass.
Removing bat guano from the garden drop.Matching distemper colors and restoring areas with paint loss in 2018.The restored garden drop and rocky mountain pass in the new Church of St. Patrick Social Hall. 2018.The Social Hall at the Church ofSt. Patrick in Shieldsville, Minnesota, where four of the historic drops are displayed. 2018.
They were installed in the new social hall attached to the sanctuary at the Church of St. Patrick’s in Shieldsville. When I delivered and hung the drops that spring, I considered my work with the St. Patrick’s Hall scenery collection over.
I was surprised to receive the following text on Nov. 4. 2022:
“Hey there, Wendy. Tracy Velishek here. Don’t know if you remember me but you finished our backdrops at St Patrick in Shieldsville a few years ago. I hope you are doing good and still doing the work you love… Our son Andy still has a bunch of flats that he has to get rid of because he has run out of room…Do you know if anyone who would want them? They have not been cleaned and one or two have some tears…If he doesn’t find someone to take them, he is going to burn them. I would hate to see that and hope you would know of SOMEONE who would want them. I look forward to your reply.”
Burn them…if she had texted anything else, I may have put this project on hold for a few months. I was opening a show that evening and traveling to the Louisville Scottish Rite theatre for a restoration project the next week.
The Gilbert & Sullivan Very Light Opera Co. “Pirates of Penzance” setting, 2022. Distemper paint (dry pigment paste and diluted hide glue) was used for the entire set (facade, drop curtain, wings, borders, shutters, and painted fabric masking).
After striking Gilbert and Sullivan Very Light Opera Company’s “Pirates of Penzance” on Nov. 20, I found myself driving south to Lonsdale, Minnesota, where the historic scenery collection was now stored. Half of my rental trailer was occupied with set from “Pirates.” It was a small wing-and-shutter stage.
A grand tormentor and foliage wing when the were set up in the new social hall at the Church of St. Patrick in Shieldsville, Minnesota. 2018.
The other half of my rental trailer was reserved for the historic scenery. Amazingly, the St. Patrick’s Hall stock flats would also work in my small Pirates stage.
When I picked up the scenery, Tracy gave me a big hug and handed me a gift bag with four jars of their homemade jelly. Historic scenery and a bag of jelly; who could ask for more?
My bag of jelly from Tracy when I picked up the scenery.
The scenery is currently at my studio, awaiting cleaning, repair, and a second life on the stage. I will continue to update this post as each piece is restored and displayed.
The historic flats, as they are currently stored in my studio.
My recent scenery restoration project at the Louisville Scottish Rite Theater began three years ago in 2019. These projects are often years in the making, and it really takes the right person to set the ball in motion. I have watched scenery collections crumble from both indecision and poor stewardship. Time is often of the essence when historic scenes start to fail. Scenery that survived decades against an upstage wall can rapidly deteriorate over the course of a few years if the conditions are right.
My initial visit to the Louisville Scottish Rite was a side trip while attending USITT (United States Institute of Theatre Technology). Whenever I attend the annual conference, I try and schedule a visit to a nearby Scottish Rite theatre or historic opera house. These side trips provide me with an opportunity to learn and document “just one more” scenery collection.
Visiting the Louisville Scottish Rite during the USITT conference in 2019.The Louisville Scottish Rite Auditorium.The Louisville Scottish Rite.
The only day that I could photograph Masonic scenery while attending USITT in 2019 was on Wednesday, March 20. Preparations for the Scottish Rite reunion were scheduled to start the next day. I had from 9AM to 3PM to document as much as possible and make my way back to the convention center for a meeting.
I must have made an impression, as the Louisville Scottish Rite hired me that fall to assess the collection. I was contracted to compile condition reports, historic analyses, and replacement appraisals for each drop in the collection. My documents that December were so well-received that I was asked to visit Louisville and present my findings at a special event.
The Egyptian Setting for the 31st degree was one of six settings featured during my presentation on March 7, 2020.
On March 7, 2020, I was the guest speaker for Family night at the Louisville Scottish Rite. I gave a presentation about their historic scenery collection, tracing the history of Masonic scenery in the United States and placing the Louisville Scottish Rite scenery collection withing the context of American theater. At the time I was also asked to work as an historical consultant for upcoming interior renovations throughout the building. After speaking at the Scottish Rite in Louisville in March 2020, the pandemic put everything on hold.
March 2020 – May 2022
Eventually, I lost touch with the Louisville Scottish Rite and moved onto other projects, yet the Louisville Scottish Rite scenery collection continued to lurk in the back of my mind. Surprisingly, Randolph Starks, Secretary of the Louisville Scottish Rite, reached out again last spring. On May 2, 2022, I received the following text: “Hi Wendy. It has been a very long time since we spoke, but I have enjoyed seeing your Facebook posts, the reports of your travels, and the images of your beautiful artwork. I would like to renew our conversation about you providing advice and guidance on some renovation and painting of our Scottish Rite temple. Let me know when you would be available to schedule a phone call to discuss this.” I received this on the same day that my mother went into the ER, so our conversation was again placed on hold for a few more months.
Stark contacted me again on June 29, 2022, but for another reason.
I received a series of pictures of the Egyptian cut drop, with the text message, “Hi Wendy. We just discovered this damage to this scenery drop today. I don’t know how it happened. I would like to know if it would be possible to repair and restore it.”
Damage to the Egyptian Cut Drop at theLouisville Scottish Rite.Damage to the Egyptian Cut Drop at theLouisville Scottish Rite.
My response was, “Yes. You will need to take the drop down, or damage will continue- I am mid-project, but can chat tomorrow afternoon.” Realistically, I was in no position to take on another project and knew that I would have to mostly advise from afar. Starks gathered a team to lower the drop, and I then directed its preparation for short-term storage, until I could travel to Louisville that fall. We tentatively scheduled my visit for November. I would not only repair the scene, but also advise on some upcoming interior renovations. I was also scheduled to again speak about the history of the Louisville Scottish Rite scenery (another Masonic event on Nov. 10, 2022).
Repairing the Egyptian Cut Drop
Unfortunately, there were a series of obstacles to overcome before rolling and storing the cut drop to await my future repairs. The first obstacle was removing wood from the backside, as several “stiffeners” were glued to the cut edge. Many cut drop openings without netting for support curl over time. As a preventative measure, some scenic studios attached wood stiffeners upon installation. These stiffeners were frequently thin strips of pine that were secured to the drop with a strip of glued muslin. Removing an original stiffener is often simple, as the fabric and wood easily peel off of the fabric.
Over the decades, Masonic stage crews tried to replicate this technique. Unfortunately, instead of using thin strips of light-weight pine, they improvised, using a variety of hard woods and solvent-based or inappropriate adhesives. Over the years I have encountered oak strips attached with contact cement (Wichita, KS), lathe attached with wood glue (Fort Scott, KS), yard sticks attached with plaster of paris (Fargo, ND), just to name a few.
Patch on a cut drop at the Scottish Rite Theatre in Fargo, North Dakota.
In Louisville, however, an enterprising Mason opted for a black substance that looks like coal-tar pitch; this was a new one to me.
Photograph sent to me by Jordan Morgan, showing stiffeners attached with a black adhesive.Wood attached to the backside of many cut drops at the Louisville Scottish Rite.
In addition to the stiffeners, ¼”-thick black flexible foam was secured to all of the cut edges with spray adhesive. Sadly, I have encountered this before too, at the Scottish Rite in Cheyenne, Wyoming. Although it works in the short term, it wreaks havoc when repairs need to occur. In Louisville, a solvent-based spray adhesive was used, partially melting the foam and permanently affixing it to the backside of the drop.
Removing the flexible foam from the Egyptian cut drop.
And there was one more thing…
The original netting in the cut opening was replaced with plastic netting that was hot glued on.
Plastic netting attached with hot melt glued, placed over original cotton netting.
Although I feel like a broken record, constantly repeating myself, here goes…NEVER use hot melt glue on historic stage scenery. Hot melt glue has no place in historic preservation, as it severely damages fragile fabric, embedding itself in the fabric’s fibers. Often the hot melt glue is even visible from the front, marring a once beautifully painted composition. Attaching anything to historic scenery with hot-melt glue makes the repair irreversible and flammable. It is especially unfortunate if the new netting is plastic or poorly positioned in the cut opening. Both were the cases with the Egyptian cut drop at the Louisville Scottish Rite. When conducting the initial examination of the scenery, I recognized that the plastic netting would have to remain, as there was so much hot melt glue applied to the fabric that it is now permanently affixed to the cut drop.
The stiffeners, foam, and plastic netting prohibited any expedient storage of the scene last summer until my fall arrival. Fortunately, one diligent Masonic volunteer, Jordan Morgan, spent over thirty-hours removing both foam and wood. Despite his diligence, some areas were left for me to deal with once on site. As I expected, removing the foam and stiffeners could not occur without damage to the painting and fabric. Some of the foam remains firmly adhered to the cut drop.
Egyptian cut drop with flexible foam around cut openings.Removing the flexible foam.
My trip to repair the scenery was slotted for November. During my stay, I would not only fix the damage to the cut drop, but again speak as a guest lecturer and continued to function as a historical consultant for a few anticipated interior renovations.
On the afternoon of Nov 8, 2022, my plane touched down and I was off to the races. This was well after casting my vote at 7AM; it was election day, and I was thankful that the Minnesota polls open so early. After renting a car, checking into my hotel, changing into work clothes, and driving to the Scottish Rite, I began the slow process of setting up the workspace. Once everything was set, I carefully unrolled the damaged cut drop and assessed the damage, simultaneously planning my attack. Despite the dozens of pictures that were sent, nothing replaces examining the damage in person. I went to bed that night, weighing the pros and cons of various approaches to the damage.
The Egyptian cut drop on the stage at the Louisville Scottish Rite.Beginning the repair
Arriving at the Scottish Rite the next morning, I met my onsite assistant, Jordan, and we began the painstaking process of cleaning both the cut drop. This is necessary before any fabric repair.
Cleaning the backside of the fabric prior to repair.
I focused on the biggest damage, before tackling the dozens of small punctures. By midmorning, I realized that the project would go far beyond patching visible damage. I had to do some preventative care – placing vertical reinforcement strips on every seam and weak area. The culprit of the anticipated damage? Flame retardant.
Split seams caused from repeated applications of flame retardant over the decades.
A repeated application of flame retardant often causes the greatest damage to historic scenery; it is like giving the drop cancer. Applying different flame retardants over the decades creates a toxic environment for the fabric and the very fibers begin to break down. Therefore, I need to help support the fabric so that the weight of the fabric will not cause stress that results in tears.
Now, I was dealing with a few different problems. The central portion of the drop is much older than the top and the bottom; the oldest portion dating from the previous building, c. 1910. Toomey & Volland Scenic Studio records indicate that scenery was delivered to the Louisville Scottish Rite in 1910.
Original fabric (below) and fabric extensions (above) added in the 1920s.Original fabric (below) and fabric extensions (above) added in the 1920s.
These drops were later refurbished, enlarged, and installed in the current building during 1923. Over the years, there have been several alterations made to the collection. Initially, the top sandwich batten was removed and replaced with jute webbing and ties lines. This likely occurred when the 1910 scenery was refurbished and moved into the new building. The first-generation bottom sandwich battens were replaced with pipe pockets at this time too.
Flexible black foam attached to the cut edge with spray adhesive.
However, over time, as the pipe pockets failed, ripping off, second-generation pipe pockets were added, the latest being thick, clear plastic that was glued to the back.
Plastic pipe pocket glued to the back of a Louisville Scottish Rite backdrop.
Additional scenery was purchased from Volland Studios between 1951 and 1952, then again in 1968.
Additional repairs, fabric reinforcements and attempts to consolidate loose pigment occurred continuously over the decades. For example, olive green edging (similar to a coarse bias tape) was sewn onto the offstage edges. This was an early attempt to prevent tearing from contact. Although this has prevented some damage and deterioration, the actual sewing greatly damaged the painted surface and has weakened the fabric over time. Other drops have large pieces of mesh glued to the entire back, possibly an attempt to prevent rips. However, the added weight is now jeopardizing the top of each scene.
Mesh glued to some of the backdrops at the Louisville Scottish Rite.
Over the course of three days we cleaned, patched, and reinforced the fabric of the Egyptian cut drop. Paint touch-up of visible patches will occur on my return. I only transport my distemper palette by ground, and therefore will drive on my next trip.
On the morning of Nov. 12 (my fourth day), I supervised the hanging of the repaired cut drop. Everything looked perfect!
Front view – the repaired cut drop.The repaired cut drop, as viewed from behind.Details of repaired damage. Egyptian Cut Drop. Repair work Completed from Nov. 8-12, 2022.
I then assessed the remainder of the collection and began planning for the complete preservation of the entire collection.
Painted detail from another Louisville Scottish Rite scene.
By the afternoon I was on my way home, only 96 hours after my arrival. It was an action-packed trip that I have yet to recover from.
In regard to the history of the Louisville Scottish Rite scenery, my research indicated that Kentucky may have been the earliest state in the Southern Jurisdiction to use stage scenery for their degree work. Here is an excerpt from the document that I submitted in 2019 as it helps frame the significance of the scenery collection and my restoration project.
“The History of Degree Productions at the Louisville Scottish Rite.
Scottish Rite Valley’s bordering the geographical demarcation between the Northern and Southern Jurisdiction were experimenting with stages in Masonic Halls and common lodge room long before the first “official” Scottish Rite theater was constructed in the Southern Jurisdiction, c. 1890s. The earliest Scottish Rite stages frequently referenced in the Southern Jurisdiction are Little Rock, Arkansas and Oakland, California in 1896. Theatrical staging of degree work in Louisville, Kentucky, may have predated these two Valleys, signifying the inclusion of the earliest Masonic stage settings in the Southern Jurisdiction.
The Wilkes-Barre Times of Pennsylvania, the Arizona Daily Star of Tucson, and the Akron Beacon Journal of Ohio all published the following article in 1895:
“BIG SCOTTISH RITE DEDICATION. Louisville, Ky., Oct. 15 – The Scottish Rite Cathedral of the Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite for the Southern Jurisdiction of the United States, at Sixth and Walnut street was dedicated today. This dedication surpassed anything ever seen in Masonic ceremonies in this city. It was open to the public, and conducted with all the pomp, which the occasion calls for. The remainder of the inaugural week will be given in reunion, during which all degrees will be conferred. The new cathedral in point of general magnificence is surpassed by only two in the United States, those being cathedrals of the Grand Consistories of Illinois, at Chicago, and of Ohio, at Cincinnati.” Both Chicago and Cincinnati boasted theatrical stages with elaborate scenery collections, but they were in the Northern Jurisdiction.
The article also notes, “All degrees will be conferred,” which translates to “all degree will be dramatically presented” aligning with the staged degree productions in the Chicago and Cincinnati Scottish Rite theaters at the time.
The Grand Consistory, Ancient and Accepted Scottish Rite, was organized in Louisville, August 21, 1852, with meetings being held on the Southwest corner of Fourth and Jefferson Streets. By August 1876, the Louisville Scottish Rite occupied the Courier-Journal Building, located on Jefferson Street, between Third and Fourth Street. In 1894, the Louisville Scottish Rite Bodies purchased the St. Paul’s Episcopal Church at Sixth and Walnut Streets. The church has been partially destroyed by fire when they acquired the building, and approximately $41,000 was spent on remodeling the facility. By 1895, it was dedicated as a Scottish Rite Cathedral. This predates what Little Rock and Oakland would do in 1896; remodel an existing space to include a Scottish Rite theatre to fully confer, or stage, the degree work. This Louisville Scottish Rite building was used until 1923, when their new home was constructed at Brook and Gray streets.
In 1910, Toomey & Volland business records note that they delivered a scenery collection to the Louisville Scottish Rite. This scenery would have replaced the original scenery installed in the renovated Episcopal Church space. Churches were perfect buildings to retrofit with theatrical stages for degree productions.
There is not yet a definitive indicator of the scenic artist or studio that first delivered the original scenery in 1895. However, it was not Toomey & Volland, as the firm was not established until 1901. Toomey and Volland delivered scenery to the Louisville Scottish Rite Cathedral in 1910, with many of their backdrops being refurbished and transported to the new building during 1923. This was a common practice throughout both the Northern and Southern Jurisdiction at the time. The Guthrie, Oklahoma, Scottish Rite even reused and transported their 1910 scenery collection to the new building during this same time.
The first Scottish Rite Cathedral in Louisville was a remodeled building. St. Paul’s Episcopal Church at Sixth and Walnut Streets was renovated for Scottish Rite purposes in 1895. From this moment forward, the Masonic membership in Louisville continued to grow at a rapid rate, as was common with many other Valleys that began producing degree work for the stage. By 1919, Louisville’s Scottish Rite candidate class size numbered 200, and the overall membership began exceeding the building’s capacity.
During the 67th annual spring reunion in 1919, the president of the “Victory Class “of Scottish Rite candidates introduced a resolution. Dr. T. H. Tuley urged, “the Grand Consistory immediately to make plans for the erection of a [new] Scottish Rite Cathedral in Louisville which will prove a credit to the Rite and to the city.” The Courier-Journal reported, “the reading of the resolution was greeted with applause, and from the manner in which the proposition was received it seems possible some steps in this direction will be taken” (26 April 1919, page 4).
Previously, the Courier-Journal reported, “Largest Class in History of Consistory Attending Scottish Rite Meeting. 200 At First Dinner” (23 April 1919, page 9). The session opened at 10AM on April 22, with conferring the Lodge of Perfection degrees (4-14). The article noted, “For several months the Scottish Rite has been practically overwhelmed with applications for membership, every Masonic lodge in the State reporting unusually large numbers of initiates.
The result has been that for the first time in many years it has been necessary to hold two spring Scottish Rite classes, the first one having completed work only about ten days ago.” Capt. John H. Cowles, sovereign grand inspector general of the Supreme Council of the Rite, was interviewed by the Courier-Times. The newspaper reported, “He says unusually large classes are being accepted into the rite in all consistories of the southern jurisdiction. He was highly pleased with the showing made by the Louisville lodge, especially in view of the fact that he received his degrees here and is a native of Kentucky, having lived for many years in Louisville.” In 1919, the Louisville Scottish Rite premiered a four-page publication for attendees titled “The Reunion News.” It was published every day during the Scottish Rite reunion. Interestingly, the Scottish Rite once met in the same building as the local newspaper, the Courier-Journal.
Scottish Rite membership was explosive during the 1920s, and the influential power of the Freemasons was substantial. This is a moment in time when the Rite, especially the Louisville Scottish Rite, was very vocal about their activities and positions on both political and social issues. From the late-nineteenth century to early twentieth century, it was not unusual to find detailed information pertaining to daily activities at Scottish Rite reunions, a list of members, the history of the organization and their stance on public and political topics. For example, the views of the Rite regarding public education were published in the local newspapers for all to read. When a potential candidate thought about joining a particular Scottish Rite, there was no question in his mind about what the organization stood for and could determine in advance if it was a good fit. This may be why the Scottish Rite continued to gain ground and dominate the fraternal landscape of America during the late-nineteenth and early-twentieth centuries.
In regard to the construction of their new home, on May 11, 1923, the Courier-Journal published, “Scottish Rite Masons will begin a three-day campaign May 23, to raise the $300,000 necessary to complete their building fund for the proposed $750,000 cathedral at the southwest corner of Fourth and Breckinridge Streets. Ground for this structure will be broken in September, it was said. The cathedral will have four stories and basement, with an auditorium seating 1,350 persons. Solicitation will be from the 2,286 members in the State of which 1,200 are in Louisville, The campaign will be in charge if Benjamin S. Washer, Richard Priest Dietzman, Edward F. Metzner, Harvey White and Dr. E. L. Henderson” (page 18).
On June 27, 1923, the old Scottish Rite was sold, becoming the new R. E. Jones Temple, Methodist Episcopal Church. On September 9, 1923, the Courier-Journal announced, “The contract for the construction at Fourth and Breckinridge Streets will be awarded shortly after bids are opened about October 15” (page 34). The building was sold to the Methodist Episcopal Church, becoming the R. E. Jones Temple. Rev. Dr. Robert Elijah Jones (1872-1960), namesake for the new church, was also a 33rd degree Scottish Rite Mason. Within a year, however, tragedy struck the old Scottish Rite building. On May 27, 1924, the Courier-Journal reported “Five Firemen and a negro preacher were overcome by smoke last night when flames of undetermined origin ignited debris in the basement of the R. E. Jones Temple, formerly the Scottish Rite Cathedral at Sixth and Walnut Streets” (page 5).
There is one thing to consider about the original Scottish Rite stage and scenery when the Louisville Scottish Rite Cathedral changed ownership. When the building became the R. E. Jones Temple, it is highly unlikely that any fraternal artifacts or decorations were left behind. This means that the old scenery, stage machinery and other stage equipment was either returned to scenic studio (for credit on the purchase of a new collection), it was enlarged for their new stage, or it was sold to another Scottish Rite. To all indications, there remains a significant amount of scenery used by the Louisville Scottish Rite that predates the current building, c. 1910.
In 1910, the Louisville Scottish Rite purchased scenery from Toomey & Volland. Interestingly, Toomey and Volland advertisements from 1912 do not list Louisville alongside fifteen other Scottish Rite Cathedral installations by that time, suggesting that they may have only been adding to a previous purchase. Toomey & Volland could have simply expanded an earlier collection, possibly the one delivered in 1895. There is a distinct possibility that scenery was delivered by the precursor to Toomey & Volland – the scenic studio of Noxon & Toomey.
Thomas C. Noxon was a Freemason, and extremely active in the Shrine. Also, in 1895, Noxon & Toomey delivered stock scenery to Louisville’s Amphitheatre Auditorium. This may have been the crucial connection, a preliminary link with Louisville Masons and the scenic studio of Toomey & Volland. It would not be surprising to learn that Noxon visited the Scottish Rite while installing scenery for another theatrical venue; a common practice among scenic studio owners at the time.
It remains uncertain as to whether the major Scottish Rite scenery supplier to the Southern Jurisdiction at the time, E. A. Armstrong Manufacturing Co., delivered any scenery to the Louisville Scottish Rite Cathedral. Scottish Rite minutes may point to a specific vendor. If the theater work was contracted to E. A. Armstrong, Sosman & Landis were the preferred subcontractors in the mid-1890s, the scenic studio who manufactured and installed the scenery for this fraternal supplier. However, the Louisville Scottish Rite is not listed in a 1902 E. A. Armstrong advertisement that notes all the Consistories they had equipped since 1897. Keep in mind that was after the potential 1895 date of delivery. If it was manufactured at the Sosman & Landis studio, David A. Strong would have been the Masonic designer and primary scenic artist for the earliest Louisville collection due to his early Masonic affiliation. Strong was instrumental in producing much of Chicago’s Scottish Rite scenery for stages starting in 1873; this was the other Masonic theater that Louisville was compared with in 1895.
There are two other possibilities in regard to regional artists who may have created the original 1895 scenery collection Louisville Scottish Rite Cathedral –scenic artists E. T. Harvey or Henry C. Tryon.
Harvey was the scenic artist who designed, painted, and installed Scottish Rite scenery collections for Cincinnati in 1886 and Cleveland in 1901. In 1886, Harvey delivered eighteen sets of scenery to the Cleveland Scottish Rite Cathedral’s stage. Keep in mind that Louisville’s 1895 Scottish Rite Cathedral was compared with the Cincinnati Scottish Rite Cathedral in the newspaper article; “The new cathedral in point of general magnificence is surpassed by only two in the United States, those being cathedrals of the Grand Consistories of Illinois, at Chicago, and of Ohio, at Cincinnati.”
Tryon was the scenic artist credited with scenery and stage machinery at the Indianapolis Scottish Rite a few years earlier in 1883. Both Harvey and Tryon were close friends with Thomas G. Moses, who was in charge of the design, painting, construction, and installation of all Scottish Rite scenery at Sosman & Landis (Chicago) after 1904.”
There is so much more that I could write about this project and the collection as a whole, but I need to pause here. For more posts about this collection, keyword search “Louisville Scottish Rite.”
My involvement with the Okanogan Murals began earlier this year. On January 28, 2022, I received the following email and a link from my Canadian colleague John Madill.
He wrote, “In case you hadn’t seen this (nice tranquil images and palette). Cheers, J”
The article reported, “A couple renovating a 115-year-old building discovered two 60-foot-long hidden murals.” The accompanying photograph pictured a lovely landscape painting above piles of construction debris.
Madill was just the first of many friends and colleagues who day shared this story with me on January 28, urging me to contact the young couple. I didn’t have to think about it for long, as Lisa Timm contacted me the next day.
On January 29, 2002, I received the following FB message:
“Hi, Wendy! My husband and I recently uncovered a 60ft mural from 1915 and are hoping to conserve it. I was wondering if you could offer any advice or expertise as it looks like a theatre backdrop. There are videos and pictures on our Facebook group (mural restoration at the historic Timm building). Thanks so much.”
I had already delayed several out-of-state business trips, as familial obligations were pressing. I was trying to stick close to home. However, that did not stop me from finding Okanogan on a map. Amazingly, it was an hour north of Chelan, Washington. I was working with a theater owner in that town.
Okanogan is located 3 hours west of Spokane, Washington.The Okanogan town sign.
My Chelan client was Ruby Theatre owner, Larry Hibbard. In fact, I had just received half of the main drape for the Ruby Theatre with a request to bid out replicating curtain, complete with hand-painted border. I would soon find out that J. M. Deeds Scenic Studio had not only decorated Okanogan’s Hub Theatre, but also Chelan’s Ruby Theatre. This was my sign to quickly document the Okanogan murals and visit the Ruby Theatre.
Larry Hibbard in front of the Ruby Theatre, Feb. 2022.
The Ruby Theatre Curtain.
Originally constructed as a commercial building in 1907, the structure in Okanogan initially housed the Okanogan Commercial Club, a precursor of the Chamber of Commerce. By 1915, the building was transformed into the Hub theatre. The theatre renovation included the installation of two 60’-0” long large murals on the north and south side walls. On Dec. 7, 1915, the “Okanogan Independent” announced, “Improvements at Hub’s.” The article reported, “Hub Carlton has contracted with J. M. Deeds of Wenatchee for interior decorations, new screen and new curtain for the Hub Theatre that will greatly improve the inside appearance of this popular playhouse. Mr. Deeds came up from Wenatchee last week and is now supervising the work, which is being done by W. J. McConnon, and experienced decorator who has been in Mr. Deeds employ for some time. Mr. Deeds has just completed decorations for the Wenatchee theater, which is said to be one of the finest in this part of the state, and also is the man who did the decorating for the Ruby Theatre of Chelan, known far and near as one of the most attractive playhouses in the country. The new improvements at the Hub include 120 feet of panoramic landscape scenery in light tans. The picture screen will be 11×13 feet in size and have frame effects of moulding. There will also be a pretty drop advertising curtain with an overhead roll, noiseless I operation and will be controlled from the operator’s booth. Mr. Carlton is sparing no means to improve his place of business and is making additions to his equipment as rapidly as business will warrant.”
One of two murals delivered to the Hun Theatre in 1915.One of two murals delivered to the Hun Theatre in 1915.
In 1918, another building renovation transformed the building into the Paramount, a movie house. It was at this time that the two three-years-old murals were encapsulated between the original wood walls and the new plaster walls.
An article from May 14, 1918, described the new Paramount Theatre recently completed by C. P. Scates, reporting, “When Mr. Scates first went into the theatre business in this city, he expected to erect a new building. He secured a location and had architects submit plans for an up-to-date theatre, but soon discovered that war prices on labor and material made it absolutely impractical to build at the present time. He then set about to remodel the old building, which has been accomplished under mechanical guidance of Geo. W. Colyar, and expert in his line, as an inspection of the Paramount will convince anyone.
“There is very little left of the old building. The entire front had been torn out and replaced with concrete and metal construction. A thirty-foot brick addition has been built on the rear. The front of the new theatre is as handsome as the interior, finished in white cement and artistically decorated with ornamental plaster in the shape of cornice, cartouches, and flower boxes. The lobby is entirely done in white and presents a particularly fine appearance from the street. The interior is a work of art. The general color scheme is old rose and silver, gray, and the ceiling is heavily beamed and panels. A heavy proscenium arch forms a handsome frame for the screen.”
Interior of the Paramount Theatre with old rose and silver-gray walls.Remnants of the Paramount interior decor.
Despite changes in the use of the building over the years, the murals lay hidden plaster and lathe. The Timms purchased the building during late 2021. During their extensive renovation in early in January 2022, their crew broke through a section of plaster wall, just to see what was behind the wall. To their surprise, the hole revealed a section of a painting. No one could have anticipated that the two paintings delivered by Deeds Scenic Studio were hidden behind the walls installed during Scate’s opening of the Paramount Theatre.
Layers of plaster, lathe, furring strip, and painted mural.Furring strips and lathe were nailed to the painted murals.
Despite bright colors, the murals were extremely damaged. There were hundreds of punctures from nails for furring strips and lathe, sporadic pockets of plaster that had oozed between lathe strips, cut openings for windows, and water stains from seasonal leaks, the paintings remained exceedingly vibrant and appeared in remarkably good shape.
Painted detail from the mural border.
Although I was swamped with work and had no intention of taking any out-of-state work , I began to contemplate the feasibility of a very, very, quick trip west to document the paintings before their removal. I immediately began to act as a resource for the young couple; they were being inundated with opinions regarding removal and restoration.
Over the course of the next two weeks, the Timms sent very detailed pictures of the two murals, and we began a series of discussions about possible options for removal, storage, and preservation. I did my best to educate them about the painting process and various options for removal, storage, repair, and restoration. We scheduled virtual meeting where they walked me through the space, closely examining how the attached to the wall. We were in luck, as the mural was glued to a few layers of wallpaper, meaning that it may easily pop off of the wall.
Green wallpaper under the painted fabric.This was one of two wallpaper layers glued to the backs of the paintings.
Various decorative layers tacked and pasted to the original wooden walls of the building offered a a walk thru time as the space was transferred from one owner to another. Initially, cotton sheeting was tacked onto the wooden walls, the only barrier to the outdoor elements.
A Delta Mills fine sheeting(right) stamp was discovered on this first layer of fabric. Only a layer of thin wallpaper covered the first layer of Delta sheeting (left).
This was likely to provide an air-barrier and uniform surface for the first layer of wallpaper. This first layer of wallpaper was off white with metallic edging.
The first color scheme for the Hub Theatre was cream with metallic scroll work. The interior was very light and simplistic in style.
A decorative border was pasted to the top of each section, somewhat ornate with metallic scrollwork paper atop a creamy background. A few years later, a new color scheme was introduced to the space, one that was much darker. A second layer of wallpaper and border paper were dark green with metallic accents in jeweled colors. The border paper was especially lovely and quite thick. When the building was renovated for a third time in 1915, the green wallpaper was primed white, and the fabric mural pasted on top.
The second color scheme for the Hub Theatre was primarily green with metallic details.The second border for the Hub Theatre. There was metallic detail on the floral border. Detail of second border, found directly under the painted mural.
In 1918 the venue changed hands, the building was renovated, and the theatre was renamed the Paramount. During the renovation plaster walls encapsulated the murals, effectively concealing them for over the next century. In the dark they patiently waited for another renovation; one that may possibly reveal the work of Deeds scenic artist W. C. Connell. would not happen until early January 2022.
The Hub Theatre was purchased and renovated in 1918, becoming the Paramount.This is when the murals became concealed behind new plaster walls.
I flew into Spokane, Washington, and examined the murals for the first time on February 16, 2022. The old Hub Theater in Okanogan is easy to miss. There is no a fly tower, no ornate façade; nothing to announce that it was once featured live theater or movies. The building looks more like an old hardware store than any temple of entertainment. If the Timms had not been standing outside, shouting, and waving their hands, I would have missed it entirely.
The exterior of the old Hub Theater during my visit in February 2022.
My plan was to only take pictures of the murals and leave with only memories. Upon entering the building my heart sank and I knew that there was very little time to save these murals. The relentless drip of water accentuated the dampness of the space. The drips both hit and missed a series of buckets lined up on the floor between the two murals. In previous conversations, the Timms had mentioned their concern of snow melt and a leaking roof. I had no idea it was this bad. I knew that it was just a matter of weeks before the distemper paintings were entirely destroyed.
My initial visit to document the murals. Note the two large garbage cans catching water from the leaking roof and wet floor.
That was when I began to game plan about their immediate removal. The preservation could happen slowly in phases, but there was minimal time to remove the murals from a leaking building.
I could not extend my stay, but I could return in a week. During my brief absence, the Timms frantically prepared the space for the upcoming mural removal. They cleared debris, removed walls, redirected water leaks, and ordered all of the necessary supplies.
On February 28, 2022, I returned to Okanogan and started work the next day. The first mural came down in two hours, the second in less than an hour. As I anticipated, the thick wallpaper backing was key to the murals’ quick release from the wall. Nick, Lisa, and their crew of four helped stabilize the painting as I carefully separated the wallpaper-backed mural from first layer of cotton sheeting that was tacked to the wooden substrate.
A view of the wallpaper backing as the murals were removed from the walls.Removing the murals necessitated that I insert myself in between the wallpaper-backed mural and fabric-covered wall, carefully releasing the wallpaper from the wall.Painted detail showing areas where plaster reached the mural.
After the murals were removed from the wall, each received a preliminary cleaning, and then was rolled, encapsulated, and transferred to a climate-controlled storage room.
A section showing the mural before (right) and after (left) the preliminary cleaning.Rolling the first mural.
The last sections of each mural were completely unsalvageable. This reducing the overall length of each mural to 50-feet. However, many of the unsalvageable scraps were carefully packed in my luggage.
Some areas of the murals were unsalvageable. It is amazing that any of the painting survived.
For the next four months, I began the laborious task of identifying the best method to remove layers of wallpaper from the fragile fabric without damaging the distemper painting. In the end, I was able to lightly mist the paper backing, wait twenty-minutes, and carefully peel the paper off, without damaging the paint.
The first phase of the Okanogan Mural Preservation included wallpaper removal, cleaning, fabric repair, fabric reinforcement, paint consolidation, and preparation for hanging. The work was planned for the first two weeks of August. We ordered materials, located a workspace, and identified local assistants. As the project neared, I watched temperatures soar to 112 degrees Fahrenheit (44 degrees Celsius). This is an area where many homes do not have any type of air-cooling systems. Despite the newly purchased swamp cooler for the Arts and Crafts Building on the fairgrounds, interior temperatures could not reach an acceptable level for art preservation.
We delayed the project until the beginning of October, hoping that the temperatures would drop to an acceptable level in fall. Yet as the project neared, I noticed that temperatures were still in the mid-80s. Crossing my fingers, I hoped for the best. Little did I know that we would have to buy heaters for the end of the project.
On October 7, 2022, I journeyed from Minneapolis to Okanogan. Flying into Spokane, I rented a car and drove the three hours west to the eastern slope of the Cascades
It is a lovely drive in the fall. This time I passed endless miles of harvested fields before entering the Okanogan Valley with acres of apple trees.
Apple trees Just south of Okanogan.Apple trees in Okanogan.
I arrived in Okanogan as sunset approached and soon settled into my new abode. My lodging was at the Timm’s estate, in a separate house once owned by Nick’s late father. With many of the windows facing east, the view was quite stunning with fall colors just starting to peak.
The view from my patio at sunrise.
On Saturday, October 8, Nick Timm and I began to set up my workspace in the Arts and Crafts Building of the Okanogan Fair Grounds. This was not an unfamiliar space, as I had approved the location during my February visit. It was a massive building, with two sets of sinks, counter tops, fantastic lighting, ample electrical outlets, and nearby restrooms. Little did we know that by October the Okanogan fairgrounds would be in the midst of water and sewage troubles. The greatest challenge on Day 1 was access to the building and running water. The fairground’s entrance gates and bathrooms were locked as it was a weekend. This meant crawling over a 4-ft. gate to get into the grounds. Fortunately for me, there were two satellite bathrooms near the railroad tracks and a potable sink to wash my hands.
My workspace was in the Arts & Crafts Building on the Okanogan County fairgrounds. Notice the two small Satellites by on the far left by the railroad tracks.
Less than ideal, it was the lack of running water that concerned me the most.
The building had housed arts and crafts projects during the county fair in September. This mean that there was dirt, flower pollen, and bits of trash all over the place. I needed a clean environment to ensure that dust and debris would not become airborne when I later turned on the box fans. By the end of the day, most of the supplies were unpacked and the murals were ready for the work to begin.
Two layers of wallpaper and border paperon the back of the Okanogan murals.
On October 9, I began the slow and arduous process of wallpaper removal from the back of each mural. It had taken me most of the spring and early summer to come up with a process to remove the paper without damaging the distemper painting. Keep in mind that distemper paint reactivates with water; it is just dry pigment paste mixed with diluted hide glue. I came up with a technique where I misted the paper with distilled water to soften the wallpaper adhesive, effectively releasing it from the painting. In Minnesota, it took a minimum of twenty minutes for the water to penetrate the adhesive, releasing it from the fabric.
When the distilled water reached the last layer of adhesive, strips of wallpaper easily lifted from the fabric.
What I did not anticipate was varying humidity levels in Okanogan. Although, the process remained very successful, it took a bit longer the first day. However, just like my experiments at home, the fabric easily released in big sections, and I was able to complete half of the first mural by the end of the day. Right on schedule, it would take a full four days to remove the wallpaper before starting the preservation of the fabric.
My second day of wallpaper removal was a bit of surprise. That night, the winds picked up and dried everything out. Temperatures dropped and everything began to dry out. This is the type of air where your lips immediately chap, and your skin begins to feel stretched. My wallpaper removal technique was no longer working; the water began to evaporate from the paper before it had a chance to permeate the adhesive. I began to experiment with a series of techniques, refining my process where the wallpaper could easily lift off. Picking at the paper or attempting to remove it when dry caused the paint to immediately release and dust off of the surface; it was too thin. I was already doing a balancing act, dampening the fabric without releasing the distemper paint.
A close-up of the mural fabric and layer of paint. There were many areas with complete paint loss.
On the third day of wallpaper removal, two assistants now helped carefully peel the paper away. One was my full-time onsite assistant Marty Staggs and the other was mural owner Nick Timm. As Timm observed, it was very similar to skinning an animal hide. The trick was knowing when to move on and not stay if paper was stuck on a dry patch; the paper remained stuck in areas where the water failed to permeate the first layer of glue and white primer. I kept repeating, “If it doesn’t come off easy, move along to another section.” We finished removing approximately 95% of all wallpaper.
Only scraps of wallpaper were left on the backside. We did not attempt to remove these at it would have irreparably damaged both the fabric and paint.
On the final day of my first week, we cleaned the space and flipped the murals (painted side up). This was to assess their condition before continuing with the preservation next week. Each painting had held up beautifully during the wallpaper removal.
A fresh layer of muslin was placed below the murals. After cleaning each painted composition, we again cleaned the room to prevent any environmental dust from becoming airborne for the rest of the restoration.
By the end of the day, we secured the edges of each mural, and I gradually dampened the fabric with distilled water, so that any residual creasing or stiffness from the wallpaper adhesive would release. This would help with the upcoming fabric stabilization and patching.
The fabric repair began with patching small holes and continued to muslin backing for large cut openings (previous window openings and of access holes). This coincided with the temperature plummeting to 39 degrees Fahrenheit (3.9 degrees Celsius). As the inside the building was only a few degrees warmer, it was too cold to consolidate paint or patch fabric. So, we had to go out and purchase four large heaters. The irony of postposing this work due to heat was not lost on me. The new heaters, combined with warmer air temperatures during the day, meant that the building was finally warm enough to continue with the preservation.
After patching each drop, I attached the top hanging strip and reinforced both the sides and bottoms of each mural.
Backing the last window opening.
The final workday, October 21, was the hardest day of all; it was a firm deadline. All of the patching and support strips needed to be done by the end of the day if we were to hang them the next day. Nothing could be glued the next day, as they had to be completely dry prior to rolling and storing. I managed to make the deadline, but my body was a little worse for wear.
Saturday, October 22, was my last day on site. I was assisted by Staggs and the Timms. We spent the morning hanging and photographing details. The afternoon was spent preparing murals for storage again. This meant rolling each mural and encapsulating them in plastic.
The murals hanging in the Arts and Crafts Building of the Okanogan County Fairgrounds. October 22, 2022.
I drove back to the Spokane airport on the morning of Sunday, Oct. 23. The drive was absolutely stunning. It gave me some time to reflect on the project and the next steps. I was also taking photographs; source material for my easel art this winter.
The Okanogan Valley on the morning of my departure home.View on my drive from Okanogan to Spokane, Washington.The Columbia River near Grand Coulee.Near Coulee Dam.Near Davenport, Washington.Leaving Spokane, Washington.
J. M. Deeds pictured in the “San Francisco Call” in 1896.
On May 29, 1913, the “Spokane Chronicle” heralded Deed’s scenic enterprise, including a picture of work being done in his studio. The article reported:
“This is the only studio of its kind between Minneapolis and the Coast,” said Mr. Deeds today. “We are prepared to cover the territory completely, including states of Wyoming, Utah, and the western Canadian provinces, and we expect to invade the east. There is no reason why we should not do this since we are prepared to complete with them in workmanship as well as salesmanship.” Mr. Deeds has been engaged in the production of scenery for 10 years and during this time has traveled extensively, visiting the leading studios in the east and middle west.”
Deeds studio pictured in the “Spokane Chronicle” in 1913.
The two Okanogan murals may be all that remains of the Deeds Scenic Studio. Theaters were repainted, renovated, and razed. It is not enough that an artifact survives. There must be stewards to take care of it. It is extremely fortunate that the Okanogan murals were found by the Timms and that they acted immediately. The Timms continue to raise funds for the second phase of preservation that will focus on areas of paint loss. If you able to support the preservation of these murals, please visit the Timm’s Go Fund Me site:
William H. Lemle worked as a scenic artist at Sosman & Landis shortly after WWI ended. He then established his own scenic studio, still renting space in the Sosman & Landis main studio on Clinton St. He would remain in the space for over a decade, as the first iteration of Sosman & Landis closed its doors, and a second iteration of the firm began under the management of Thomas G. Moses and Fred R. Megan. In the end, it was Lemle who purchased the last remnants of Sosman & Landis stock from Moses and P. Lester Landis.
The scenic studio shuffle is complicated, and Lemle was in the right place at the right time. Sosman & Landis Scene Painting Studio closed its doors by the end of 1923. This ended the first iteration of the firm; the main studio on S. Clinton Street was built in 1886 and considered one of the best shop spaces in the country. In 1924, the Sosman & Landis name (and goodwill) was sold to Moses and Megan, but they did not lease the studio space. Instead, the second iteration of Sosman & Landis established their business offices at Kedzie Ave.
Several parties vied for the highly coveted main studio space at 417-419 S. Clinton St. Prior to the firm’s closure, both William H. Lemle and Chicago Studios rented space at Sosman & Landis’ main studio. Lemle remained in the space after the firm’s closure, eventually becoming a subcontractor for the National Theater Supply Co.
The main studio for Sosman & Landis, later marketed as the scenic studio of William Lemle, Inc. This image was brought to my attention by Bob Foreman. It is part of the Rick R. Zimmerman Collection on Theatrical Stage Lighting Equipment (https://library.osu.edu/collections/spec.tri.0012 ): National Theatre Supply Company Pink Sheet vol. 1 no. 7, 1927 May 10, Box Accession No. TRI.2018.0036.001. Sosman & Landis main studio on S. Clinton St., pictured in 1910.From the Waszut-Barrett Theatre Collection.The exterior of the Sosman & Landis studio on S. Clinton St. in Chicago.From the Waszut-Barrett Theatre Collection.
Lemle’s early painting career included sign painting, lamp shade decoration, panoramas, and advertising curtains in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. He was a bit of a Renaissance Man, always on the verge of something new, an innovator, with an abundance of talent and ambition. Like many of his predecessors, Lemle entered the theatre industry as a performer, and immediately tried his hand at playwriting and production. All the while, he continued to work as a decorative painter and scenic artist.
I have written about Lemle past posts, exploring his early life and later accomplishments. This post for Lemle, as Sosman & Landis Employee No. 90, gives me a chance to piece everything together that I have uncovered to date. His life and career are incredibly complex and difficult to decipher as he accomplished so much in a relatively short period of time.
William Henry Lemle was born in Philadelphia on July 29, 1871. The son of Francis P. Lemle (1841-1925) and Margaret A. Wooley (1847-1906), he was one of four children born to the couple. His siblings were Francis E. Lemle (b. 1864), David J. Lemle (b. 1865), and Martha Lemle (b. 1876). His father, Francis P. Lemle, tried his hand at a few professions when Lemle was young, but primarily worked as a salesman. By the early 1890s, Lemle followed in his father’s footsteps and also worked sales; a skill that would repeatedly benefit him over the years. Throughout his career, Lemle successfully marketed his skills as a painter, performer and producer.
He remained close to his family in the early years, staying in Philadelphia when he entered the workforce. By the age of 22 yrs. old, Lemle was still living with his family at 1826 Judson St. In 1893, the “Philadelphia Directory” listed William Lemle as a salesman. That same year he married Elizabeth “Bessie” C. Cushing (1872-1905) in New Jersey. Despite marrying in another state, the young couple returned to live in Philadelphia where they set up house with Lemle’s extended family. They remained in the family home until 1895. In 1896, William and Bessie Lemle celebrated the birth of their first child, Ethel M. Lemle. At the time, Lemle was working as a shade maker, painting a variety of scenes on the shades. For a little context, late-nineteenth-century window shades were constructed of thick cotton or linen, and often glazed or decorated with painted scenes and ornament.
While working in the decorative arts industry, Lemle came in contact with scenic artist William Cook – soon to be his future brother-in-law. The same year that Ethel was born, Lemle’s sister, Martha Christina Lemle married William Harman Cook. On June 21, 1896, the “Philadelphia Times” announced, “COOK-LEMLE – At 2589 Montgomery avenue, Philadelphia, June 4 by Rev. S. G. Shannon, William H. Cook to Miss Martha C. Lemle, both of this city.” (page 12). Cook made quite a name for himself in the scenic art field, with his own son continuing in the trade. It makes sense that Lemle also worked with his brother-in-law over the years and was thus introduced to the Philadelphia Theatre scene.
From 1896 to 1898, Lemle continued to work as a decorative painter and paper-hanger, seldom straying from the window shade industry. By the fall of 1899, a second daughter was born to the couple. On September 27, 1899, Eloise F. Lemle, arrived, prompting her family to seek larger living accommodations.
The 1900 US Federal Census listed the William H. Lemle family living at 1221 Ridge Ave, in Philadelphia. In addition to an expanding family, Lemle also began to expand his business interests. By 1900 Lemle had established two companies – the Novelty Window Shade Co. and Lemle & Hemple. Both firms were listed in “Boyd’s Co-Partnership and Residence Business Directory of Philadelphia City” that year. 1221 Ridge Ave. was listed as the business offices for both firms. Interestingly, Lemle & Hemple was a company that specialized in gas machines, having nothing to do with scenic art or the theatrical trade. Hemple was only a few years younger than Lemle, but was also lived in the Lemle home at 1221 Ridge Ave. The Lemle & Hemple firm was very short-lived.
Lemle’s Novelty Window Shade Co. at 1221 Ridgeway Ave.Lemle & Hemple at 1221 Ridgeway Ave.
In 1901, Lemle established another partnership, forming a scenic art concern. Lemle’s new business partner was Philadelphia sign painter D. H. C. Warren. As with Hemple, Lemle’s relationship with Warren was also short-lived.
Lemle and Warren made headlines after the failure of a New Year’s Eve display. On Jan. 2, 1902, “The Philadelphia Inquirer” announced, “Winds Rattled Figures.” The article continued, “The two most disappointed men over the failure of Father Time and the Angel of Peace to perform their proper duties are D. H. C. Warren and William H. Lemle who designed the feature and suggested it to the committee. They suffer not only artistic loss, but financial as well by the interference of the roaring winds with the working of the illuminated figures. What was designed as a picturesque and imposing feature was turned into a grotesque display. Father Time and the Angel of Peace hung from the tower and coquetted, with each other in the most amusing way. They looked for all the world as though they were in the death embrace. While being hanged in effigy from the top of City Hall Tower. The financial loss for the failure, it was explained by Jacob E. Henderson, a member of the committee, will fall on the contractors and not on the city. “We were doubtful about the success of the scheme when it was suggested,” he said, “but the men who proposed it were so earnest that we determined to give it a trial. Our agreement was that if it worked we would pay $350 agreed upon, while if it was not a success we would merely defray the cost of the materials used” (page 2).
On January 3, 1902, the ”Philadelphia Inquirer” reported, “Designers Demonstrate That Only High Winds Prevented Display” (page 2). The article continued, “In order to demonstrate that the angel of peace, which failed to take flight in the New Year’s Eve display, was in proper working order, D. H. Warren and William H. Lemle, designers of this feature of the display, yesterday afternoon gave a special demonstration on North Broad Street. At a given signal, the figure, illuminated with candles, left City Hall and started on its journey toward Vin Street. A wire stretched across the street above Race street halted the figure for a minute or so by did not stop its journey, It only required a few twists of the main cable and the angel, with horn on her lips floated triumphantly to her destination. In every respect the exhibition was a success, and the projectors of the scheme expressed regret that the same favorable conditions did not prevail on New Year’s Eve. They ascribe their failure to properly manipulate the figures on that occasion to the high winds and an accident to one of the wires.
Fully a thousand persons witnessed the triumphant descent of the angel yesterday and lustily cheered when the figure landed safely at Broad and Vine Streets. Both Lemle and Warren devoted considerable time and money to the construction of Father Time and the Angel of Peace, and were deeply disappointed at the failure which attended their portion of the celebration of the New Year. They contend that the weather conditions were such as to make it impossible to carry out their plans.”
The dissolution of Lemle and Warren’s partnership occurred just prior to period of great loss. Between 1903 and 1906 Lemle’s older brother, mother and wife passed away. His brother, David Lemle, was the first to go. On Nov. 20, 1903, the “Philadelphia Inquirer” reported, “On the 19th last, David J. Lemle, son of Francis P. and Martha A. Lemle, in his 39th year. Due notice of the funeral will be given, from his late residence, 1847 North Judson street” (page 7).
During this time, Lemle continued to work as a scenic artist and sign painter. He advertised in the “White Letters” section of the “Philadelphia Directory” in 1904. Interestingly, Lemle’s name was listed just below that of scenic artist Otto Armbruster, son of the famous scenic artist Mathias Armbruster of Columbus, Ohio. Otto also worked with Thomas G. Moses over the years, and possibly at Sosman & Landis.
Lemle was actually listed twice below Armbruster, and his second listing advertised:
“Sign Letters of all kinds. Enameled, Gold, Wood, &c. Sole agent for Stamped Aluminum Letters, Wholesale and Retail. Agents wanted. Phone PO La8 2487 0 1221 Ridge Ave.”
William H. Lemle’s firm at 1221 Ridgeway Ave.
Lemle also became associated with the Criterion Dramatic Association. Both Lemle and his wife began performing with this amateur theatre group. It remains unclear as to whether Lemle painted the sets or not. However, Lemle soon became the Criterion Dramatic Association’s business manager.
On April 10, 1904, the “Philadelphia Inquirer” reported, “The Criterion Dramatic Association is one of the oldest and most widely known amateur dramatic associations in Philadelphia. The Criterion was founded several years ago by a few young people merely to satisfy their ambition in ways of amusement.” The group performed their productions at the New Mercantile Hall. That spring, Lemle played the role of Col. Bonham in “Arizona.” On May 8, 1904, the “Philadelphia Inquirer” reported that Lemle’s wife, Bessie, was also one of the principal players for the company (page 36).
Lemle’s wife, Bessie, passed away the next year. On Sept. 4, 1905, the “Philadelphia Inquirer” announced, “BETH C. wife of William H. Lemle (nee Cushing). Relatives and friends are invited to attend the funeral services, at her late residence, 1221 Ridge Ave on Tuesday, at 2PM, Interment private at Greenwood Knights of Pythias Cemetery.” She was buried at Greenwood Cemetery in Philadelphia on September 6, 1905. Church records for her burial note that cause of death was “albrumurod”; I have yet to locate what that medical term is, and wonder if it was misspelled. Two weeks later Lemle posted an advertisement in the “Philadelphia Inquirer.” On Sept. 18, 1905, Lemle advertised,
Soon after his wife died, Lemle moved to the home of Martha Lemle Cook and William Cook. Martha was five years younger than her brother, born on June 4, 1876. Instantly, she became a surrogate mother for two young nieces. Lemle continued to work as both a painter and performer during this time, securing whatever work he could find. However, it was his stage career that took off like a rocket.
By 1906, Lemle was also performing as the lead in numerous comic roles, including Deacon Coleman and Judge Schneider in “The Bronco Buster.” At the time, he was part of English actress, Alyce Kee Kan’s company. Advertisements for this “high class musical comedy drama by Ed deCorsia” were placed across the region, including the Chronicle Hall in DeKalb, Illinois. On Dec. 17, 1906, “The Daily Chronicle” advertised that the production traveled with “special scenery, proper costuming and novel stage effects” (page 5). “Not Like Other Girls,” starring Alyce Kee Nan and Lemle was also performed that winter. Lemle soon caught the eye of Fred C. Conrad and began touring with his company as the starring actor. With Conrad’s Company, he not only performed, but also penned the play adaptation of “Monte Cristo.” In the fall of 1907, Lemle was mentioned in newspapers across the country for his contributions to the popularly received production. When the company performed at the Opera House in Paris, Kentucky, “Bourbon News” reported, “Mr. Conrad has had unlimited experience in producing ‘Monte Cristo’ and his especial care is shown in his use of Wm. Lemle’s arrangement of the play. Mr. Lemle will be remembered by most people interested in the drama, as one of the most talented and scholarly actors on the American stage. In his thoroughness and high ideals, he belongs virtually to the old school, and it was in this way of thinking and doing that he prepared and starred in ‘Monte Cristo’ under Mr. Conrad’s management. When we go to the theatre to see this famous character, we want to see him in the play as prepared by Mr. Lemle and presented by Mr. Conrad’s Company, we can expect to see him step from the pages of romance to the footlights in the full power and dignity of his personality.”
1907 advertisement for Paris, Kentucky.
When the production toured to Huntington, Indiana, the “Daily News-Democrat” reported, “the production which is to be seen at the New Theatre has the authority of one of the most thoroughly trained and accomplished leading actors on the American stage, William Lemle who through presentations of the play in all the leading cities and during several entire seasons has brought his part of Dantes and the play to a finely complete and finished condition. Wm. Lemle who is a scholar, as well as an actor and stage director, has provided a production of ‘Monte Cristo’ which may well be expected to reveal the full power that made it famous at the New theatre Monday night.”
On September 18, 1907, the “Van Wert Daily Bulletin” reported, “Mr. William Lemle, who handles the lead in the company to appear here; it is said that he is exceptionally clever in this character and his support unusually good” (page 3). Other articles heralded Lemle’s staging of the duel scene. The “Daily News-Democrat” published an article entitles “A Famous Duel,” reporting, “The memorable duel scene in ‘Monte Cristo,’ as well as such climaxes as ‘The World is Mine’ will be irresistible magnets for the coming engagement of the play at the new theatre September 16. The duel scene in this production was introduced by William Lemle, who presented the play with great success in all the leading cities and it is as exact a reproduction as possible of the most thrilling combat that ever took place on a field of honor, the ‘meeting’ of Del Frenchi and Chateau Renaud in the Fountainbleau Forest, near Paris. It is a deadly duel with all the details closely following the historical combat described by Benjamin D’Isreali.”
By 1908 Lemle was listed as the producer for “Monte Cristo.” On Jan. 3, 1908, the “Jefferson County Republican” (De Soto, Missouri) reported that the W. H. Lemle Company was presenting “Monte Cristo” (page 5).
The next year, Lemle was associated with another touring production. In 1909, Lemle starred in Henry Thorn Hum’s biblical romance, “Moses, the Prince of Egypt,” (“The Pemiscot Argus,”Caruthersville, Missouri, 16 Sept. 1909, page 1). As with “Monte Cristo,” Lemle’s production toured throughout the Midwestern region, playing in a dozen states. On Sept. 17, 1909, “The Commercial Gazette,” of Union City, Tennessee, reported, “The company presenting this splendid play is said to the one of uncommon excellence and is headed by that finished actor, William Lemle, who portrays the part of Moses” (page 7). On September 24, 1909, the “Weekly Citizen Democrat,” of Poplar Bluff, Missouri, announced, “On October 9 a really notable engagement has been contracted for. On that date the ‘Moses Prince of Egypt’ company, controlled by Fred G. Conrad, will present the sterling Biblical drama of that name…The company is said to be one of uncommon excellence, headed by William Lemle, who portrays the part of Moses” (page 5). The show traveled with elaborate scenery. On Oct. 1, 1909, the “Weekly Citizen Democrat” detailed, “It will be seen at the opera house Tuesday, September 21, and is said to be a gorgeous spectacle with a wealth of special scenery, electrical effects, and historically correct costumes” (page 2). By 1910, several amateur groups were featuring the production, so Lemle returned to star in “Monte Cristo.”
On March 10, 1910, “The Hope Pioneer” of Hope, North Dakota,” reported, “The Drama, Monte Cristo presented at the Opera House Monday evening by Wm. Lemle and company may have been the best play of the season under different conditions. The play, with the exception of the first act which was played in the most lifeless manner, was above the average. However, owing to the long waits between acts and the late start, most people lost interest and left before the last act” (page 4).
On April 14, 1910, the “Turtle Mountain Star” of Rolla, North Dakota, reported, “Monte Cristo still holds its own and sways its old fascination over the theatre going public is proven by the remarkable success of William H. Lemle as “Edmund Dantes” in Fred G. Conrad’s production of that play. Mr. Lemle is now in his fourth season appearing in that part, and bids fair to rival Charles Fechter and James O’Neil in reputation as Dumas’ romantic hero. Mr. Lemle will appear at the opera house in Rolla, N. D. on April 15, 1910.
In 1910 the US Federal Census still listed Lemle’s occupation as an actor in the theatre industry. Lemle and his daughters were still living with his sister and her family. The Lemle-Cook household included William H. Cook, Martha Lemle Cook, Charles Cook (their son), Lemle, Lemle’s two daughters, and his father (Francis P. Lemle). Both William Cook and his son Charles Cook ran a scenic art studio.
Lemle’s next two productions were “The Rosary” and “Rock of Ages.” “Rock of Ages” was written by Edward E. Rose. With eight speaking parts, the play centered around the white slave trade and the power of faith. Both productions found a stronghold in a variety of theaters across the country. Although Lemle continued to meet with a certain amount of success, touring with a company began to take its toll. Lemle’s interests began to drift elsewhere as he contemplated leaving the road. In 1911, the “Indianapolis Star” reported, “William Lemle, manager of ‘Rock of Ages,’ coming to the Park tomorrow, has struck upon a novel idea to add to the many souvenirs that he has gathered while touring the country in the capacity of a theatrical manager, Mr. Lemle is desirous of securing the autograph of the mayor and the chief of police in every city that he visits. Mr. Lemle proposes to bid farewell to the show business next season and retire to his farm in Oklahoma. He was last in Indianapolis as manager of “The Rosary” company last season” (27 Sept. 1911, page 7).
Lemle relocated to Chicago, not Oklahoma. In the Windy City, Lemle continued to work as a performer, but began to expand is business interests. On May 3, 1912, the “Chicago Englewood Times” listed Lemle as part of the cast for “Thelma” at the National Theater (page 8). The production starred Irene Summerly.
From 1912 until 1915, Lemle tried his hand at a variety partnerships. All the while, he continued to financially struggle. He partnered with Daniel L. Martin in 1914 to establish, Martin & Lemle, Inc. One of their touring showing included “September Morn” (”The Post-Crescent, Appleton, WI, 25 Aug 1915, page 3). In 1915, this partnership expanded to include Edward J. McArdle to establish Lemle & Martin by 1915. Their firm was listed in the “National Corporation Reporter” that summer. In 1916, William Lemle and Daniel L. Martin were managers of “September Morn” musical comedy company. Their business endeavor did not go so well after they failed to pay the necessary royalties. The box receipts of their company were seized in Larned, Kansas. The “Hutchinson Gazette” reported, “an attachment on their property for $781.98, claimed to be due for royalty on the play” (27 Feb. 1916, page 9). Half of the box office receipts were collected for payment due to the corporation that owned the copyright.
This seems to have been a definitive moment for Lemle. He left the road and began diversifying his business interests in both Chicago and Philadelphia. In short, Lemle established and became an officer in multiple organizations. At first, he invested in silent films.
I’ll start in Philadelphia where Lemle invested established a film studio. In 1920, William H. and Charles Cooks were working as scenic artists at the Lemle picture studio building. The firm made newspapers that year when a telephone pole crashed into the building (“Philadelphia Inquirer,” 3 Nov. 1920, page 19). Previously, Cook and his son worked as scenic artists for the Lubin Motion Picture Co. Lemle was also associated with the Art Film Co., another motion picture machine company.
In Chicago, Lemle was linked to a variety of Chicago firms, including Sosman & Landis Co., Allardt Advertising Company, the Hoyland-Lemle Advertising Co., and the Lemle-Barrett Company, Inc.
Lemle’s career at this point is intertwined with that of Charles L. Hoylund and the Allardt Advertising Co. Lemle’s entry into advertising is what kept him financially afloat for the next few decades.
For context, here is a little background on both Charles Hoylund and their introduction to the Allardt Bros., as they are part of Lemle’s history.
Charles Leroy Hoyland was born on Sept. 24, 1885, in Illinois. So he was fourteen years younger than Lemle. Hoyland was the only child of James Andrew Hoyland (1861-1918) and Carrie Major (1866-1931). By the time he was twenty years old, Hoyland was working at a theater in Springfield, Illinois. In 1905, Hoylund began managing George W. Chatterton’s Opera House. He was in the right place, at the right time, and met all of the right people while working for Chatterton. On January 28, 1905, the “Herald and Review” reported, “Manager George W. Chatterton of the Chatterton Opera House, Springfield, Ill., has decided to dispose of his jewelry store that he may devote his entire time to his rapidly increasing theatrical interests. His large stock of jewelry is being sold and Manager Chatterton will hereafter be found either in the box office of the Chatterton or in his private office on the second floor. George Hickock, treasurer, and C. L Hoyland, assistant, will have charge of the box-office” (page 19). For several years, George W. Chatterton Jr. managed opera houses for his father.
Hoyland quickly moved from box office assistant into theatre management. This is likely where he first encountered Lemle, as he toured with “Monte Cristo” throughout the region. By 1907, Hoylund relocated to Wayne, Michigan, where he continued managing theaters. In Michigan, Hoyland married Frances H. Putman Thompson. He and his bride went from one project to the next. By 1910, the Hoylunds were living in Illinois, and this was when Hoyland became associated with the Allardt Bros. Circuit. His timing was impeccable. Between 1910 and 1913, the Allardt circuit grew from one theater in Terre Haute, Indiana, to twenty-four theatres throughout the Midwest and Canada. Their circuit was composed of both vaudeville and legitimate theaters.
In 1910, Hoyland was working at Allardt’s Lyric Theatre in South Bend, Indiana. His connection with the brothers was cemented, however, when he was invited as their guest at the Theatrical Mechanic Association in 1911. On Jan. 9, 1911, “The South Bend Tribune” reported that Hoyland was initiated into the Theatrical Mechanical Association, South Bend Lodge, No. 120, the guest of Messrs. C. J. and Louis F. Allardt of the Orpheum. In 1911, the Allardt Bros. acquired the Broadway Theater Hotel in Superior, Wisconsin. Hoyland began managing the venue in 1912. Hoyland became the Allardts’ “right-hand man” and business boomed throughout the region.
On Feb. 23, 1912, the “Virginia Enterprise” in Minnesota reported, “The Allardt circuit will, with the opening of the new house here, be divided into two circuits, the southern and the northern. All the theaters north of Chicago will be in the northern division. The acts that will appear here will be routed not only though the Allardt houses but into several of those owned by close allies of the big firm. It is planned to open every act in the Northern division of the circuit at the Lyric. From here the shows will proceed to Fort William and then back to Superior, St. Paul and Minneapolis and south to the southern points on the big wheel” (page 4). By 1913 Hoylund managed the Allardts’ New Orpheum Theatre in Racine, Wisconsin. He continued to climb in the Allardt enterprise, becoming both treasurer, and managing their new advertising firm. On Feb. 1, 1914, Chicago’s “Inter Ocean” listed Hoyland as not only Allardt Bros. treasurer, but also Allardt Advertising Company director.
On Dec. 21, 1913, the “Inter Ocean” published an article about the Allardt Bros. rise to fame. The article reported, “The firm was founded by three brothers with H. J. (senior partner of the firm) and L. F. Allardt in Chicago and C. J. Allardt directing affairs in South Bend, Indiana. The firm diversified, investing in Boyle Woolfolks, Inc. (producer of musical comedy tabloids), Robert Sherman (dramatic tabloid producer), the Alamo Film company, and the Allardt Advertising company.” At the time, Allardt Advertising Co. was considered of the biggest firms in vaudeville.”
Hoylund continued his association at Allardt Advertising Co. for the next several years. His 1918 WWI Draft Registration card listed that he was an advertising agent for the Allardt Advertising Co., then located in 316 Westminster Building.
Enter, Lemle.
By Feb. 19, 1920, Lemle was listed as one of four directors for the Allardt Advertising Co. when the number of Directors was increased from three to four. The other three were Charles L. Hoyland, Carrie Hoyland, and Mabel Shearer. When exactly he actually began working for the firm remains a mystery. The 1920 US Federal Census listed William H. Lemle as a salesman for a Manufacturing concern, living at 211 Ellis Ave. in Chicago. He was listed as a lodger of Vera J. Bales at the address.
As with other studios, the Allardt Advertising Co. struggled with collecting payment from their clients. This became increasingly common throughout the 1920s, and many scenic studios folded, despite the phenomenal profits provided by advertising curtains. Collecting money owed became a full-time job. On September 16, 1921, Allardt Advertising Co. published the following Want Ad in the “Alton Evening Telegraph”:
“Party whose present occupation will permit him to act as collector for a Chicago concern. Only a very small part of time required. Accounts are payable quarterly and will aggregate about $500.00 each quarter. 5 per cent commission. Good references or bond necessary. Address Allardt Advertising company, Inc. 417 S. Clinton street, Chicago, or call Mr. Kentnick at Illini Hotel” (page 13). That address was the same address as the main studio for Sosman & Landis; Allardt Advertising Co. was renting space from Sosman & Landis, likely subcontracting some work too.
In 1922, the Allardt Advertising Co. business offices were located at 1100-1109 N. Dearborn St., Chicago, but the firm still rented space on S. Clinton St. That February Allardt Advertising Co. increased its capital stock from $5,000.00 to $50,000.00, and then changed its name to Hoyland-Lemle Company. In April 1922, the Hoylund-Lemle Co. offices relocated from their temporary 56 West Randolph Street to 417 South Clinton Street in Chicago. Again, 417 S. Clinton St. was the main studio and business offices for Sosman & Landis. Before the name-change in 1922, the official studio address for the Allardt Advertising Co. was listed as 417 S. Clinton St. Charles Hoylund and William Lemle worked closely with Sosman & Landis on a variety of projects. As the demand for scenic illusion for the stage declined, the demand for advertising products and services increased. Hoyland and Lemle saw an opportunity, bridging the gap while staying in the same prime location – 417 S. Clinton St. This space remained the one of the best shops in the country to manufacture a painted product. As Sosman & Landis work dwindled, Hoyland-Lemle Co. work skyrocketed. Back to 1922…
Certificates were granted for both of capital stock and name changes on March 4, 1922. In addition to a name change, the objective of the company also changed. The original object of the company:
“To engage in and carry on a general advertising business by the circulation and distribution of display cards, signs, posters, dodgers, handbills, programmes, banners and flags, to be placed in and on railroad cars, street cars, steamboats, cabs, hacks, omnibuses, stage, and all kinds of conveyances used for passengers or any other purpose. To display stationary or movable or changeable signs, cards, pictures, designs, mottoes, etc., operated by clockwork, electricity or any other power, to use, place and display the same in theatres, depots, hotels, halls and other public places. To make contracts with individuals and corporations for the exclusive use of their property and to purchase, control and use individual rights, easements and contracts, and to have all the rights, powers and privileges and franchises incident to and granted to corporations organized by virtue of the law of Illinois.”
The new objective in 1922 stated:
“To carry on the business of advertising contractors and agents and any other business which may be usually carried on in connection with such business; to lease property and real estate for the purpose of exhibiting advertising signs; to make, manufacture and display advertising curtains in theatres, halls and other places of amusement; to carry on the business of originating, composing and devising forms of advertisements and advertising matter for others and publishing and securing the publication of the same and all other matters thereto pertaining. To manufacture, buy, sell, import, export and deal in advertising novelties and devices of every kind and description, including raw materials used in the manufacture thereof and to conduct the business of printing, stamping, lithographing, engraving, and binding in connection therewith. To act as agent of representative of corporations, firms and individuals and as such to develop and extend the business interests of firms, corporations and individuals.”
At the time, certificates for the change were signed by Charles L. Hoyland, Carrie M. Hoyland William Lemle, and Maybelle Shearer. M. Shearer would become a key player in another Lemle business endeavor. The Lemle-Barrett Co. The same year that Allardt Advertising Company became Hoyland-Lemle Co., Lemle partnered with John P. Barrett.
Barrett was the manager of Chicago’s National Theatre. The Lemle-Barrett Company, Inc. was a corporation established to manage movie houses in 1922. On Oct 5, 1922, the “Blue Island Sun Standard” reported, “The National Theater on the south side has been leased by John P. Barrett and William H. Lemle for a term of years and opened its season Sunday with “Why Wives God Wrong”…Mr. Barrett, who has been manager of this theater for the past twelve years” (page 9). The new company of was formed manage to moving picture venues, or “picture theaters” (“Moving Picture World, Nov-Dec 1922). The offices for the Lemle-Barrett Company, Inc. were located at 6219 S. Halsted St. This is the same address for the National Theatre and future National Theatre Supply Co. The primary focus of the business was motion picture production. The new company was listed in the New Corporations section from the Oct. 26, 1922, issue of “Manufacturer’s News. “Lemle-Barrett Company, Inc., 6219 S. Halsted St. William Lemle, John P. Barrett, M. Schearer; $5,000, motion pictures. William Lemle, John P. Barrett, M. Shearer. Cor., Hoyland-Lemle Co., Inc. 417 S. Clinton St.” The address, 6219 S. Halsted, was in the Englewood neighborhood, between West 63rd Street and Peoria Drive; it was the address for the National Theater. The venue had opened in 1904 as a vaudeville theater known as the Avenue Theatre. In 1908, it was refurbished, becoming a movie theater until the early 1930s. Over the decades, then venue was known as the Ace Theatre and Kim Theatre, until it permanently closed in 1966.
Lemle invested in the motion picture industry in Chicago and with his brother-in-law William H. Cook in Philadelphia. Keep in mind that motion picture theaters not only purchased equipment, but also painted settings that framed a projection surface and necessary draperies. Many scenic artists began specializing in designing a variety of cinema stages.
On Sept 29, 1922 the “Englewood Times” ”reported, “National Theatre is to reopen Oct. 1. The National Theatre in the south side, has been leased by John P. Barrett and William H. Lemle, for a term of years and will open its season on Sunday, October first with “Why Wives Go Wrong.” A phenomenal hit, that is fairly coining money for its producers, Ralph Ketterling and C.S. Primrose. The company presenting the play at the National has been especially organized and will tour the vicinity surround Chicago, while the company which has been playing the piece on the road will start eastward with Boston for the Thanksgiving destination. While the opening of the National will be given to this road show, it is the intention of Mr. Barrett, who has been manager of this theatre for the past twelve years, to install a high class and dramatic stock company which will begin its season immediately following the termination of the engagement of “Why Wives Go Wrong” (page 7). In 1923 the Lemle-Barrett Company, Inc., was located at 1539 Milwaukee Ave. in Chicago. The firm did not last much longer after that, and Lemle began to focus much of his energy on other business endeavors.
But wait, there’s more! Lemle also established Lemle Incorporated in 1922. This business continued for over a decade, operating in the background until 1934. As with the various Sosman & Landis business, they all look very separate on paper, but they are all part of one big operation.
1922 was not only the beginning of new partnerships, but also the beginning of a new chapter in his personal life. On May 17, Charles L. Hoyland married his second wife, Anna E Kentnick (also spelled Kentnich). Kentnick was the daughter of Allardt employee, William J. Kentnick, and very much a sign of the times. Kentnick was quite independent, employed as a stenographer in a law office.
Keep in mind that stockholders at Sosman & Landis decided to liquidate all of their assets in 1923. This is when the first iteration of the company closes. In 1923, Moses wrote: “On our return to Chicago we had a little chat with Fred Megan about buying into the company and getting Hoyland and Lemle out. D.S. Hunt is also bobbing about for the lease of the studio.” Now, Hunt was doing a similar thing as Hoyland and Lemle. He was deeply involved with Sosman & Landis, New York Studios (their eastern affiliate) and Chicago Studios (also using space at 417 S. Clinton St.). So this makes a couple individuals representing completing business entities racing around to acquire the coveted Sosman & Landis address and assets as the firm folded. They were like vultures, rapidly pecking away at carcass.
Hoyland-Lemle quickly became known as a major advertising curtain concern. On May 18, 1923, “The Gazette” of Cedar Rapids, Iowa, credited the Hoylund-Lemle Co. with a new illuminated street scene for the Majestic Theatre. The article reported, “The curtain was installed today by H. L. Winkler of the Hoylund-Lemle company of Chicago, one of the largest curtain advertising companies in the country. The curtain is built so that by the manipulation of lights it presents either a night scene or a day scene. An artistic coloring effect results when soft lights are turned on back of the curtain so that it appears as a panoramic view of the city at night. Many local business firms have reserved space on the curtain which provides an excellent background for their advertisements. The curtain will be shown for the first time Sunday when the Dixon Players open an engagement here ” (page 13). The “Gazette” article’s use of “illuminated” indicates translucent sections on the ad drop with backlighting. In other words, street lamps, windows, or stars in night sky would glow for the nighttime depiction. The street scene was a success. On June 2, 1923, the Gazette reported, “Last night was the first time the boys had seen the new illuminated curtain at the Majestic and when it was shown, they burst into a round of applause” (page 15).
To clarify…this is a translucent street scene with advertising spaces placed in the composition. The advertisements were incorporated into the architecture of buildings, street signs, walls, marquees, windows, etc. This also means that the ads were visible during the production, an appealing prospect for any merchant. In a way, it’s similar to a brand name product appearing in a television show or movie. Traditionally, advertising curtains were lowered at specific times during a production, coming in between scenes or acts. Ad spaces traditionally created a border around a central composition. They were also incorporated into the ornament of the surround. Over time, the number of ad spaces multiplied, greatly encroaching upon the central picture and reducing its dominance in the overall composition. Lee Lash became quite well known for his advertising curtains too, and raked in massive profits.
On June 17, 1924, the “Quincy Daily Herald” reported, “William Lemle, of Chicago, president of the Hoyland-Lemle company, here for the opening of Washington Square Theater, will leave Tuesday evening for Omaha. It was Mr. Lemle’s company that installed the night and day transformation street scene curtain in the new theater. Fred Loomis is the company’s local representative” (page 16).
Despite its initial success and rise to the top, the Hoyland-Lemle Co. also began to fail. By 1926, both Hoyland and Lemle begin focusing on other companies. In 1926, Lemle opened William Lemle Company, Incorporated. This is not to be confused with his 1922 firm, Lemle Incorporated. In 1926, Lemle’s firm also became associated with the National Theatre Supply Co. as a subcontractor. Just as in the past, Lemle diversified and represented a variety of interests in the advertising game. All of his firms did quite well in the beginning. Lemle’s 1927 letterhead read:
“William Lemle Inc. Theatrical scenery and drapery. Executive office and studios 417-419 South Clinton Street, Chicago. Telephone State 0619.”
1929 Lemle letterhead.1930 Lemle letterhead.
Lemle continued to expand as his work for National Theatre Supply continued to increase. He continued to expand his staff. On Dec. 2, 1927, the “Chicago Tribune” published the following want ad: “Bonaz Machine Operators – Lemle Studio, 417 S. Clinton-st.” (page 41). Bonaz machines were used for embroidery, suggesting an increase in fabric draperies for theatre installations, such as main curtains.
In regard to the declining Hoyland-Lemle business endeavor. The last mention that I have located of Hoyland-Lemle in newspapers involved a lawsuit against the Strong Motor Co. It was mention on April 16, 1927 in the “Tampa Times” (page 19). About this same time, Hoyland established the Charles L. Hoyland Co. This is also around the same time that Lemle becomes deeply involved with the National Theatre Supply Co.
Early in 1927, Thomas G. Moses wrote, “Another rumor that the National Theatre Supply Co. will take over our old Studio. Lemle is interested and wants me to come with him.” By the summer of 1928, Moses wrote, “I have agreed to join Lemle at our old Studio, which will pay me from $8,000 to $10,000 a year.” Moses began working for Lemle and the National Theatre Supply Co. at this time, still painting in the old Sosman & Landis studio; the same studio space that he began working in when it was first constructed in1886.
During the summer of 1927, Lemle’s association with the National Theatre Supply Co. was also mentioned in “National Pink Sheet. On June 10, 1927, National Theatre Supply Co. announced their formation of a new scenery and drape department, managed by P. Lester Landis. Again, Perry “Lester” Landis the son of Sosman & Landis founder, Perry Landis (page 2).
The old Sosman & Landis studio was pictured on the “National Pink Sheet Cover,” now captioned: “Spacious scenic studio of William Lemle Inc. of Chicago, the entire output of which will be distributed through national service.” The “National Pink Sheet” article reported that Lester Landis was “quite well known to the trade, having been member of the original Sosman & Landis Company in Chicago. With 12 years experience in all branches of scenery production and stagecraft.” The article continued, “Arrangements have been made to distribute the entire output of the Wm. Lemle, inc. Studios, located in Chicago. This company, with one of the finest and best equipped scenic studios in existence, and in charge of Wm. Lemle, also a former associate of Mr. Landis in the original Sosman & Landis studios, will produce all of the stage curtains, both fabric and painted, house draperies and novelty stage settings of every description of the new scenic department of National’s Midwest Division.” Lemle became one of many National Theatre Supply Co. subcontractors, strategically placed across the country. National Theatre Supply Co. was a business entity that secured large theater contracts, but didn’t actually manufacture any product.
Advertisements for National Theatre Supply Co. that year detailed:
“The National Theatre Supply Company manufacturers nothing, nor has it any direct control over factory costs or factory list prices of any article it sells. It is strictly a sales organization and service representative of a majority of manufacturers of theatre equipment and supplies. It is therefore obvious that the establishment of selling process is not within its power, except insofar as quantity purchasing and increased consumption are concerned. Quantity production and distribution governs the price of everyday commodity or service, regardless of its nature. The same conditions apply to the theatre supply industry and any readjustment of prices must necessarily result from the patronage and support. And when manufacturers are given a suitable volume of business, their products serviced promptly and reliably and their bills paid in accordance with terms there is very little likelihood of an increase in price of these products.”
Map with branch office locations of the National Theatre Supply Co.
In 1928 Thomas G. Moses wrote: “Called on the National Theatre Supply Company of San Francisco in order to assist Abrott in contracting for some of their building, as we did in Chicago. I believe they will give up their Studio in Seattle, as I understand it is a losing proposition.” National Theatre Supply Co. made a hefty profit. This was not always the case with their subcontractors, as Lemle and Moses discovered a few years later when they delivered scenery to the Scottish Rite Theatre in McAlester, Oklahoma.
One of the backdrops painted by Thomas G. Moses for the McAlester Scottish Rite.
Although Moses was periodically working for Lemle, he was still running the second iteration of Sosman & Landis, encountering one obstacle after another. Clients were not paying their bills. In 1928, Moses wrote, “Found everything at the Studio at ‘sixes and sevens’ – terrible shape. $38,000 still uncollected. I have had enough! I have put back into the business $25,000 and I don’t see any chance of getting it out without remaining in the business; so I had to apply for a dissolution of the business [Sosman & Landis]. This took effect July 1st, and I have agreed to join Lemle at our old Studio, which will pay me from $8,000 to $10,000 a year.” Moses later added: “Have sold my Sosman and Landis Company stock to Lemle, which will be paid to me monthly. I am at last free from that trouble. Landis has also sold his to Lemle.”
Lemle’s business was continuing to expand. On May 8, 1928, Lemle placed a want ad in the “Chicago Tribune” for drapery workers (page 48). The ad stated:
“DRAPERY WORKERS. Experienced; permanent position. William Lemle, Co., 417 S. Clinton-st.”
Hoyland-Lemle, however, was not quite dead, but circling the drain. In 1928 the capital stock of Hoyland-Lemle was reduced from $50,000, consisting of 500 shares of the par value of $100 each to $5,000 consisting of 500 shares of the par value of $10.00 each.
On a personal front, Lemle’s daughter, Eloise Lemle Andrews, passed away on Dec. 29, 1928. She was only 29 years old at the time. His sister, Martha Lemle Cook, had passed away the year before 1927, only two years after their father in 1925. This was somewhat reminiscent of twenty years earlier when Lemle lost his wife, brother and mother over the course of three short years.
The William Lemle Company was incorporated on January 16, 1929. Incorporation papers show list William Lemle as president and treasurer, with Mary J. Phelan as Secretary. Directors were William Lemle and May Bell Shearer of 2512 Lake View Avenue, and Mary J. Phelan of 4439 W. Monroe. Some of the same players, but a different year. Business offices were listed as 160 West Tenth Street. And the games continued…
In 1929, William Lemle Company, Inc. changed its name to Lemle Studios, Inc. Not a big surprise, as their space on Clinton Street was repeatedly referred to as the Lemle Studio. However, the company was dissolved the same year of the name change – 1929. Likely a decision to avoid corporate taxes and increase their overall profit margin. In January 1929, William Lemle Company, Incorporated, was registered as a Delaware Corporation. On Jan. 17, 1929, “The Morning News” of Wilmington, Delaware, (page 15) listed: “William Lemle Company. Deal in stage scenery. $10,000. A. V. Lane, C. S. Peabbles, L. E. Gray, Wilmington, Del. (Corporation Trust Company of America). Lemle’s business license was later revoked in 1933. Lane, Peabbles and Gray of the Corporation Trust Company of America, were involved with dozens of Delaware corporations that year. For example, on March 26, 1929, “The Morning News” of Wilmington, Delaware, announced “27 Companies Granted Articles of Incorporation” (page 12). Of those 27 firms, Lane, Peabbles and Gray were involved with fourteen:
N. R. Feltes & Co. (Deal in stocks bonds); Admirality Coal Corporation (deal in minerals of all kinds); J. Newman & Co. (deal in brick, terra cotta); Myron C. Herrick Royalty Co. (deal in oils, petroleum); Pittsburgh Smoketeria Corporation (deal in tobacco products of all kinds); P. H. Saunders Company, Inc. (deals in stocks bonds); The Bulah Coal Corporations (deal in coal, coke, charcoal); Stephen M. Foster & Co. Incorporated (deals in stocks, bonds, securities); Alabama State Fair Company (to hold agricultural, mechanical, educational, and other types of fairs); M. C. Trading Corporation (deals in stocks, bonds); North Central Distributors (deal in all kinds of communication and receiving sets); Typekrafters, Inc. (deal in printers and publishing supplies); Avenue Agency Corporation (general real estate agency); Business Corners, Inc. (deal in stocks, bonds). Lemle’s registering his business in Delaware was a calculated choice, yet he continued manufacturing product in Illinois.
The name change was also a refined business tactic for many scenic studios at the time. For context when examining early-twentieth-century studio name changes, I add the following:
When a firm began to financially fail, the name was often changed so that a new iteration of the company could immediately reopen with the previous name. It was almost a seamless process, especially if the firm was juggling several ongoing projects. Minimal changes to the name, with alternative addresses, despite work continuing as usual in the same shop.
In 1929, Moses represented William Lemle, Inc., when he painted the scenery for the Scottish Rite Theatre in McAlester, Oklahoma, 1929. He was also representing the National Theatre Co. at the time. The Scottish Rite backdrops were quite large, measuring 40′-0″ high by 56′-0″ wide. Reflecting on the project In 1930, Moses wrote: “The National Theatre Supply Company are the only ones that made any money on the McAlester job. Everything went 30% higher than what I figured, all because of the enormous size. Not so much in material, as to the expense of handling. I was way off painting, something that I am as a rule pretty close in estimating. There is one redeeming feature and that is, I did a job that Mr. Fuller said was, ‘Wonderful, more satisfactory,’ and that expressed the sentiments of the whole crowd.”
Although Lemle acquired the last remnants of Sosman & Landis stock from Moses and Landis, Fred R. Megan continued to use the Sosman & Landis name. I have yet to determine whether Megan and Lemle were working together, or at odds. The Sosman & Landis name sporadically appeared in papers until 1930, but that was it, the end of a scenic studio empire. Moses continued to work for Lemle, primarily on Masonic theater projects by late 1920s. Regardless, the name, Sosman & Landis, still held sway with some Freemasons. Most work was done on site, as it had been in the beginning.
The last mention that I have encountered for Sosman & Landis scenery dates from 1930. On Sept. 25, 1930, the “Altoona Mirror” credited Sosman & Landis with the scenery for the Jaffa Shrine Temple in Altoona, Pennsylvania (page 28). The article reported, “The [William F.] Gable company supplied the equipment for the big stage of the auditorium and it was installed under the direction of the firm’s special artist, Frederick Megan. One of the features of the equipment is the big asbestos drop curtain, weighing 900 pounds. It bears a painting that is in keeping with the organization and entitled ‘The City of Jaffa’ and is very artistically done. It and the other furnishings were secured through the Sosman & Landis company of Chicago and include stage sets, drops, lights and everything necessary to the modern stage. Mr. Megan directed the furnishing of the stages in the Shriner’s mosques at Cleveland, Chicago, and other cities.
Shriner building in Altoona, Pennsylvania.
I have to wonder, if Lemle was divesting himself of Sosman & Landis product. After all, he was still working out of the old studio on S. Clinton St.
Moses continued to also work with F. R. Megan, until 1931, representing the William Lemle Co., the National Theatre Supply Co., and even the Armstrong Studios of Los Angeles. His memoirs reveal a frustrated individual who continued design Masonic scenery, hoping to reignite the passion for painted illusion on stage. Unfortunately, much of the work was refurbishing or repainting old scenery. Such had been the case for quite some time.
In 1931, Moses again mentioned Lemle and the Clinton Street Studio, writing, “Rupert and I started for Dubuque on the 23rd of January. We closed the contract for work at $850.00, and brought all the old drops that are to be repainted back with us in the car. It took but a few days to get started on the old and new work at Clinton Street, where it was good and warm, as Lemle had some old advertising curtains on the frames.” Moses remained connected with the National Supply Co. in the early 1930s. In 1932, Moses wrote: “Have had several small designs to make for the National Theatre Supply Company, none of which has ever gone through. While I don’t like to waste much time, I feel that I can’t afford to miss a chance to get some work, no matter how small.”
Back to Lemle…
The 1930 US Federal Census listed William Lemle as living in the Pine Grove Apartment Hotel at 2828 Pine Grove Ave. Lemle was listed as a proprietor in the stage draperies industry. Maybell (May Belle) Crispell Shearer and Joseph T. Shearer (1874-1955) also lived at this address, along with several others employed in the theatre and advertising industry. The name Shearer should ring a bell – May Bell Shearer. Remember that in 1920, the four directors for the Allardt Advertising Co. were William H. Lemle, Charles L. Hoyland, Carrie Hoyland, and Mabel Shearer. Shearer was also involved with the Lemle-Barrett Company, Inc.; the officers of the corporation were William Lemle, John P. Barrett, and M. Shearer. Again in 1929, Shearer was involved with the William Lemle Co., Inc. When it was incorporated on January 16, 1929, William Lemle was president and treasurer, with Mary J. Phelan as Secretary. Directors of the firm were William Lemle and Maybell Shearer, both of 2512 Lake View Avenue. Despite how her name was spelled, it was the same gal. Interestingly Maybell Shearer, Joseph T. Shearer and Emil Feldman were listed as incorporators for the Felshea Co. This was a firm that engaged in general advertising, publicity, printing and sign-painting. With business addresses at 159 North State St., Chicago, the starting capital was $8,000 (“Editor & Publisher, July 12, 1924, page 18). This was a period of time when one advertising business after another opened its doors.
Shearer had worked with Lemle since 1915, since before her husband entered the fray. In 1930, Joseph T. Shearer was listed as the proprietor of a Theatrical costume shop. He was previously employed as a lithographer in the printing/advertising industry, although May Bell had designed and built costumes for years. She, transitioned from performance to costumes prior to WWI, a decade after they were married. By 1915, May Bell was listed as the wardrobe mistress (“Daily Arkansas Gazette, Little Rock, 20 Oct 1915, page 4).
Lemle’s production of “Spetember Morn,” with mention of May Bell Shearer.
For additional context, the Shearers were married in 1903 and celebrated the birth of a daughter in 1904. Between 1915 and 1916 May Bell Shearer toured as a principal with “September Morn.” This was the same show managed by Martin & Lemle, Inc. Shearer not only performed as a principal, but also functioned as the wardrobe mistress for the company (“Springfield Leader and Press, Missouri, 24 Oct. 1915, page 6). The 1920 census listed that their 16-yrs.-old daughter, Mary J., was working as an actress, following in her mother’s footsteps.
However, May Bell left the stage and began a career in theatrical costume design. Even backstage, May Bell was a shining star and gained quite a reputation as a costume designer. She and her husband maintained close ties with Lemle over the years, even sharing their home. The two were proprietors of the May Bell Shearer costume shop, located at 62 E. Lake St. An article published on Nov. 1, 1944, in the “Chicago Tribune,” reported that they had an apartment at the same address. Their establishment was burglarized that year on Halloween. When Joseph Shearer passed in 1955, his obituary announced, “He is survived by May Belle Shearer, Loop theatrical designer” (“Chicago Tribune,” 20 Aug 1955, page 35). May Bell Shearer’s obituary was published in the “Chicago Tribune” on Nov. 25, 1972: “May Bell Shearer, theatrical costumer, 615 ½ Washington Blvd, Oak Pk., Ill., wife of the late Joseph Shearer. Services John Carroll Sons for Funerals, Erie and Wabash Av., Monday Nov, 27, 1972, 10 a.m. Interment Evergreen Cemetery, Visitation Sunday after 4 p.m.” (page 69).
As far as Lemle’s in-laws, the Cooks…
In 1930, both Lemle’s brother-in-law and nephew (W. H. Cook and his son Charles) were listed as proprietors in the US Federal census. Each was listed as a proprietor in the “artist and sculpting” industry. Ten years later they were still painting, working as artists in the decorative painting industry.
By the mid 1930’s, Lemle was heralded in newspapers as a “noted theatrical scene designer” (“Forest Parker,” 20 Dec 1935) and a “leading Chicago scene designer (“Wilmette Life,” 19 Dec 1935, page 58). On Jan. 9, 1936 (page 19), the “Wilmette Life” noted Lemle’s participation in Chicago’s third annual Business Exposition: “A striking decorative scheme evolved by Melville Chatten, prominent architect; and William H. Lemle, well known Chicago scenery designer, will provide an especially attractive background for the show, according to William V. MacGill, chairman of the exposition committee.”
By 1938, Lemle’s studio space on S. Clinton St was liquidated. The contents of the space were listed in the “Merchandise.” Section if the “Chicago Tribune” on Feb. 25, 1938 (page 29). The listed contents gave insight into studio equipment:
“Radley stencil cutter. Glass top desks, Singer sewing machines, French embroidery machine, Remington typewrite, motors, ext. ladders, 20 and 50 gal, crocks, orange juice pumps, artist’s drawing table, 2 large gas chicken fryers [for cooking hide glue], balance scales, large coffee grinder [for dry pigment], 25 gallon butter churn’s, 5 gal milk cans, burlap bags, gas and electric stoves, antique tables, stage curtains, letter files, sprocket chain, automatic typewriter, reducing gears, large electric liquid agitator, and 3 and 4 inch wood battens. 417 S. Clinton. 12-7 daily.”
The 1940 US Federal Census reported that Lemle was a 68-yrs. old widower, living at 200 Jackson Blvd. in Chicago. He was listed as the proprietor of a drapery business.
And then Lemle fades from print…until his obituary was posted in the “Chicago Tribune” on March 29, 1950 (page 35).
It simply announced: “LEMLE – William H. Services March 29, 2 P.M., at Graceland cemetery.”
At the time of his passing. Lemle was running an upholstery shop. On April 9 and 10, 1950, the “Chicago Tribune” announced the sale of his business:
“UPHOLSTERY SHOP.
By order probate court, will sell at public auction upholstery shop, consisting of materials, machines, etc. on premises, 525 W. Roosevelt-rd. Tues., April 11, 1950, at 2 p.m. Est. of William Lemle, dec’d. Inspection from 1 p.m. to time of sale. Sale in bulk for cash. Thomas D. Nash, Public Admin’r.” (page 54).
Lemle was not actually buried in Chicago.
Lemle’s ashes were brought home to Greenwood Cemetery in Philadelphia, buried in the Lemle family plot on May 4, 1950. Greenwood Cemetery is located at Addams Ave. & Arrot St. in Philadelphia. Lemle was placed in the same family plot as his parents, Martha H. and Francis P. Lemle. He shares the same grave as William E. Lemle (Feb. 15, 1903) and Christian Lemle (June 2, 1883). Other family members in the plot include Elizabeth C. Lemle (September 6, 1905) and William E. C. Lemle (August 20, 1895).
Lemle’s brother-in-law, William H. Cook, died three years later and is also buried at Greenwood Cemetery. Adjacent to the Lemle’s is the Cook family plot, containing the remains of William Cook, Martha Lemle Cook and Frank E. Lemle.
In 1953 the “Philadelphia Inquirer” reported, “Services for William H. Cook, a scenic artist with the old Lubin Motion Picture Co., were held yesterday at Mulligan’s funeral home, 1119 W. Lehigh Ave. Burial was in Greenwood Cemetery. Mr. Cook, who was 77 lived at 548 E. Dupont St. He died Tuesday. He was employed by the movie company at 8th and Market Sts. And later became associated with the Art Film Co. He also held one of the first-class licenses issued for operating a motion picture machine. Surviving are his wife, Martha A.; a son, Charles W., and two grandchildren” (The Philadelphia Inquirer, 27 Oct. 1953, page 8).
Art Oberbeck worked at Sosman & Landis from approximately 1902 until 1920. Of all the scenic artists who I have written about, Oberbeck is unique; I have listened to his voice on a cassette tape. His recollections were recorded on Nov. 4, 1972, when asked to give a speech at the Southwest Theatre conference in Dallas, Texas. At the time, Oberbeck was 86 years old and still painting on a vertical frame at Peter Wolf Studios at the Texas State Fair Grounds. A cassette of his 1972 speech was gifted to me by Lance Brockman a few years ago. This meant that I was able to hear Overbeck tell a few of his own stories.
Art Oberbeck’s 1972 Speech.
In addition to the cassette tape, a substantial amount of information was gathered from Oberbeck during the 1970s. The combined efforts of Dr. John Rothgeb, Randi Givercer Frank, and Peter Wolf preserved many of Oberbeck’s memories about his work as a scenic artist in Chicago. Representing the University of Texas, both Rothgeb and Frank personally interviewed Oberbeck. In later years, Peter Wolf of Peter Wolf and Associates enticed a retired Oberbeck to relocate to Dallas, Texas, and again work as a scenic artist.
Now they gathered what Oberbeck wanted to remember, and we all know that time tints memories. I will supplement Oberbeck’s recorded recollections with information from historical documents.
Arthur Walter Oberbeck was born on Feb. 14, 1887, in Chicago, Illinois. His parents were Heinrich “Henry” Oberbeck (1848-1916) and Wilhelmine “Minnie” Ehlert Oberbeck (-1921). At the time of his birth, his father was working in a shoe store at 210 S. Clinton St., just a few doors down from Sosman & Landis at 236-238 S. Clinton.
Art’s father, Heinrich, sailed from Hamburg, Germany, to New York during the fall of 1868. At the age of 19 yrs. old, Heinrich “Henry” was accompanied by his four younger brothers aboard the S.S. Gutenberg: Ludwig “Louis” (17 yrs.), Fredrick (15 yrs.), Charles (12 yrs.) and Ernst Oberbeck (7 yrs.). After their arrival in New York, the Oberbecks continued west, settling in Chicago. By 1871, Heinrich “Henry” Oberbeck married Wilhelmine Ehlert and the two celebrated the birth of their first child, Louise. in 1873. By 1874, Henry Oberbeck was listed as a malster in the Chicago Directory, residing at 358 Church. For context, malsters worked in the beer brewing industry. His brother Frederick C. Oberbeck was also listed in the Chicago Directory, working as a carriage painter and living at 54 Sigel.
In 1880 the US Federal Census listed that Henry Oberbeck’s home was located at 186 Clybourne Pl in Chicago. The Oberbeck’s family home remained at Clybourne Place for the next few decades. In 1880, the Oberbeck household included Henry Oberbeck (31 yrs.), Wihelmine Oberbeck (28 Yrs.), Louis Oberbeck (7 yrs.) and Henry Oberbeck Jr. (5 yrs.). At the time, Henry Sr. worked in a cabinet shop. When Art Oberbeck was born seven years later, his father was working in the boots and shoes business. At this same time, Art’s uncles, Louis and Frederick C. Oberbeck, were operating Oberbeck Bros. at 210 S. Clinton. The Oberbeck Bros. furniture store was located just a few doors down from the newly constructed Sosman & Landis studio at 236-238 S. Clinton St. Sosman & Landis opened their new building in 1886.
Little is known of Art Oberbeck’s early childhood before the age of 12 yrs. old, nor did he elaborate in later years. In some instances, Oberbeck explained that he began working at the age of 12 yrs. old. In other instances, Oberbeck explained that he began working as a paint boy when he was fourteen years old. The 1900 US Federal Census, however, did not list any occupation for the 13-yrs.-old Art. That year, the Oberbeck home at 199 Clybourne included Henry Oberbeck (50 yrs.), Minnie Oberbeck (48 yrs.), Fred Oberbeck (19 yrs.) and Arthur Oberbeck (13 yrs.). Only Henry and Fred were listed as employed; Henry was employed as a machinist and Fred was employed as a packer of notions.
Regardless of when Oberbeck began his career in scenic art, he started as a paint boy at Daniels’ Scenic Studio in Chicago and remained there for approximately 18 months. About the time Oberbeck began working for the firm, a WANT AD was published in the “Chicago Tribune.” On Aug 29, 1902, the “Chicago Tribune” published a want ad: Boy – Strong. 16 years old. Daniel’s Scenic Studio, 2321 Wabash-av.” (page 9). For context, Daniel’s Scenic Studio was located on the Chicago Opera House block.
Alonzo P. Daniels, namesake of Daniels’ Scenic Studios, of Chciago.
Daniel’s Scenic studios of Chicago was incorporated in 1903 with a starting capital of $40,000; manufacturing and painting scenery and stage accessories; incorporators, Alonzo P. Daniel, Charles J. Tietzel and Edward Beiderman” (3 Jan. 1903, page 9). I was lucky enough to discover a detailed article in “The New York Clipper” about the firm’s founder from 1903.
On Aug. 29, 1903, A. P. Daniels was listed as No. 19 in part of the “New York Clipper” series “Men Who Have Developed Western Amusements” (page 2). Here is the article in its entirety, as it sets the stage for Oberbeck’s scenic art training:
“Numbered among those who developed and extend the vogue of theatrical the scenic artist has rightful place. Of the numerous company of knights of the brush A P. Daniels ranks in prominence with the best artisans in his line. Under his management, and because of his industry, the Daniel’s Scenic Studios of Chicago are known far and wide. Examples of his workmanship and the products of his studios are to be found in theatres in every State in the Union. Mr. Daniels entered theatrical life as a member of Lawrence Barrett’s company, playing boys’ roles, and was with that organization when Mr. Barrett achieved the then remarkable feat of playing two towns in one day – New Orleans and Mobile. In New Orleans, where, in 1858 he was born, he first started to learn the art of scenic painting, working on the paint bridge at La Varieties Theatre, as a paint boy. His first serious essay at theatrical life was in 1885, when he joined J. H Haverly’s forces, in Chicago. After several years with Mr. Haverly he took Robert
Fulton (now manager of Trocadero, Chicago) upon the road as a boy magician. Later he formed a partnership with James Mass, a clever comedian of his day. Afterward he, for the first time, left the show business and entered the employ of the National Cash Register Co., as their first travelling salesman, and for three years made considerable money. He was thus enabled to form a partnership with Robert Manchester, and put upon the road the Night Owls. During the second year of his partnership with the late James A. Herne, opening the Casino Theatre, Chicago, as a vaudeville house. Later they closed out their interest to Snellbaker & Hopkins, Mr. Daniels arranging to continue with Mr. Herne, He, however, decided to remain in Chicago, and engaged in several theatrical enterprises. Finally he entered into a scenic painting partnership with Ruben Merrifield, which continued until Mr. Merrifield went to New York. The Daniels Scenic Studio was continued as a firm until Jan. 1 last, when it was converted into a corporation, the heads of the various departments being taken into the concern” (page 2).
Although Oberbeck recalled that Daniels’ Scenic Studio was only a small studio and sideline business for its namesake, the firm was much more. In 1904 the Chicago Directory listed only a handful of scenic artists in the business section:
Buhler & Mann (276 Sedgwick)
Cook & Donigan (60, 87 Clark)
Daniels’ Scenic Studios (906 Opera House blk. And 2321-2325 Wabash av.)
Richard A. Green (1046 W. Van Buren)
Guthermann & Goodrich (rear 107-115 Throop)
Shepard & Slipper (86 Locust),
Sosman & Landis (236 and 238 S. Clinton)
Wood, Risser & Bevis (rear 3020 Cottage Grove av.)
Of the firms listed above, only Daniels’ Scenic Studios and Sosman & Landis were printed in large font bold.
Chicago Directory, 1904.
In 1905, the Chicago Directory listed only two studios in the Scenic Artists Section: Daniels’ Scenic Studio and Sosman & Landis. The competition between Daniels’ and Sosman & Landis continued in the Chicago Directory continued for the next several years.
Chicago Directory, 1905.
Oberbeck’s 18-mths. Stint at Daniels’ Scenic Studio likely lasted between 1902 and 1903. I say that, as Sosman & Landis were very adamant that they would not hire boys younger than 16 yrs. old. Oberbeck explained that he was 15 ½ yrs. old when he began working at Sosman & Landis. That means that he started at Sosman & Landis during August 1902.
Working backwards, Oberbeck began at Daniels’ Scenic Studio in approximately Feb. 1901 and continued until August 1902. At Daniels’ Scenic Studio, Oberbeck worked a 48-hour-week building scenery and painting. His job as a paint boy not only included tacking the canvas to frames, washing brushes and other menial tasks, but also included some lay-in and lining work. In other words, Oberbeck got to paint at Daniels’ Scenic Studio between the ages of fourteen and fifteen yrs. old. However, the aspiring artists as Daniels’ Scenic Studio were mistreated by a manager that Oberbeck identified as “Mr. Tissell.” He was actually referring to Charles Julius Tietzel (1874-1936)/ Tietzel was well versed in scenic design, painting and stage machinery, having worked in both Chicago and Columbus, Ohio. His 1918 WWI Draft Registration card described him as tall and thin, with red hair and grey eyes. Again, in 1903, Alonzo P. Daniel, Charles J. Tietzel and Edward Beiderman, were listed as incorporators of Daniels’ Scenic Studio in Chicago. This is not when the firm was founded, but incorporated. It was likely founded around 1900, although I have yet to confirm that the unincorporated-firm was in existence at that time.
Oberbeck had a very difficult time at Daniel’s Scenic Studio, and did not leave with fond memories. He did not like Tietzel and shared the following story at the 1972 Southwest Theatre conference in Dallas, Texas, and in an interview with Rand Givercer Frank for her BA Thesis at the University of Texas, entitled “The Sosman & Landis Studio, A Study of Scene Painting in Chicago, 1900-1925.” Here is an excerpt from Frank’s paper, as she heard it first hand:
“Mr. Tissell [sic.]. the man in charge of the studio, exploited the young boys he hired. He would keep them until midnight for only fifty cents overtime pay. Often they were kept after midnight and would miss the last bus or trolley and have to sleep in the studio, ready to start at eight. As Oberbeck was the oldest [??!!] One night the boys, led by Oberbeck went on strike. They demanded a dollar overtime when they stayed past twelve. Thereafter. On the occasions that they did work late, Tissell [sic.] kept them up all night working.”
In his 1972 speech, Oberbeck elaborated about his early career, stating, “I had a very poor education to start with. I never graduated from a grammar school.” He further explained that his starting salary at Daniels’ Scenic Studio was only $4 a week, and there were eight boys who did all laying in and painting of scenery the best they could, with Tietzl finishing the work. Oberbeck’s stories suggest that Tietzel hired a group of young boys between the ages of 12-15 yrs. old to do the majority of the work, with a journeyman artist adding the finishing touches to the composition. I have to wonder what Daniel’s was doing at this time, as he was also well-known as a scenic artist. Maybe he was focusing on sales. Between 1903 and 1910, Daniels’ Scenic Studio was credited with some rather large projects. The firm’s projects included scenery for touring productions such as the Orpheum Circuit’s “Ferry, in Ferryland,” Joseph E. Howard’s “Love and Politics” and Billy Kersands’ minstrels, as well as stock scenery collections for stages across the country, including the Hagemeister Park Theater (Green Bay, Wisconsin), the Memorial Building (Dayton, Ohio), Phillips Opera House (Richmond, Indiana). Daniels’ Scenic Studio was also credited with the decorations for Chicago’s Auto Show at the Coliseum and First Regiment Armory in 1907.
Oberbeck’s speech in 1972 also described his transition from Daniels’ Scenic Studio to Sosman & Landis. Oberbeck explained, “My mother insisted I was ruining my health.” She was concerned about his long hours at Daniels’ Scenic Studio, suggesting that he work for Sosman & Landis. Oberbeck detailed that Sosman & Landis was “the biggest scenic studio in the part of the country at that time” and “They offered me $6 a week. I accepted and quit the other place.” Although the pay was better, Oberbeck began at the firm washing palettes; a job he felt was beneath him, by this time. After the first day, Oberbeck told his mother he wasn’t going backwards. His mother disagreed, explaining that it was a better opportunity and he should stay. Oberbeck left home for two weeks, returning to Daniels’ Scenic Studio. In the end, he returned to Sosman & Landis, and slowly worked his way up the line. He continued washing buckets and completed a variety of other menial tasks at the firm until he was assigned as Fred Scott’s paint boy. It was around this time that Oberbeck began to work beside Scott, copying the older artist on a smaller canvas. After several months, Scott advocated for Oberbeck’s advancement, arguing, “You’re losing money by having this boy wash pots and pans. I want him as my assistant.” In an interview with John Rothgeb in 1973, Oberbeck stated, “Being with [Scott] and helping him and doing him and all his ways and methods have proven today to be of value to me. I used a lot of his judgements and things that he has told me.”
Oberbeck remained at Sosman & Landis for eighteen years, approximately from 1902-1920. It is possibly that Oberbeck’s dates were a bit off, but he likely left the Sosman & Landis during the midst of the mass exodus between 1918 and 1919. Keep in mind that when Sosman passed away in 1915, Thomas G. Moses was elected president. Moses did not last for long and resigned by the fall of 1918. Although Moses returned in 1920, he was boarding a sinking ship. That years five former Sosman & Landis scenic artists formed Services Studios.
This is where Oberbeck’s memory gets a little sketchy. So far, Oberbeck’s timeline at Sosman & Landis goes from washing buckets during the summer of 1902, to working as Fred Scott’s paint boy by 1904. In 1905, Oberbeck purportedly became Scott’s Assistant, replacing Victor Higgins, Scott’s previous paint assistant. This means that between 1905 and 1915, Oberbeck went from Scenic artists assistant to a full-fledged scenic artist with his own palette. Similarly, John Hanny was hired by Moses in 1906 as a paint boy, and was still working as an assistant in 1912. Hanny inherited Fred Evans palette at Sosman & Landis when he passed away.
Oberbeck’s big break at Sosman & Landis was when Sosman’s nephew left a partially-completed set of tormentors on the frame. After Oberbeck completed the pair of tormentors, he was given another set and soon inherited his predecessors palette. My gut instinct says that this is around 1910. My rationale is that Oberbeck’s move from scenic art assistant to full-fledged scenic artist came with a slight increase in pay. The 1910 US Federal Census listed Oberbeck still living at home with his parents and a niece. The household included: Henry Oberbeck (61 yrs.), Minnie Oberbeck (58 yrs.), Arthur Oberbeck (23 years) and Lillian Belke (Henry and Minnie’s 16 granddaughter. Henry was employed as a millwright, Arthur as an artist, and Lillian as a clerk. On April 16, 1910, Art married Edna W. Trinkhaus (1889-1968) and the two celebrated the birth of their first child, Arthur William Oberbeck, on Jan. 13, 1912.
Oberbeck’s time at Sosman & Landis was summarized very concisely by Frank in her paper:
“Oberbeck was a very versatile painter, painting everything except landscapes. He was considered by his colleagues as one of the fastest painters of his time. His versatility and speed, combined with his aggressiveness and desire to learn from anyone he met, made him one of the best painters in Chicago…He was one of the first artists at Sosman & Landis to earn more than thirty-five dollars a week. He took advantage of the arrival of a man who had come from New York to find painters, by telling Sosman he was interested in the job than when in fact he had no desire to leave. He was interested in more pay. Sosman raised his pay to forty dollars a week, more than even Scott was getting.” This is questionable there was a direct correlation between subject specialty and pay grade at Sosman & Landis. Landscape painters were at the top of the food chain, and Oberbeck did not specialize in landscapes.
Also, Oberbeck surmised that Scott was bitter about the pay discrepancy and therefore refused to give any more advise to the younger artist. Understandable from a variety of standpoints, but also a little questionable. Scott was dealing with a lot of his own problems at this time, as his marriage crumbled and his personal life fell apart. I have yet to recover a departure date for Scott from the studio or even an obituary, but it was likely around 1911. Here is the link to Scott’s story: https://drypigment.net2021/04/29/sosman-landis-shaping-the-landscape-of-american-theatre-employee-no-27-fred-scott/
My previous research suggests that Oberbeck was not the top-paid artist at Sosman & Landis. However, it was very possible that Oberbeck was TOLD he was the highest paid artist on staff, if only to end any foreseeable requests for pay increases and future negotiations. This is one of the reasons that some employers are not always eager for their employees to know the salaries of others. It you think you are making more than everyone else, you typically don’t cause trouble.
Sometime between 1918 and 1920, Oberbeck left Sosman & Landis. For perspective, in 1920, the US Federal Census listed Oberbeck living with his wife Edna and two sons, Arthur (7 yrs.) and Robert (4 weeks) at 4051 Kilbourne in Chicago. At the time he left the firm, Oberbeck was invited to join the five other former Sosman & Landis employees to establish Service Studios. He declined, because he didn’t think it would work. Instead, he secured painting work at Peltz & Carsen.
At this time, Oberbeck explained that he worked for both Herman Peltz (1869-1919) and Robert Carsen (1876-1958) at Peltz & Carsen. This means that he left Sosman & Landis pre-1919, as that was the year that Peltz passed away. Oberbeck also explained that he remained with Peltz and Carsen for about a year, before establishing his own studio. Of the new studio, Oberbeck described that after the death of Peltz, Carsen shared that he couldn’t make money on painting projects, only construction. Every time he hired a scenic artist he went over budget. Oberbeck proposed the following: “If you Give me the use of your studio, I’ll by my own paint. I’ll do the work for cost you take your profit off of the job before I do if. But I said, “Don’t expect me to do a two-day job for one-day pay…That’s the way I started in the business. I was still making profit in his cost, turning it out fast. I was there for about three years.” This means that Oberbeck worked at Peltz & Carsen from about 1919 until 1922. This coincides with the first appearances of scenery produced by Acme Scenic Studios in the newspaper.
Of the name, Oberbeck recalled that the name ACME was suggested by his father-in-law because of its meaning: the top. As defined in the dictionary, acme is the point at which someone, or something, is the best, perfect, or most successful. Oberbeck aspired to be the acme of scenery. It was also a strategic choice as the name ACME Scenic Studio placed it first in any list or directory. The earliest mention of the studio that I have located to date is from 1922. On Nov. 28, 1922, “The Democratic Banner” of Mount Vernon, Ohio, reported that the stage settings for the three-act comedy “Hello Algy” were designed and painted by the Acme Artists Scenic Studio of Chicago (page 4).
By 1926, Service Studios sold out to ACME. That year, Oberbeck moved ACME Studios from 36 West Randolph Street to the Service Studios space at Van Buren and Sacramento Street (2919 W. Van Buren). Of the acquisition, Oberbeck explained, “I bought them out for $6,000.” He purchased the renovated stables from the old Jewel Tea Company. In 1920, Service Studios had invested $11,000 to renovate the old barn.
From an old ACME Scenic Studios sales book, showing previous ownership by Service Studios. Private Collection.
The 1920s were an incredibly successful time for Oberbeck and ACME, despite the decline in demand for painted scenery. On Aug. 22, 1926, the “Detroit Free Press” announced: “Acme Scenic Productions Specified in the New Michigan Theater.” The announcement continued, “It was only natural that in seeking the very best in equipment for the great new Michigan Theater, its sponsors should select Acme Scenic effects, found in many of the country’s largest theaters. All of Acme’s scenic work is personally supervised by a scenic artist of international reputation, and its productions are universally recognized to be quite without equals anywhere. Theater managers everywhere understand that scenic work entrusted to the Acme Studios will command their sincerest approbation and respect. We are equipped to handle the largest and the smallest contracts” (page 87). The studio’s address was listed as 2919-23 W. Van Buren Street.
1926 advertisement.Acme sales book showing a design for an interior setting.
Oberbeck recalled 1927 as the firm’s biggest year, completing $187,000 of work and gaining $54,000 in profits. That year his studio was also pictured on a page in the First Annual Scenic Artists Ball in Chicago. The entire ACME Scenic Studios staff was also listed: Acme’s scenic art department included Peter Darges, William A. Smart, Louis Huebner and Louis Zingarelli; the Fabric Department included Anna Klumpp, Fred Oberbeck, Mrs. Daniels, Mrs. Dillinger, and Nick Koffmann; the Carpenter Department included Herman Peltz Jr.; and the Office Staff included Mr. Bishop and Mr. Olsen. W. G. Sherfese, W. A. Anderson and Ann Silverstein.
Acme Scenic Studios Page in 1927 Souvenir Book for the Scenic Artists Ball in Chicago.
On April 8, 1928, the “Indianapolis Star” included an advertisement about ACME Studios, noting, “Handling the largest amount of scenic work in Chicago and the United States, the ACME Studios products must necessarily reflect quality and completeness. The advertisement added, “Startling effects in color, design and execution have been achieved by the Acme Scenic Studio on the stage dressings of the new Granada Theatre. You’ve perhaps heard of the Acme Scenic Studios before, because the quality of workmanship and thoroughness of detail have made an enviable name for the Acme Company. Handling the largest amount of scenic work in Chicago and the United States, the Acme Studios’ products must necessarily reflect quality and completeness. The scenic work don for the U. I. Theatre Circuit Inc., theatres is the best ever executed scenic company. The highest standard is maintained at Acme, both in coloring, tone and technique. All work is personally supervised by A. W. Oberbeck, himself a scenic artist of ability who has spent more than twenty years in the profession. The firm delivered ‘stage dressings’ for the new Granada Theatre of the U. I. Theatre Circuit, Inc.” The Acme Studios have been in existence in Chicago for many years, and the name is synonymous with quality scenery and draperies. They execute the stage scenery and draperies for the U. I. Theatre Circuit, Inc., and they furnish stage settings and draperies for numerous other large photoplay and legitimate theatres, such as Balaban & Katz, marks Bros., and others. The name of the Acme Studios has spread out over the entire United States, and theatre owners well know that their scenic and draper problems placed in the hands of the Acme Studios, will be highly satisfactory. Their new and most modernly equipped studio is located at 2919-23 West Van Buren, Chicago. Ill.” (page 74).
In 1972, Oberbeck shared a story with the audience at the Southwest Theatre Conference, noting that it would have probably been against the law at the time. This ties neatly into the tale of Leo A. Star, art director for Balaban & Katz, as well as previous Sosman & Landis employee No. 82.
Here is his tale…
Oberbeck was bidding out a project for the Oriental Theatre, competing against Becker Bros. and Eugene Cox. Each was provided with a list, and each submitted a price. After some discussion behind closed doors, Leo A, Stahr came out and said, “Boys we want you to itemize all these items.” Oberbeck leaned over to Becker and said, “Ray, they’re going to pull something. If you want to stick with me, I won’t cut my price. I won’t itemize it. Because what you think is high, I may think is easy and go low, but as an average we come out the same.” Ray retorted, “We can’t do that, we’ll have to itemize.” And they did.
Oberbeck explained that Stahr took the cheapest item from each bid, effectively cutting the overall price in half. This would have been bad enough, but the stagehands had a good laugh and chided Oberbeck about it. That was the mistake.
Oberbeck then held a meeting with Becker and Cox, proposing a new approach to all future bids. He said that these big jobs typically run $1000 to $3000 each and the Client would never miss $300. That amount would be split three ways, giving each $100. Oberbeck surmised that Acme, Becker Bros., and Cox, each made $5,000 over the course of the next five years; the client never was the wiser.
Not commenting.
Oberbeck’s success, however, came at a cost, as he gradually withdrew from painting and solely focused on the management of the studio. At the end of his career, Oberbeck explained, “[there was] so much busines that I couldn’t work, I didn’t paint scenery for about 30-35 years. I had about seven of the best artists that I could get in the west. Just directing the thing.”
In 1930, the Oberbeck’s were living at 3435 Harding Ave. in Chicago. The Oberbeck household included Arthur (43 yrs.), Edna (41 yrs.), Arthur Jr. (18 yrs.) and Robert (10 yrs.). Despite an economic depression, ACME Studios plugged along. Not everything was rosy as the country struggled through the Great Depression. On June 14, 1930, the “Chicago Tribune” reported, “Bandits Trail Manager of Studio; Seize Pay Roll. Trailed from the Cosmopolitan State bank, Clark street and Chicago avenue, to the Acme Scenic studios, by two Negroes in a green sedan, R. H. Morrison, manager of the studios, was held up and robbed of an $841 pay roll as he alighted from his own car” (page 14).
And this is where it gets a bit odd, there is a second set of Oberbecks in Missouri. Arthur W. and Edna Oberbeck are listed in the St. Louis Directory during the early 1930s. In 1932, Oberbeck is working for Goodwill Industries and living at 4404 N. 20th., The next year Art W. Oberbeck is working for Volunteers of American, now living at 3837 Washington Blvd. They remain in Missouri for the remainder of the decade. It is likely that their relocation had to do with aging parents and siblings. I realized that this was a different couple, when the obituary for Arthur W. Oberbeck’s father, Henry W. Oberbeck, was published in the “St. Louis Post-Dispatch” on May 30, 1937: “Henry W. Oberbeck of 4138 Pleasant St., entered into rest Sun., May 30, 1937, 8:15 a.m., beloved husband of Minnie Oberbeck (nee Brockfield), dear father of Arthur W. Oberbeck…” Art’s parents had passed away years ago.
By 1942, Art Oberbeck’s WWII draft card listed his home address as 2919 W. Van Buren; that was the ACME business address, not his home address. Oberbeck listed his employer as “Scenic Artist,” listing his place of employment as 2919 W. Van Buren. At the time, Oberbeck was described as 5’-7 ½”, 160 lbs., with gray hair and light complexion. I have uncovered very little about the Oberbeck’s during the 1930s and 1940s.
Thirty years later, Oberbeck explained he retired when they tore the studio down for the Eisenhower highway. He added that although his young son was interested in art there was no desire to take over the business. Therefore Oberbeck sold out and retired. On March 14, 1950, “The Pantagraph” of Bloomington, Illinois, reported, “Allyn Purchases Part of Stage Setting Firm. Oliver Allyn, 611 East Walnut street, said Monday he is one of four dramatic students who have purchased the Acme Studios in Chicago, a firm which makes stage sets. Mr. Allyn has attended Illinois Wesleyan university and the Goodman Dramatics school in Chicago. He is joining three other students of the Goodman school in the venture” (page 15). On May 4, 1950, the “Oak Park Leaves” announced, “CAL. NO. 9-50-Z. “I” Business District Applicant Acme Scenic Studio: Owner, Wm. H. Bromann; premises affected Southeast corner South Boulevard and Marion Street, Oak Park, Illinois, Subject; Application under the Zoning Ordinance to permit the first floor of premises to be used as display studio and workshop” (page 11).
Oberbeck only retired for twelve years. During that time, he moved to Canada, built a log cabin, and purchased a motor boat. I think that he quickly grew bored too. In 1952, at the age of 65 years old, he began flying airplanes and logged about 2600 hours in the air over the next nine years.
In the midst of retirement Oberbeck was contacted by Ray Becker. Becker had quit Becker Bros. moved south to Texas where he began working for Peter Wolf and Associates. Becker asked Oberbeck to paint for a few weeks on the summer musical. For the next two years, Oberbeck painted scenery for 4 to 5 weeks every summer. Oberbeck was an immediate success and soon Wolf suggested that Art relocate Texas. That was he could work whenever he felt like it.
By 1964, Oberbeck was living in apt. 206, 1021 Knob Oak Dr. He remained at that address for the next several years.
On June 10, 1966, the “Fort Worth Star-Telegram” reported, “Retired 18 Years Ago. At 80, He’s Active Painting Scenery” (page 56). The article continued, “Peter Wolf said it: When Art Oberbeck quits painting stage scenery, it’ll be the end of an era. The Chicago native who will be 80 years old Feb. 14, 1967, ‘retired’ from the stage designing business 18 years ago.
But to a man of Oberbecks vitality, ‘retirement’ is a dirty word. Staying active as a scenic artist is his way of ‘keeping alive:”
“It keeps me active and in pretty good health,” he said recently in Dallas, setting aside for a moment his paint brush and characteristic cigar for a Star-Telegram interview. Oberbeck who took up flying at the age of 65, is the most respected employee of Peter Wolf Associates, Inc. He was one of many Wolf employees who helped put together Fort Worth’s Heritage Hall, the ‘Living Museum of the Old West.”
Oberbeck has been in the set designing business more than 40 years when he ‘retired.’
After retiring, he came to Dallas for three consecutive summers to work as scenic artist for the State Fair Musicals. About four years ago, Wolf asked Oberbeck to consider settling in Dallas and working for Wolf. The veteran craftsman didn’t have to think it over for too long before taking Wolf up on his offer.
When you’ve been in the business as long as Oberbeck, to stop working is to stop living. The scenery paint gets into your blood.
In one instance, it has proven hereditary, you might say:
One of Oberbeck’s two sons – Robert, 47 – is a scenic designed for the movie industry in Hollywood, where he was associated with Metro Goldwyn – Mayer Studios for a long time, his father said.
The other son – Maj. Gen Arthur W. Oberbeck, Jr., 53 – held on graduation from West Point in 1937 a grade average second only to that of Douglas MacArthur, who achieved the highest in academy history. General Oberbeck, who now resides in Paris, France, is three years away from retirement, his father noted.
Wolf thinks highly of his eldest employee: “He has a real sharp mind. He’s a valuable asset to us.”
How much of an asset can be demonstrated by the lengths to which Wolf has gone to make working comfortable for the elder-statesman scenic artist:
Most scenery painting is done, because of the huge size of backdrops to be painted in a kneeling or bending-over position with the canvas on the floor.
A bad back, however, won’t allow Oberbeck to bend as other scenic artists do.
So Wolf built for Oberbeck a sort of mobile scaffold that moves back and forth, up and down, so the veteran artist can reach an ‘hidden corner of the upright backdrop.”
Younger men in the craft conceded there is little Oberbeck hasn’t learned in more than half century of scenery painting. At one time, he handled all the work for Balaban & Katz theaters in Chicago.
“But at 62 I didn’t care to re-establish in another location,” he said,” so I retired.” He built a log cabin in Canada so he could hunt and fish more easily.
Through a friend who owned a lodge in Canada, Oberbeck met a Chicago flying instructor who invited him to take a plane ride.
Oberbeck, looking the instructor squarely in the eye said, “Give me a lesson.”
After 4 ½ hours of instruction, he made his first solo flight – at the age of 65.
“I’ve driven a car over 55 years and I feel safer in my plane,” said Oberbeck.
He noted that a flyer has to have a physical every two years.
“My doctor told me I’ll be flying when I’m 90.” Oberbeck said with a grin.
And painting backdrops, hopes Wolf” (page 56).
1966 article about Art Oberbeck.
In his 1972 speech, Oberbeck credited Wolf as the “most wonderful man that ever lived.” Oberbeck’s adoration for Wolf should be of little surprise: Wolf gave Oberbeck purpose again.
Oberbeck passed away on Dec. 24, 1978, in Dallas, Texas, yet his legacy lived on.
Examples of Oberbeck’s scenic art were shared by designer George L. Pettit, in a booklet entitled “Art Oberbeck, Samples of the Art of Scene Painting.” The small twenty-one-page handout was published by Cortec Corrugated Cardboard Technology for the Theatre, It included twenty-one examples of scenic art techniques, painted by Oberbeck on 3’x3’ squares of heavy-weight muslin. The caption below each scenic art example on the following pages included a picture of Pettit showing him holding the samples alongside the caption: “I acquired them in the bankruptcy sale around 1978. At the time, Art was in his later 80’s or early 90’s.
The cover page depicted a tree trunk painted by Oberbeck with the caption, “Art painted these 3’x3’ examples on heavy muslin while working at Peter Wolf Associates, Dallas, TX, in the 1970s. Painted for the USITT conference in Dallas [1971], they were painted on a vertical paint frame when he was, I believe, in his late 80s.”
Booklet with samples of Art Oberbeck’s painting.First page in booklet with Oberbeck’s work.
In 1915, the J. M. Deeds Scenic Studio of Spokane contracted with the Hub Theatre in Okanogan, Washington, to produce two 60-feet-long murals for the venue. Recently uncovered, these two murals shed a little light on the history of theatre manufacturers in the Pacific Northwest during the early twentieth century. When Deeds secured the Okanogan contract, his firm had already painted scenery and decorated auditoriums at Chelan’s Ruby Theatre and the Wenatchee Theatre. Prior to establishing his scenic studio in Spokane, Deeds was well known for his scenic art and advertising curtains in California and Oregon.
Section of mural by scenic artist representing the J. M. Deeds Scenic Studio if Spokane, 1915.Detail of mural in Okanogan.Map showing the location of Okanogan in relation to Vancouver, Seattle and Spokane.
James Marion Deeds was born in Windsor, California, on October 27, 1877. For geographical context, Windsor is located in Sonoma County, due west of Sacramento and just north of Santa Rosa. He was the son of James B. Deeds and Millie Grey. By the age of three, the Deeds family moved north to Red Bluff, California, approximately 125 miles north of Sacramento. The 1880 US Federal Census listed that the Deeds household included James Sr. (b. 1858), Millie (b. 1862), James Jr. (3) and Lillie (8 months.). At the time, James Sr. was working as a farmer. By 1887, the Deeds family moved south to Woodland, California, where James B. Deeds continued to work as a farmer. On Sept. 10, 1887, the “Sacramento Daily Record” reported that grain was being “cut and thrashed by James Deeds, of Woodland” for county exhibits at the state fair that year (page 5). Woodland is approximately 20 miles due west of Sacramento.
By the age of seventeen, James M. Deeds was living in the San Francisco area, and going by the name “J. M. Deeds.” In 1894, he was competing as an athlete, representing the Young Men’s Christian Association (YMCA). On April 29, 1894, the “San Francisco Call” listed that YMCA member, J. M. Deeds, competed in a one-mile race in the Midwinter Fairgrounds as part of the Olympic Club Contests (page 7). At the time, he was competing for a cash prize. On May 2, 1894, the “San Francisco Call” announced that Deeds participated in the one-mile handicap run Games in Recreation Park, also part of the Olympic Club Games (page 9).
Over the next few years, Deeds athletic achievements frequently made the news. On May 29, 1895, J. M. Deeds was listed as a participant in the Caledonia Games, held during the Caledonia Club picnic. Deeds participated in both the 300-yard handicap run and 500-yard handicap run. Later than summer, Deeds traveled with a group from the Oakland YMCA to Bryant’s ranch. The young men were identified as “lovers of pedestrianism and healthful recreation,” (“San Francisco Call,” 13 July 1895, page 8). During the summer of 1895 Deeds tied for third in the standing wide jump during the Scots Picnic in Sacramento. On July 3, 1895, the “Stockton Record” reported that J. M. Deeds, representing the YMCA of Oakland, participated in the running high jump and standing broad jump in the Field Day Games in Stockton.”
On June 22, 1896, the “San Francisco Call” reported that J. M. Deeds participated in an event at the Shell Mound shooting range as part of the contest for class medals by the Red Men’s Shooting Section (page 5). On July 5, 1896, the “San Francisco Call” noted that J. M. Deeds of the Reliance Athletic Club placed second in the running high jump at the Stockton Carnival of Sport (page 6).
J. M. Deeds pictured in 1896
On 7 July 1896 the “San Francisco Chronicle” reported, “Oakland, July 6 – The Reliance Club has lost a star member of its athletic team, and at the same time the Stockton Athletic Club has gathered in a man who will be expected to make new records for it. Oakland’s loss has been Stockton’s gain and the members of the local organization feel much chagrined over the turn affairs have taken. James M. Deed was regarded as a pillar of the Reliance Club. He held the Coast record for high jumping for many years. On the Fourth of July he went to Stockton to spend the day and before nightfall he had signed with the Stockton Athletic Club. His resignation as a member of the Oakland Club was mailed, and to-day it came to President Fitzgerald at the club headquarters. Deeds was a man of great promise, and it was expected that he would gain many honors for the Reliance Club in coming contests. Mush astonishment is expressed by the local athletes at Deed’s sudden break from the ranks of the Reliance Club will be developed and an effort will be made to hold the records which he established in this city” (page 14).
It was in 1897 that Deeds became involved with the theatre industry, working as an advance man for the Unique Entertainment Company. On Dec. 8, 1897, the “Marysville Evening Democrat” of Marysville, CA, reported, “James M. Deeds, advance agent of the Unique Entertainment Company, was in town to-day” (page 4). On Feb. 12, 1898, the “Free Press” of Redding, California, announced, “James M. Deeds and M. Aspden of San Francisco arrived here Thursday morning. They are giving exhibitions of Edison’s projectoscope and are now en route to Trinity county” (page 4). Their production was advertised as “Electrical entertainment” (“Daily Evening News, Modesto, California, 9 Nov. 1897, page 1). M. Aspden was actually, Martha Aspden, a music teacher and vocalist. She provided the musical entertainment during each projectoscope exhibition.
The Unique Entertainment Company was run by M. Aspden and Arthur Troibert. Many of the advertisements sadly misspelled Troibert’s last name as Trolbert – consistently. On September 28, 1897, the “Santa Cruz Sentinel” of Santa Cruz, California, published an advertisement for Troibert & Aspden’s Unique Entertainment Company, entitled “The Projectoscope, Edison’s latest improved moving picture machine scenes. Natural as life” (page 2).
On Nov. 8, 1897, “The Modesto Bee” published a detailed description of the Unique Entertainment Co. production. The article reported, “Armory Opera House. On Next Friday and Saturday evenings, November 12th and 13th, the people of this city will be given another rare treat in the line of entertainment and amusement by Troibert & Aspden’s Unique Entertainment Company who come highly praised by the press of other cities in which they have played. Their program consists of Edison’s Projectoscope, the latest improved moving picture machine which throws a series of foreign and domestic animated scenes on a large screen with a clear, distinct and steadiness that cannot be claimed for previously invented moving picture machines. There also exhibit the stereopticon views of the Klondike which attracted such wide-spread attention at the Chutes in San Francisco recently. These are the original views which were taken by the Canadian government surveyors and the lecture which is very interesting and instructive is officially correct. Those who contemplate a trip to the northern gold fields next spring should not miss the opportunity of seeing these views as they convey a very good idea of the hardships of the journey. Miss Martha Aspden is a soprano of remarkable wide range and softness of voice, who sings favorite selection from famous operas and plays her own accompaniment on the violin. She is highly spoken of by the daily press of San Francisco and other cities. Troibert the merry wizard comes with flashing newspaper notices and will give some of the best and latest illusions in sleight-of-hand and modern magic. As many of our citizens have enjoyed and evening with him before, he will no doubt be greeted with crowded houses each night. They give and entire change of program each evening and everyone should go prepared to laugh, roar and scream. The general admission is 25 cents, children 15 cents. Seats can be reserved without extra charge at the Moss Rose” (page 3).
On Dec. 17, 1897, the “Chico Weekly” included an advertisement entitled, “Edison’s Projectoscope” (page 1). The article continued, “Troibert and Aspden’s Unique entertainment company will hold forth at Armory Opera House for three nights beginning Thursday, December 16. Their program consists of some very attractive features. The Edison Projectoscope is the very latest improved moving picture machine, showing animated scenes (life size) with a clear distinctiveness that puts all previously invented machines in the shade. The Spanish Bull Fight (taken in Spain) is one of the views shown. The views of Klondyke are copies of the originals which were taken by the Canadian Government Surveyors, and exhibited at the Chutes, San Francisco” (page 1).
In addition to his entertainment and sports activities, Deeds enlisted in the National Guard on Nov. 21, 1895. He served until 1898 when he enlisted in the Spanish-American War. Both Deeds and his father served in the military at this time.
Deeds enlisted as a private in the California Infantry on June 28, 1898. On July 1, 1898, Deeds was listed as part of Company A, Eighth Regiment, when the left Chico for Camp Barrett that summer. On July 5, 1898, an article in the “Woodland Daily Democrat” listed James Deeds as a member of the Chico company of Eighth Regiment at Camp Barrett, Deeds was listed as a one-time resident of Woodland (page 4). On January 14, 1899, the “San Jose Herald” announced, “J. M. Deeds, first lieutenant of Company A. of the English regiment, spent Saturday and Sunday with Mrs. Montgomery and family on Santa Cruz avenue.” Deeds fought in the Spanish-American War until his discharge on Feb 6, 1899.
It remains unclear as to where Deeds settled or what he did between the spring of 1899 and the spring of 1901, yet he likely spent is significant amount of time in Pomona, where he met Nellie Jennie Dappen (1881-1958). By 1901, the young couple was engaged. On April 2, 1901, the “Pomona Progress” reported, “J. M. Deeds and Miss Jennie Dappen will be married next Monday at Keller’s hotel. Mr. Deeds is now in San Luis Obispo compiling a city directory, and the couple will leave for that place after the wedding” (page 3). Interestingly, Deeds completed the directory that fall, and on Sept. 23, 1901, the “San Luis Obispo Telegram” reported, “The first San Luis Obispo city and county directory ever published has just been issued by J. M. Deeds.” On April 3, 1901, “The Los Angeles Times” announced their marriage license: “James M. Deeds, aged 23, a native of California, and Nellie J. Dappen, aged 19, a native of Missouri; both residents of Pomona (page 12) – Marriage License. On April 8, 1901, “The Pomona Progress” reported, “The Marriage of James M. Dees and Miss Nellie J. Dappen was celebrated at Keller’s hotel at 2:30 o’clock Sunday afternoon, Rev. W. G. Clatworthy officiating. The groom has spent most of the past two months in Pomona and the bride came here about a year ago from Colorado. They took the afternoon train for Los Angeles, and after a few days there will go to San Luis Obispo, where Mr. Deeds is engaged in the publication of a city and county directory” (page 1).
By the next year, Deeds was working for a new entertainment firm. On, Jan. 18, 1902, “The Californian” of Salinas, California, reported, “Messrs. P. Young and J. M. Deeds representing the Pacific Coast Advertising Company are looking after business interests in Salinas.” A day earlier, “The Californian” reported, “Will Place a New Curtain. The Pacific Coast Advertising Company of Oakland has secured the advertising curtain in the opera house for a period of fourteen months. The new curtain will arrive in a few days and promises to be a work of art” (page 3). This is the first mention that I have located regarding Deeds work with advertising curtains.
Over the next few years, the couple celebrated the birth of three children: Woodson Crittendon Deeds (1903), Cecille Thelma Deeds (1905) and Maxwell A. Deeds (1907). In between supporting his growing family and managing various projects, Deeds was able to enjoy a little leisure time. On July 31, 1901, the “San Luis Obispo Telegram” announced, “J. M. Deeds caught eleven trout while fishing yesterday in San Luis creek.”
By 1903, the Deeds family moved to Sacramento. In “The Fresno Morning Republican” Deeds was identified as a Sacramento businessman. In Sacramento, Deeds continued in the advertising curtain industry; this time with a new partner, William Henry Funk (1875-1940). The two established the scenic studio named Deeds & Funk, a company that specialized in advertising curtains for theaters. Immediately they became known as “the Ad Men.” On Nov. 7, 1903, the “Woodland Daily Democrat” of Woodland, California, reported, “J.M. Deeds of the firm of Deeds & Funk, the ‘Ad’ men, is in this city today” (page 1). W. H. Funk was born in Bloomington, Illinois, Funk moved to California in 1901 and married Alice V. Montgomery (1883-1936). Remember that while on leave from the military in 1899, Deeds visited the home of Mrs. Montgomery and family on Santa Cruz avenue.” Same family. In later newspaper reports the relationship was clarified: “Mrs. Funk, who is the sister of Mr. Deeds, is also in Medford, and on Wednesday evening Mrs. Deeds and son arrived from San Francisco.” I have yet to pinpoint the exact relationship and wonder if Alice was affectionately referred to as a “sister,” maybe a close childhood friend.
Deeds & Funk advertised themselves as “The Ad Men” in 1904.
Although Deeds was a skilled painter, Funk was the much more-experienced artist. They both painted scenery, but Funk took the lead as the artistic head of the firm, hiring local assistants when necessary. Various newspaper accounts paint Deeds as a quite charming; the consummate salesman who could talk you into anything. Deeds landed the majority of work and Funk guided the designs. Deeds & Funk took an interesting approach to the marketing of advertising curtains, making it as an economically-wise choice: “Because the rates are lower in proportion than any other advertising. It reaches more people than any other ad you can place.”
However, it was a bit of a bumpy start. In the beginning as they clashed with the local Painters’ and Sign Writers’ Union over the ACME Theatre curtain in Sacramento, California. On Jan. 21, 1904, the “Sacramento Bee” published a letter to the Editor that condemned the actions of Deeds & Funk (page 5). The letter written by A. A. Killen on Jan. 25, 1904, and entitled, “Now Let the Curtain Be Rung Down.”
“To the Editor of The Bee – Sir:
I presume you feel like Mercutio and would say: “A curse o’ both your houses” – but never having replied to the anonymous article. “A Reply to Killen,” and now being further attacked by parties signing themselves “Deeds & Funk,” I crave your indulgence and ask space for a few words.
The sun does shine, notwithstanding the fact that all do not see it. The labor among local sign painters has been used considerably in advance of the curtain episode. It was only at that time that Mr. Green entered upon the scene and found things without a title – so per se – we need the Union label, and without it I cannot read my title clear, but I have invested coin and I must, lawyer-like, argue there was no label, there is no label. But Mr. Funk’s case is different. He knew the Union label was in use, so did Mr. Deeds – else why were they so anxious to secure it prior to our last election? Why did Mr. Funk object to window dressers painting show cards? And why did he remark that he would stop them when he obtained the Union label? Simply because he recognized its adoption by the local sign painters.
No, the Union label was never used until they wanted to get a curtain painted, but Mr. Deeds knew he could sell more of Mr. Funk’s work is he had the use of the label. As to the fine for not using according to our by-laws, it takes three readings to enact a law; or to make it operative, that takes three weeks, and this was done long before the election in November.
Now the anonymous writer and the same writer in the last article seem desirous to call attention and comparison between Grauman curtain and the Acme. The Grauman curtain was painted in my shop; it is 11×13 feet, and is viewed from a long, narrow room; it was accepted and paid for and proved a good investment for Mr. Green; its total cost, hung, was about $83 – that money was all spent in Sacramento. The Acme curtain comes in contact with very different surroundings and is 20×21 feet; its earning capacity is nearly three times as great as the Grauman. Why should it not cost twice as much to paint it? Did the advertiser receive lower rates because the curtain cost less – or was the firm afraid that if they spent their money in Sacramento the sign painters would get dizzy from their wealth? A few more curtain deals and Deeds, Funk & Green could ride in an auto – even if the local sign painters did not trudge behind on foot.
About prices: the local sign painters without exception pay shop rent, telephone, electrical lights and fuel bills and some advertising and are willing to complete with sign painters similarly situated in San Francisco. Notwithstanding the fact that they handle work in much larger quantities that we do, their jobs average $20 to our $5. As to the covert sneer about delay of the label from headquarters, perhaps at some future time our general officers at Lafayette will answer for themselves.
By the way, considerable information regarding the union label can be obtained from reading the official Painters’ Journal and all painters receive it who are entitled to it. Read it up, brothers, and avoid mistakes with the next ad curtain you don’t paint.
A. A. Killen
Sacramento, January 25th”
They soon focused on work outside of Sacramento. After all, there was plenty work out there and the demand for painted scenery outpaced the supply of scenic artists to complete the work. On March 12, 1904, “The Placer Herald” in Rocklin, California, reported, “New Curtain for Opera House. J.M. Deeds of the firm Deeds & Funk, advertising specialists of Sacramento, has been in town this week, and made arrangements to put in a fireproof curtain at the Opera House. Aside from being protection against fire, the curtain will be of handsome design, and will contain the cards of many of our businessmen” (page 1). On May 3, 1904, “The Morning Union” of Grass Valley, California, reported “W. H. Funk and J. M. Deeds have arrived from Sacramento to repaint the curtain in the Nevada theater” (page 5). The two soon headed north to Oregon but maintained their business offices in Sacramento and Los Angeles. On June 3, 1904, “The Medford Mail” of Medford, Oregon, reported, “J. M. Deeds and W. H. Funk, of San Francisco, are in Medford this week at working and repainting the drop curtain at the Wilson opera house. The have worked fairly well along and it presents a very pretty appearance – much prettier than any curtain which has yet been painted for that house. The design is beautiful and at nighttime, when electric lights are on will show up grandly and give splendid effect to the many advertisements which the gentlemen have placed there for our merchants” (June 3, 1904, page 5). Two weeks later, on June 16, 1904, “The Rosenburg Review” reported that “Deeds & Funk of Los Angeles and Sacramento” owned and operated over 40 advertising curtains in California and Oregon (page 2). On June 29, 1904, “The Eugene Morning Register” reported, “[Deeds & Funke] have on their list 50 curtains they have designed between Eugene and their home city [Sacramento], the last one completed at Rosenburg” (page 8).
Deeds & Funk spent the rest of the summer in Oregon. On June 23, 1904, the “Weekly Rogue Courier” of Grants Pass, Oregon, announced that Deeds & Funk had placed several “very attractive advertising curtains” in many leading theatres of California and Oregon” (page 2).
On June 28, 1904, the “Morning Register” of Eugene, Oregon, reported, “Painting New Drop Curtain. Sacramento Firm Doing Work at the Eugene Theater. Deeds & Funk of Sacramento, the theatrical advertising firm, are in Eugene for the purpose of painting a new drop curtain for the Eugene theater. They have just completed a fine curtain for the Roseburg opera house and do first-class work. The work on the curtain is in progress and will be ready for business ads, in a day or so.” (page 8).
An advertisement placed by “Deeds & Funk, the Ad Men” on July 3, 1904, stated:
“Two Classes of people who do not attend the theater. Those who do not believe in such a place of entertainment, and those who are physically incapacitated, aside from these two classes, upon some one occasion or another during the eighty times or more every year that this local opera house is used, nearly every man, woman, and child in this city, and surrounding community attend. At a cost of not exceeding 25 cents, nor less than 12 ½ cents each night, you can put an ad where they cannot help but read it, namely on a new scenic ad curtain in a space of no less than eight and up to twenty square feet. It is a straight, honest, publicity, recognized and used as such by leading merchants throughout the world. The curtains contain over six hundred square feet, and as two-fifths of it is devoted to scenery and draperies, it is a work of art as well as a splendid advertising medium.
There are about twenty-five spaces, and each space is separate and by itself.
Ten of the leading business firms of Eugene have already engaged spaces, and their ads are now being artistically arranged and painted in their separated spaces.
Think it over. We’ll call on you if you don’t call on us.
It’s Good and it Catches the eye.
That’s the way it strikes us.
How does it strike you?
(signed) Deeds & Funk, the Ad Men”
On July 8, 1904, the “Morning Register” of Eugene, Oregon, credited Deeds & Funk with an advertising curtain for the Eugene Theater. The article reported, “Messrs. Deeds & Funk, the Sacramento firm who have been painting a new drop curtain at the Eugene Theater completed their work yesterday and from an artistic point of view the curtain is a thing of beauty. Grouped around a splendid scene are the place signs of the reputative business firms of the city, fully held in the folds of the drapery painted with skill and excellent taste, by Mr. Funk. Deeds & Funk have performed a job that commands them to all the managers on the coast. The gentlemen accompanied by their wives left this morning for home of the McKenzie” (page 8).
Work was so lucrative in Oregon, that Deeds and his wife relocated to Eugene by 1905. His relationship with Funke seemed to have paused at this point, as Funk was not mentioned in relation to Deeds until 1908. On Nov. 14, 1908, Eugene’s “Morning Register” reported, “Mr. and Mrs. W. H Funk of Sacramento, California, arrived last night and will put on the Electric theater their actophone, which is a combination of the voices with the actions in the pictures. They are old friends and business companions of J. M. Deeds of this city” (page 8). Again, this suggests that the two closed Deeds & Funk in 1905, with Deeds moving to Eugene and Funk remaining in Sacramento.
In Eugene, Deeds diversified his business investments, becoming associated with the Eugene Land Co. He had preciously invested in the Maywood Colony in Red Bluff, California. the Eugene Land Co. was located in Bijou theatre building in Eugene. On March 7, 1906, Eugene’s “Morning Register” reported, “A New Land Co. J. M. Deeds, manager of the Eugene Land company, opened in the Bijou Theatre building yesterday morning. The company is handling the Campbells addition to Eugene, a fine tract of land on the western edge of the city and will do general business. Mr. Deeds has been employed to handle the company’s business through the knowledge of his wide experience in the real estate business, gained in California, where he was connected with the famous Maywood colony. The Campbell property is meeting with ready sale, owing to the class of lots the easy payment system on which these lots are sold and for the reason that they are cheap. Mr. Deeds was employed by Register for six months and we recommend him as a reliable man” (page 3). Deeds’ real estate transactions pertaining to the Maywood Colony were repeatedly listed in the “Red Bluff News” during 1904.
In Eugene, Deeds also sold apples and played baseball. On March 8, 1906, the “Eugene Morning Register” announced that J. M. Deeds was selling Siuslaw apples at 5 cents a pound, selling in lots of 20 lbs. or more. That spring Deed played baseball with others from the northside of Eugene that included J. J. McCormick, Will Branstetter, and “Shorty” Russell. (“Morning Register,” 13 April 1906, page 4). Deeds even worked temporarily as an accountant for a local bank, but in the end, he was still known “J. M. Deeds, the artist of Eugene.” He was slowly accumulating funds to open his own studio.
Deeds continued to work as a scenic artist, despite taking a series of odd jobs in Eugene. When completing painting projects in nearby towns, he continued the practice of hiring local labor to reduce overall expenses. On July 24, 1906, the “Corvallis Gazette” in Corvallis, Oregon, reported, “Cecil Cathey, who enjoys a good local reputation as a sign writer, was engaged by J. M. Deeds, to assist in the lettering the main drop curtain in the opera house. The work is of an order justifying pride on Cecil’s part” (page 3). On August 7, 1906, the “Morning Register” reported, “J. M. Deeds, the artist, who has just completed a fine drop curtain at Corvallis is now at work on the drop in Eugene Theatre and is doing fine work” (page 4).
On Aug. 14, 1908, the “Albany Democrat” of Oregon reported, “J. M. Deeds, of Eugene, is in the city renewing contracts for space on his opera house contract, now up for a year. He was recently in California, and thinks the valley is far ahead of the places he visited” (page 3). On August 28, 1908, the “Albany Democrat” reported, “A fine showhouse. The new Wonderland Theater, for moving pictures, opposite Fortmiller Bros., will be one of the most artist affairs in the valley. Something new will be the proscenium theatre art effect, being arranged by J. M. Deeds, the artist of Eugene, who has painted nine pictures for the effect, six to be used inside, three outside, making the theatre a very attractive place. And the pictures shown will be in keeping with the surroundings” (page 5). On October 30, 1908, the “Morning Register” reported, “J.M. Deeds left for Hoquiam, Wash., yesterday where he expects to put in a theatre curtain” (page 5).
By 1909, Deeds began to solely focus on scenic art. On Aug. 27, 1909, Deeds was mentioned twice in the “Albany Democrat.” The newspaper reported, “J. M. Deeds, the artist of Eugene, left Saturday evening on his trip to Portland, after looking after his drop curtain at the opera house. While one of Eugene’s best boosters Mr. Deeds declared that there wasn’t a place in the valley that had made a more striking change in a year than Albany during the past years, and nowhere is there a city with better surrounding for progress” (page 3
Deeds briefly returned to California in 1910, possibly to relocate his family back home. That year he was listed twice in the 1910 US Federal Census twice, each dated April 1915. In the first census, Deeds was living in Long Beach, California, with his wife, three children and his 32-yrs.-old sister-in-law, Ora E. Dappen. For a brief period of time, Deeds was listed as a commercial traveler working with theatre curtain advertising. He was also listed as a lodger on 22 ½ street in Sacramento, employed as a solicitor in the advertising company industry. In his second census listing, Deeds was living in an apartment complex by himself alongside several other individuals working in the theatre industry. His neighbors included actors and architects. This is likely when he separated from his first wife and planned his move to Spokane, Washington.
On Dec. 6, 1911, the “Spokane Chronicle” reported, “Local Scenic Artist Gets Colville Contract. J. M. Deeds, a well-known local scenic artist, has been given the contract for furnishing the curtain and stage settings for a $20,000 theater recently constructed at Colville by the Odd Fellow. The work in finishing the curtain will be completed by December 16” (page 2). On Dec. 2, 1911, “The Colville Examiner” reported, “J. M. Deeds of the Deeds Scenic Studio of Spokane, has been given the contract for the complete stage fittings of the new opera house, and expects to start the work soon. Local artisans will do the carpenter work, and Mr. Deeds’ best artist will come up to do the curtain painting. It is the plan to give Colville opera house an up-to-date stage. The work will take three or four weeks. All the materials are to be purchased from local merchants. Mr. Deeds is the one who has the contract to put up the new drop curtain at the Spokane Auditorium next month” (page 3). Deeds was not only listed as an employee at the Auditorium Theater in Spokane, but also operating his own scenic studio in the Auditorium.
On Jan. 10, 1912, “The Spokesman-Review” reported that Deeds landed a contract for the Lewis and Clark High School stage in an article entitled, “Paint High School Scenery” (page 6) The article reported, “The J. M. Deeds scenic studio, which was awarded the contract for furnishing the $1188 equipment at the Lewis and Clark high school stage, have the frames completed and began the painting yesterday. The work will be ready for the stage early in February, The stage fittings are four complete changes of scenes.”
On Feb. 15, 1912, “The Spokesman-Review” announced, “Will Give Curtain.” The article continued, “August Paulsen will make present to New High School Auditorium. August Paulsen, well-known capitalist, has agreed to donate the curtain for the auditorium of the new Lewis and Clark high school. J. M. Deeds, manager of the Deeds scenic studio, has been given the contract for painting the curtain. The contract is left upon the condition that after its completion it will be satisfactory to Paulsen. Deeds will commence work this week. The curtain will cost $600. Six weeks will be required to finish the work. At the bottom in small letters will be “August Paulsen.” Six weeks will be required to finish the work. Mr. Paulsen, Fred P. Green, president of the school board; Mr. Deeds and Mr. Harding, manager of the Paulsen Realty company, made a trip through the new high school building this morning” (page 6).
Deeds continued to make inroads with the Spokane business community. On Feb. 22, 1912, Spokane’s “Spokesman Review” reported, “J. M. Deeds of the Auditorium theaters and L. S. Hurtig were admitted active members of the ad men’s club luncheon yesterday” (page 7). A week later, on Feb. 29, 1912, the “Spokane Chronicle” reported, “J. M. Deeds will install the settings for Stage at St. Aloysius Hall” (page 8) The article reported, “J. M. Deeds, manager of the Deeds scenic studio, was this morning awarded the contract for furnishing the stage and appliances for the new St. Aloysius parish hall by Father George P. Butler, S. J. Work on painting the scenery will start immediately and part of it will be installed by March 18 in time for the play to be given by the seniors of Gonzaga college. The contract is for the following: One fancy parlor setting, including 10 pieces plain chamber scene of eight pieces, front curtain with Venetian scene, street scene, Ohio scene, picture screen, garden drop, wood scene, three sets of borders, six wood wings, cottage settings, sky tabs, tormentors and gold drapery.” The influx of work helped secure the necessary funds for Deeds to build a stand-alone studio for his business.
On 11 March 1912, the “Spokane Chronicle” announced, “To Build Scenic Studio in City.
J. M. Deeds Incorporates a Stock Company to Build $6000 Structure” (page 2). The article continued, “The Deeds Scenic Studio, of which J. M. Deeds is manager, is to be incorporated into a stock company and a $6000 building is to be built in Spokane as its permanent home.
Three local theatrical men are now interested in the corporation of the company and Robert Sweatt, local architect, has been instructed to draw plans for the building. The entire building, 100×40 feet will be devoted to the painting of scenes for theaters. The building will contain a display stage and the room for the hanging of curtains will be from 60 to 70 feet in height. M. S. Anderson, an artist of 30-years-experience, has been engaged as head artist for the new studio. Mr. Deeds will also conduct his studio in the Auditorium block for the convenience of traveling theatrical companies. The studio has been in operation for the last year.”
On April 12, 1912, “The Spokane Chronicle” reported, “The new scenery which was recently installed in the hall at a cost of $1250 will be used for the first time. The scenery was designed by J. M. Deeds, who designed the scenery at the Lewis and Clark high school.” This was in an article about the play “Breezy Point,” starring Miss Katherine Connelly, at the parish hall of St. Aloysius” (page 19).
Deeds continued to make headlines that Fall. He certainly understood the benefits derived from self-promotion and marketing. On Oct. 6, 1912, “The Spokesman-Review” included a huge article about Deeds:
“Scene Painting is New Industry.
J. M. Deeds will build unique studio to paint and make stage fittings.
Contracts Completed.
Newest Product of Spokane Already in Great Demand in Inland Empire Towns.
Plans are being completed and work is expected to start withing a few weeks on a home for one of the most novel industries that has as yet entered the industrial life of the city, when a modern scenic studio will be opened by J. M. Deeds. For the last 18 months he has been doing his work under a disadvantage on the stages of the Auditorium and American theaters when these were not in use, R. C. Sweatt is drawing plans for the studio, which will be erected on the north side on one of two sites now under consideration.
The nature of the work calls for a building of unusual dimensions to permit of the hanging of large theatre drop curtains while these are being painted, The plans call for a building 100×50 feet and 70 feet high to cost approximately $12,000. Deeds who had 10 years’ experience in the work at Sacramento, California., and Eugene, Oregon., before coming to Spokane, is organizing a stock company and articles of incorporation are already prepared. Since coming to the city Deeds has painted scenery for several local buildings and many out of the city. Among these are:
Lewis and Clark building, North Central high school, St. Aloysius parish hall, Ellensburg opera house, Wenatchee theater, Scenic theater, Leavenworth; Odd Fellow’s theaters at Monroe and Colville, Casino at Republic, Auditorium at Davenport, Parish hall at Nelson, B.C.; Nelson opera house, Odd Fellows’ hall at Bonners Ferry, Burford’s Theatorium at Lewistown, Woodmen’s opera house at Grand Bend, Grand at Missoula, Mont., and Odd Fellows’ theater at Garfield. Deeds furnishes scenery and stage appliances complete and at the present time his force of 11 men are completing contracts as follows: Keylor Grand theater, Walla Walla; Bijou Grand, Walla Walla; Temple, Lewiston; Ridgeway, Colfax; new opera houses at Austin and Cashmere and scenery for the interstate fair. Rush of work has made it necessary for Deeds to increase his force to 13 men” (page 31).
As in Sacramento with Funk, Deeds again focused on sales, leaving more skilled artists to paint the scenery. He lined up a series of projects that continued to generate profits for the firm and continued to expand his work force. He also found a partner, likely an investor- C. H. Eaton. I have yet to locate much information pertaining to Eaton, including a first name. Meanwhile, Deeds’ scenic studio continued to make news.
On May 29, 1913, “The Spokane Chronicle” reported in the “Realty and Business News” section: “Scenery and Curtains for All Kinds are manufactured by Local Company” (page 14). The article included a picture of Deeds studio included with caption: “Show in the above picture is an interior view of the Deeds Scenic Studio plant on E8 Trent avenue. The Spokane Enterprise was started in 1911 with only one employee. It now has a payroll of 16 persons, practically all specialists in the production of theatre scenery, and in planning to greatly extend its territory, insuring a further increase of payroll.”
Interior of J. M. Deeds Scenic Studio that accompanied the 1913 article in the “Spokane Chronicle.”
The article continued: “Deeds Scenic Studio Handles Work in Many Northwest Towns. Local Firm Started with one man, now has fine plant and 16 employees.
A home industry established in 1911 with one employee, now an organized partnership with a manufacturing plant and a payroll of 16 employees, having the prospect of greatly increasing its force and extending the field of its operations – is the unique record of the Deeds Scenic Studio, E8 Trent avenue, builders of theaters scenery of all kinds.
J. M. Deeds and C. H. Eaton are the partners in the business, which now extends over the states of Washington, Idaho, Oregon, and Montana. The partners said today they are prepared to extend their field to include western Canada, Utah, and Wyoming in the near future.
The production of theater scenery was started by Mr. Deeds here in December 1911, Not having an advantage of a plant at first, he worked in the Auditorium and American theaters here and at the Colfax Theatre at Colfax. Mr. Eaton became a partner in the firm in April of this year and the work on installing the studio in its new quarters has already been largely completed.
Have carpenter Shop.
The first floor is devoted to the carpenter shop, which is now well equipped. Additional woodworking machinery, however, is on the way to Spokane, and will be installed as soon as it arrives. The second story is devoted to the general decorating and manufacturing work and also contained the offices. Frame equipment is afforded here for curtains 45×32 feet. There are also two 32-foot frames and two 26-foot frames.
The Deeds Scenic studio is now completing work for theater at Pocatello, Idaho; Baker City, Oregon, and for the Fraternal Opera house at Tekoa. Work is also underway on the curtains for the new high school at Moscow, Idaho.
‘This is the only studio of the kind between Minneapolis and the Coast,’ said Mr. Deeds today. ‘We are prepared to cover the territory completely, including the states of Wyoming, Utah and the Western Canadian provinces, and we expect to invade the east. There is no reason why we should not do this since we are prepared to complete with them in workmanship as well as salesmanship. Mr. Deeds has been engaged in the production of theater scenery for 10 years and during that time has traveled extensively, visiting the leading studios in the east and middle west.” (page 14).
On June 27, 1913, “The Spokane Chronicle” reported, “J. M. Deeds, senior member of the Deeds Art Studio company, left this afternoon for a two weeks’ visit in Chicago and other middle western points. On his way east he will stop at Pocatello, Idaho, where he will install a chapter of the St. Anthony’s order” (page 6). On July 19, 1913, “The Spokane Chronicle” reported, “J. M. Deeds, senior member of the Deeds Art studio firm, has returned from an extended business trip through the Inland Empire. He has engaged W. F. Berry, a scenic artist of the east, to assist in the work of painting the scenes and curtains for which orders were taken (page 6).
Deeds continued to travel throughout the region for work, and soon met his second wife. On June 8, 1914, “The Spokesman-Review” reported,
“Cupid is Busy at Cashmere.
Announcement Tells of Wedding Several Months Ago.
Cashmere, Wash., June 7. -…Miss Nellie Stoffer and J. M. Deeds of Seattle were married in Victoria, B.C. several months ago, but the fact was announced here only lately. Miss Stoffer has had charge of the music in the schools here for two years. They will live in Seattle” (page 7). Nellie Katherine Stoffer (1885 – 1981) was the daughter of Andrew Jackson Stoffer (1853-1905) and Susan Hyde (1863-1934). This gets a bit confusing as both Deeds’ first wife and second wife shared the same first name – Nellie. Nellie Dappen was his first wife and Nellie Stoffer was his second wife.
On Dec. 7, 1915, the “Okanogan Independent Newspaper” reported, “Mr. Deeds has just completed the decorations for the Wenatchee Theatre, which is said to be the finest in this part of the state and did the decorating for the Ruby Theatre known far and wide as one of the most attractive playhouses in the country.” Somehow, between contracting the murals for Okanogan’s Hub Theatre in 1915 and the beginning of 1917, Deeds returned to California. He was still working in Washington during 1916, but his work takes on takes a new twist.
On September 4, 1916, “The Spokesman-Review” reported, Page 8: “Davenport, Wash., Sept 3. – The home talent minstrel show under the auspices of the Davenport volunteer fire department Saturday night, directed by J. M. Deeds, pleased a crowded theater” (page 8). It did not specify that Deeds was solely providing the scenic elements for the production, instead he was directing the action.
In 1916, Deeds primarily made news as a fisherman, which makes me wonder what was going on at his scenic studio. On October 3, 1916, “The Spokesman-Review” reported, “Six salmon, weighing from 10 to 4 1-2 pounds were caught by J. M. Deeds in the Wenatchee river, near Dryden power plant. Mr. Deeds used a casting pole with linen line and spoon. It took from about 10 to 45 minutes of hard work to land the big fellow” (page 3). In 1916, J. M. Deeds was evened pictured in “The American Angler” (Winter 1916, Vol. 1, No. 3). Below his picture was the caption was: “J. M. Deeds of Seattle, Wash., and 7 lb. Rainbow Trout, Caught in Crab Creek, Lincoln County, Wash.” To date, this is the only photograph of Deeds that I have located.
J. M. Deeds pictured in “The American Angler,” 1916.
By the end of 1916, Deeds returned to California and was living in Red Bluff. In the beginning, he was still listed as a theatrical scenery contractor. Later on, he was listed as a scenic artist. On January 25, 1917, the “Auburn Journal” published an article about Deeds painting scenery for the Colfax Theatre in Auburn, California. Entitled, “Brushing Things Up,” the article reported, “S. K. Williams has engaged J. M. Deeds, theatrical scenery contractor, to install a new drop curtain with a local scene as the Centerpiece; also, a nine-piece fancy parlor set in the Colfax theatre. Mr. Deeds and his assistant are now engaged in the work. This is an improvement that will be greatly appreciated by the townspeople, especially by the home talent players.—Colfax Record.”
By February 1917, Deeds temporarily returned to work with for his old business partner in Sacramento, W. H. Funk in Sacramento. This was only temporary and may have been somewhat awkward after Deeds divorced his first wife. In 1917, Funk owned and operated an outdoor advertising company. Funk’s WWI draft registration card listed him as employed in the outdoor advertising industry and working for himself. At the time, the Funks were living at 3181 D St. in Sacramento. Funk’s physical appearance was described as medium height, stout, brown hair, and brown eyes. On Feb. 16, 1917, the “Sacramento Daily Union” reported, “The regular luncheon of the Rotary club was held at the Hotel Sacramento at noon yesterday. The time was spent In a pleasurable and profitable manner, land after special musical numbers and j several short talks by members a general discussion on attendance followed. J. M. Deeds, sales manager of W. H. Funk & Co., talked on outdoor advertising, and J Haley on the principles of Rotaryism.”
Interestingly, Deeds’ WWI draft registration card in 1917 listed his occupation as “Moving Picture Shows,” working at venues in Tehama and Shasta counties. Deeds’ physical description was listed as medium height, medium build, brown hair, and blue eyes. In Red Bluff, Deeds leased and managed the Red Bluff Opera House for seven months. Built in 1908, the Red Bluff Opera House was a 1,000-set venue that Deeds managed between 1917 and 1918. During that time, he hosted in a number of events that helped support the war effort, including benefit performances for the Red Cross and Liberty League.
While managing the Red Bluff opera house, Deeds was repeatedly referred to as “Sunny Jim” in newspaper articles and advertisements.
For example, on Nov. 6, 1917, Red Bluff’s “Daily People’s Cause,” reported, “Mary Pickford in ‘Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm’ is to be the opening of the opera house under the management of ‘Sunny Jim’ Deeds Saturday evening” (page 1). On Nov. 17, 1917, the “Daily People’s Cause” reviewed the much-anticipated production of Irving Berlin’s musical “Watch Your Step, scheduled to be shown at the Red Bluff Opera House. The article reported, “When the above newspaper’s critic puts his O.K. on a show it must be exceptionally good, and it is with a feeling of satisfaction that we can also place our approval on the motto of “Sunny Jim” Deeds, when he says that he will play only the first class shows while he has charge of the Red Bluff opera house.” (page 1).
On Jan. 11, 1918, the “Tehama County Daily Republican” still mentioned “Sunny Jim” Deeds, as the “genial manager of the opera house” (page 1). Deeds still had a handle on marketing; he placed ads in local newspapers announcing that red-headed boys would be admitted free to the Douglas Fairbanks matinee, “Reaching for the Moon.” In addition to managing the opera house, Deeds took on work as a painter.
One of the many advertisements placed by Jim Deeds when he managed the Red Bluff Opera House.
The stage at the Red Bluff Opera House offered studio space, where Deeds was able to complete a variety of painting projects. He was still working as a scenic artist. On Jan. 18, 1918, the “Red Bluff Daily News” included an article entitled, “J. M. Deeds Paints Map Orchard Park.” The article reported, “J. M. Deeds has proved that he is an artist as well as a first-class theatrical manager. Yesterday he placed in the window of the James Feeley Company on Main street a colored map of Orchard Park which shows the smallest detail relative to the big tract just south of Red Bluff. The map is a thing of beauty as well as being instructive and already has attracted a great deal of interest from the passersby. Orchard Park is one of the prettiest suburban tracts adjacent to the city and recently several big sales have been made to people from a distance who are anxious to come to Tehama county to make a permanent home.”
And then there was the family reunion…
On May 13, 1918, the “Tehama County Daily Republican” announced, “Father and Son Together after Twenty-Two Years” (page 1). The article reported, “A happy reunion after a period of twenty-two years took place today when J. B. Deeds and wife of Gridley, who chanced to be in Red Bluff on business, net their son, Jim M. Deeds, Manager of the Red Bluff Opera House. The meeting was purely accidental. The elder Deeds and his wife were passing along the street when Mrs. Deeds said, “There is our son” and stopped Jim, who was in his auto, and happy greetings of love and affection took place. Twenty-two years is a long time for families to be separated and without any knowledge as to each other’s whereabouts, but it also proves that after all the United States is not such a large place after all, because no one can get lost within its confines. The elder Deeds is in the real estate business and is here looking over some property, and may settle in Tehama county as a home, which in fact pleases ‘Sunny Jim’ all the more.”
On May 14, 1918, the “Red Bluff Daily News” carried a similar story:
“J. M. Deeds Meets Parents after a Long Separation.”
Manager Deeds of the Opera House met with a pleasant surprise yesterday morning when he stepped out of his automobile on Main street. He noticed a man standing in front of one of the business houses who looked familiar to mm. He started toward him and at the same time the man turned and recognized him. The stranger was J. B. Deeds, father of J. M. Deeds and the two had not met for twenty-two years. During the Spanish-American war Mr. Deeds and his father became separated and although both tried to get trace of the other, they were unable to find each other. Mr. Deeds, senior, has been living at Gridley, and he came to Red Bluff yesterday on land business. He was accompanied on the trip by Mrs. Deeds and the two have remained over for a few days’ visit with the son and his wife.” For a little context, Gridely was just 30 miles southeast of Chico, California, where James Deeds Jr. departed with Chico Company A of the Eighth Regiment during the Spanish-American War in 1898.
I find this whole story very strange and wonder what really happened to cause the separation in 1899. It’s not as if both men weren’t making news in the same region. Maybe the Deeds Jr. didn’t want to be found.
Interestingly, the spring of 1918 marked another transition for the J. M. Deeds as he gave up managing the Red Bluff Opera House and moved. On May 25, 1918, the “Red Bluff Daily News” announced, “J. M. Deeds Gives Up Opera House at Early Date.” The article continued, “The news that J. M. Deeds has relinquished the Opera House, will be generally regretted by the Red Bluff people. During the seven months that he has had charge of the Opera House he has given his patrons many of the best shows being played this season as well as putting on the best pictures that have been turned out by the producers. Mr. Deeds has also been an enthusiastic booster for Red Bluff, and has been active in all public affairs, and generous in donating the use of the Opera House for many patriotic and benefit gatherings. Mr. Deeds will continue his picture shows in the smaller towns for the present. He has had an offer of a responsible position and will probably accept it within the next thirty days.”
It doesn’t appear as if Deeds had an exit strategy when he left the opera house, and I have to wonder of the family reunion prompted his departure. That summer Deeds began to consider other employment opportunities, and still made the news, despite being unemployed.
On June 13, 1918, the “Red Bluff Daily News” reported, “Injured Foot. J. M. Deeds met with a painful accident last evening. He was working in his garden when he ran a spading fork in his left instep. A physician was called immediately, and the foot dressed. Mr. Deeds will be confined to the house for several weeks.” Despite his injury, Deeds began to game plan for the future and returned to painting. On June 18, he placed the following announcement in the “Red Bluff Daily News:
“Business Men Attention! While engaged in completing the contracts for highway signs and’ lettering several store fronts in this city, I can handle some additional work and will appreciate an opportunity of serving you. I believe in “signs” and “will sign anything.” J. M DEEDS.” His article ran in the paper or several consecutive days.
In December 1918, Jim and Nellie celebrated the birth of their first child, Jean M. Deeds. On Dec. 26, 1918, the “Red Bluff Daily News” reported, “Mrs. J. M. Deeds and baby have gone to Woodland for a two-week visit with relatives. They will go from there to Sacramento, where they will be joined later by Mr. Deeds.” In 1919, James and Nellie celebrated the birth of another child, a son named James Andrew Deeds. Deeds was still working as a scenic artist. On Jan. 22, 1921, an advertisement o page four by the McCormick-Richards Ins. Agency mentioned Deeds as a client:
“WHO’S NEXT?
Mr. J. M. Deeds, the scenic artist, was another “repeater” last fall. On October 8th, we paid him $12.65 for a small fire damage to his auto and, in less than a month (Nov. 3rd), “came-across” again to the tune of $66.08 for a collision damage which, among other things, smashed a front axel.
DOES MR. DEEDS BELIEVE IN AUTOMOBILE FIRE AND COLLISION INSURANCE?
WE’LL SAY HE DOES.
McCormick-Richards Ins. Agency, 410 Third Street. Phone 220
An article published on May 22, 1919, in the “Woodland Daily Democrat” credited Deeds with re-enameling and renumbering the “Old Town Clock” in Woodland, California (page 1). Later that summer he was still making news in Woodland. On August 5, 1919, the “Woodland Daily Democrat” announced, “Jim Deeds May Open Paint Shop in Fresno” (page 1). The article continued, “James Deeds leaves tomorrow for Fresno. He is thinking of opening another sign painting shop in the Raison City and will make an investigation of the prospects in that community. His family has moved to Sacramento.”
The 1920 US Federal Census listed James, Nellie, and their two children living at 2915 H St in Sacramento. Deeds was now listed as a district manager for an insurance company. Meanwhile in Long Beach, California, Deed’s ex-wife, Nellie Dappen Deeds, was living with their three children, Woodson (16 yrs.), Cecile (14 yrs.), and Maxwell (12 yrs.). They were living with Nellie’s sister, Ora Dappen, at 1363 Olive Ave. with their children. Nellie was employed in the dressmaking industry, working out of their home.
The Deeds went on the move again and headed south. At first, they first settled in Livermore, California. It doesn’t appear as if Deeds ever returned to painting after this point. He began to solely focus on sports. On April 6, 1927, the “Livermore Journal” reported, “Horseshoe Club Ranks Second in California, Only Long Beach has more members than Livermore Club. That the Livermore Horseshoe Club is the second largest organization of its kind in the state was the pleasing announcement of J. M. Deeds, organizer of the club here, yesterday.”
By 1930 the US Federal Census listed the Deeds family living at 703 North Street in Taft, California. For geographical context, Taft is about 280 miles south of Sacramento and due east of San Luis Obispo. In his early years, Deeds enjoyed fishing trips in San Luis Obispo. However, in Taft, Deeds was employed as a salesman with the automobile accessories industry. Nellie was now working as a music teacher. In regard to his ex-wife Nellie Dappen Deeds, she was now 48 yrs. old and on her own, working as a housekeeper for the Swan family. She lived with the Swans at 635 Euclid Avenue in San Bernardino, California. Little is known of Deed’s ex-wife after 1930, but she lived another eighteen years, passing away in Los Angeles on Oct. 8, 1958.
As with many, Deeds continued to pick up odd jobs throughout the Depression. He seems to have turned to education and was giving lessons in archery. On August 6, 1935, the “Oakland Tribune” announced, “Housewives Better Archers Than Mates.” The article continued, “Two-hour nightly classes in archery in five Oakland schools have disclosed that housewives prove to be better archers than their husbands, it was announced today by James M. Deeds, expert bowman and instructor of the classes being conducted by the Emergency Education Program. Approximately 475 adults have enrolled in the archery classes which are being conducted at the following schools: Chabot School, Monday: Peralta School, Wednesday: Fruitvale School, Thursday: Webster School, Tuesday, and Allendale School, Friday. All classes are conducted from 6 to 8 p.m. nightly” (page 13).
In 1938, California Voter Registration listed Deeds as a teacher, living at 5768 Vincente St. in Alameda, California. He continued to work with aspiring athletes in a variety of capacities for the next few years. In 1940, he was a sales manager in manufacture of bows and arrows (62) living in Oakland, California, living with Nellie (54) and his son James, now 20 yrs. old. The last information I have located for Deeds placed him in Oakland in 1941. That year, he was listed in the Oakland Directory, living with his son James at 803 57th. At the time, his son was employed a radio technician. He remained in the Oakland area until his passing nine years later.
On Sept. 29, 1950, Deeds passed away in Alameda, California. He is buried at the Golden Gate National Cemetery in San Bruno, San Mateo, California (Section N Site 2801). At the time of his passing he and Nellie were living at 2126-C 62nd Ave. in Oakland, California.
He shared a CNN link from Jan. 27, 2022, that reported, “A couple renovating a 115-year-old building discovered two 60-foot-long hidden murals.” Below the heading was a photograph of a lovely landscape painting above construction debris. The color palette and stencil reminded me of several backdrops that I had encountered over the years, and my first thought was, “A scenic artist painted that.”
CNN story posted on Jan. 27, 2022.
John was just the first of many friends who shared the link that day, and each time I thought, “Looks like fun, but nothing I can deal with right now.” I had already cancelled my trips to teach at Cobalt in February and attend USITT in March. Familial obligations were pressing, and I was trying to stick close to home this spring.
However, the story was intriguing. After serving in the military, a young couple had returned home to take care of dying parent. In the midst of grieving and settling the estate, they decided to put down roots in the town. They purchased and began the renovation of an old movie theater. It was to be a bar and restaurant; a gathering place for locals. Early in January of this year, they decided to break through a section of plaster, just to see what was behind the wall. No one could have anticipated that there would be a huge landscape mural; one of two. Despite punctures from furring strips and water damage from plaster oozing between strips of lathe, the paintings were in great shape.
The very next day I received a FB message from Lisa Timm. I opened it and read:
“Hi, Wendy! My husband and I recently uncovered a 60ft mural from 1915 and are hoping to conserve it. I was wondering if you could offer any advice or expertise as it looks like a theatre backdrop. There are videos and pictures on our Facebook group (mural restoration at the historic Timm building.” Thanks so much.”
I scheduled a time to chat with her about the murals.
In the meantime, I decided to do a little research on my own. I started with the simple query: “Where in the heck is Okanogan, Washington?” After opening a Maps app, I started to peruse nearby towns. Okanogan was due north of Chelan, Washington. At that moment, half of the main curtain from Chelan’s Ruby Theatre was laid out on my paint frame. I had just started the process of bidding out a replica.
Detail of main curtain from the Ruby Theatre in Chelan, Washington.
Although I was swamped with work and had no intention of traveling out of state for the next few months, I began to contemplate the feasibility of a very quick trip west. After realizing that the same scenic studio decorated both the Okanogan and Chelan theaters, I booked a flight. There were too many signs pointing me in the direction of Washington.
Over the course of the next two weeks, Lisa and Nick Timm sent detail pictures of the murals and we began a series of discussions about possible options. I was still hesitant to take on another project yet fielded their questions. I also did my best to educate them about the painting process and options for removal, storage, repair, and restoration. We even scheduled a WhatsApp video chat so they could walk me through the space, and I could clearly examine how the mural was attached to the wall. We were in luck as the mural was the last of three layers.
Three layers: cotton sheeting, wall paper and mural.Detail of where furring strip was tacked to mural.
Initially cotton sheeting was tacked to the wall with a thick wallpaper layer pasted on top. When the theatre was renovated in 1915, a second layer of cotton sheeting was tacked on top of the wallpaper and primed. This effectively glued the fabric to the wallpaper, creating a backing for the mural. The mural was only visible for three years before a plaster wall concealed it for a century.
The layers: plaster, mural, wallpaper and cotton sheeting.Area behind a chimney showing lathe, furring strips and mural. The chimney was removed prior to my arrival.Detail of painting.Detail of stencil.
In 1918 the venue changed hands, the building was renovated, and the theatre was renamed the Paramount. During the renovation, furring strips were tacked to the murals. Then lathe and plaster entombed the landscape paintings. In the dark they patiently waited for another renovation; one that would not happen until early January 2022.
The renovated Paramount Theatre, c. 1918.Remnants of the Paramount theater walls. Some remnants will remain in place.
I flew into Spokane and drove three hours west to Chelan where I stayed for the remainder of the trip. In Chelan I met explored the Ruby Theatre space and gave a community presentation about their theatre. When I ventured north to Okanogan, I was accompanied by Larry Hibbard, local architect and Ruby Theatre owner. I could not have asked for a better host. It is an absolutely beautiful area, home to miles and miles of fruit orchards. Their biggest export remains apples. Hibbard operated an apple orchard for decades.
Scene just south of Okanogan, Washington.Scenery near Okanogan, Washington.Scene on my drive from Spokane to Okanogan.
My plan was to only take pictures and leave with memories. This was not a project that I could drop everything else and take on in March. I was in the midst of several restoration projects, an opera design, and recognized that I was already overextended. Little did I know that everything was about to change.
The old Hub Theater in Okanogan is easy to miss. There is not a fly tower nor ornate façade to announce that it was once featured movies. The building looks more like an old hardware store than any temple of entertainment. If the Timms had not been standing outside, shouting and waving their hands, we would have missed it entirely.
The old theater is sandwiched between an automotive repair shop and a law firm in Okanogan.
Upon entering the building my heart sank and I knew that there was very little time to save these murals. The relentless drip of water accentuated the dampness of the space. The drips both hit and missed a series of buckets lined up on the floor between the two murals. In previous conversations, the Timms had mentioned their concern of snow melt and a leaking roof. I had no idea it was this bad. I knew that it was just a matter of weeks before the murals would be entirely destroyed. That was when I began to game plan about their immediate removal. There would be plenty of time to plan the conservation of each painting, but there was minimal time to remove the murals from a leaking building.
Water leaking from the roof from rain and snow melt.
I could not extend my stay but could return within the week. In the meantime, the space needed to be cleared, prepped and necessary supplies ordered.
The first mural came down in two hours, the second in less than an hour. Nick, Lisa and their crew of four helped stabilize the painting as I separated the wallpaper from the first layer of cotton sheeting.
One of the two murals prior to removal.I inched along behind the mural to loosen the layer of wallpaper from the original cotton sheeting tacked to the wall.
I am breathing a bit easier today, and happy to report that both murals have been successfully removed from the walls. In the end, the thick wallpaper backing helped support the long artworks throughout the process. Each mural will be transferred to a climate-controlled storage room until I am able to restore them.
After the first mural was down and prior to rolling.
These murals come with their own artistic provenance and shed a little light on American Theatre in the Pacific Northwest. J. M. Deeds Scenic Studio, of Spokane, secured the contract to paint the murals in 1915. By this time his firm had already decorated Chelan’s Ruby Theatre and the Wenatchee Theatre, located south of Chelan. I’ll share the story of J. M. Deeds tomorrow.
Map showing the location of Okanogan, Chelan and Wenatchee, Washington.