Travels of a Scenic Artist and Scholar: The Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre Scenery Collection

Copyright © 2020 by Wendy Rae Waszut-Barrett

Backdrop delivered by Toomey & Volland scenic studio of St. Louis, Missouri, to the Scottish Rite Theatre in Richmond, Virginia. Last month I visited the Richmond Scottish Rite and documented the historic scenery collection, dating from 1900-1920.

Backdrop by Toomey & Volland Studio of St. Louis, ca. 1920.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland Studio of St. Louis, ca. 1920.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland Studio of St. Louis, ca. 1920.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland Studio of St. Louis, ca. 1920.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland Studio of St. Louis, ca. 1920.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland Studio of St. Louis, ca. 1920.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland Studio of St. Louis, ca. 1920.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland Studio of St. Louis, ca. 1920.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland Studio of St. Louis, ca. 1920.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland Studio of St. Louis, ca. 1920.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland Studio of St. Louis, ca. 1920.

Travels of a Scenic Artist and Scholar: The Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre Scenery Collection

Copyright © 2020 by Wendy Rae Waszut-Barrett

Backdrop delivered by Toomey & Volland scenic studio of St. Louis, Missouri. Last month I visited the Richmond Scottish Rite and documented the historic scenery collection, dating from 1900-1920.

Here is a link to my past post:

https://drypigment.net2020/10/26/travels-of-a-scenic-artist-and-scholar-the-richmond-scottish-rite-october-24-26-2020

Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri, for the Scottish Rite Theatre in Richmond, Virginia.
Painted detail. Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.
Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.
Painted detail. Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.
Painted detail. Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.
Painted detail. Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.
Painted detail. Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.
Painted detail. Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.
Painted detail. Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.
Painted detail. Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.
Painted detail. Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.
Painted detail. Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.
Painted detail. Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.
Painted detail. Scenery by Toomey & Volland of St. Louis, Missouri.

Travels of a Scenic Artist and Scholar: The Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre Scenery Collection

Copyright © 2020 by Wendy Rae Waszut-Barrett

Backdrop delivered by Toomey & Volland scenic studio of St. Louis, Missouri. Last month I visited the Richmond Scottish Rite and documented the historic scenery collection, dating from 1900-1920. Here is a link to my past post:

https://drypigment.net2020/10/26/travels-of-a-scenic-artist-and-scholar-the-richmond-scottish-rite-october-24-26-2020/?fbclid=IwAR0ndD1AoWzv4oixFC293ANHLryNf1lp6aQzBRlTDwlwIpZ4kyE9ZspQZsQ

Scene painted at Toomey & Volland Studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland Studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland Studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland Studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland Studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland Studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland Studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland Studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland Studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland Studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite

Travels of a Scenic Artist and Scholar: The Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre Scenery Collection

Copyright © 2020 Wendy Rae Waszut-Barrett

Scene designed and painted by Toomey & Volland scenic studio of St. Louis, Missouri, for the Richmond Scottish Rite.

Toomey & Volland scenic studio.
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland scenic studio.
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland scenic studio.
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland scenic studio.
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland scenic studio.
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland scenic studio.
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland scenic studio.
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland scenic studio.
Painted detail. Toomey & Volland scenic studio.
Toomey & Volland scenic studio.
Toomey & Volland scenic studio.

Travels of a Scenic Artist and Scholar: The Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre Scenery Collection

Copyright © 2020 by Wendy Rae Waszut-Barrett

Here is a backdrop designed and painted by Toomey & Volland scenic studio of St. Louis, Missouri, ca. 1920. Last month I visited the Richmond Scottish Rite and documented the historic scenery collection, dating from 1900-1920.

Landscape drop by Toomey & Volland scenic studio of St. Louis, Missouri
Landscape drop by Toomey & Volland on the stage of the Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre

Here is a link to my past post about my visit to the Richmond Scottish Rite this fall:

https://drypigment.net2020/10/26/travels-of-a-scenic-artist-and-scholar-the-richmond-scottish-rite-october-24-26-2020/?fbclid=IwAR18iqXfhc-REFMElYe3BBn-4ZXygKuig9zr9Chw8YVg-xG3pUcZIqT-wgg
Scenery by Toomey & Volland for the Richmond Scottish Rite
Painted detail. Landscape drop by Toomey & Volland
Painted detail. Landscape drop by Toomey & Volland
Painted detail. Landscape drop by Toomey & Volland
Painted detail. Landscape drop by Toomey & Volland
Painted detail. Landscape drop by Toomey & Volland
Painted detail. Landscape drop by Toomey & Volland
Painted detail. Landscape drop by Toomey & Volland
Painted detail. Landscape drop by Toomey & Volland
Painted detail. Landscape drop by Toomey & Volland
Painted detail. Landscape drop by Toomey & Volland

Richard Finkelstein also made a lovely video of this scene with changing light:

Travels of a Scenic Artist and Scholar: The Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre Scenery Collection

Copyright © 2020 by Wendy Rae Waszut-Barrett

Here is a backdrop designed and painted by Toomey & Volland scenic studio of St. Louis, Missouri, ca. 1920. Last month I visited the Richmond Scottish Rite and documented the historic scenery collection, dating from 1900-1920. Here is a link to my past post:

https://drypigment.net2020/10/26/travels-of-a-scenic-artist-and-scholar-the-richmond-scottish-rite-october-24-26-2020/?fbclid=IwAR37c4KGBw4bIkkiH4i6RlHqreCLW9xxqMbPi_ElzIWZtJLDPe4lbLmV2VQ

Backdrop by Toomey & Volland for the Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland for the Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland for the Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland for the Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland for the Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland for the Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland for the Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland for the Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre.
Painted detail. Backdrop by Toomey & Volland for the Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre.

Travels of a Scenic Artist and Scholar: The Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre Scenery Collection

Copyright © 2020 by Wendy Waszut-Barrett

A cathedral setting designed and painted by Toomey & Volland scenic studio of St. Louis, Missouri, ca. 1920. Last month I visited the Richmond Scottish Rite and documented the historic scenery collection, dating from 1900-1920. Here is a link to my past post:

https://drypigment.net2020/10/26/travels-of-a-scenic-artist-and-scholar-the-richmond-scottish-rite-october-24-26-2020/?fbclid=IwAR2euDAn-lNGbjUPAVvzvZ7yEglrG3bHNxfGfG6RgSJpPONqolDtSNaB42o

While on site, I was assisted by Michael Powers and Richard Finkelstein to set and light each scene during the cataloguing process. Here are a few images that I took of the scene:

Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Translucent sections. Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Translucent section. Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Translucent section. Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Note the charcoal drawing beneath the paint. Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920
Cathedral scene by Toomey & Volland scenic studio for the Richmond Scottish Rite, c. 1920

Travels of a Scenic Artist and Scholar – The Richmond Scottish Rite, October 24-26, 2020

Copyright © 2020 by Wendy Waszut-Barrett

It has been a busy month, and I am currently in Richmond, Virginia. The Richmond Scottish Rite Theatre appeared on my radar again last month. The timing was less than ideal, since I was packing to leave for the Tabor Opera House in Leadville, Colorado. On September 17, I received word from Art DeHoyos that the Richmond Scottish Rite was selling their building and had no plans for the historic scenery collection. I immediately contacted Rex Hutchens, as a few years ago we tried to purchase the Winona Masonic scenery collection in an online auction.

In regard to the Richmond Scottish Rite, I was well aware of the potential sale, just not the timeline. Immediately after receiving the information from Art, I was on the phone with Rex, asking if he was still interested in acquiring a collection. After chatting briefly with him about the compositions, I contacted the Scottish Rite Secretary in Richmond to get more details, leaving a message. When I headed west to Colorado on the morning of September 19, I had little hope that I would ever see the Richmond scenery, or that it would find a new Scottish Rite home.
I did not think about the Richmond Scottish Rite again until Rex called last Sunday, October 18. By Thursday, October 22, I was on the road again. The plan was to arrive in Richmond the next day; it was an eighteen-hour drive. I would catalogue the collection over the weekend, from 8AM-6PM each day, and depart on Monday. I needed to determine the scope of the collection and whether the drops would withstand the move. If everything checked out, I would come up with a transportation plan based on the impending sale of the building. Fortunately for me, I had slide collections from both Larry Hill and Lance Brockman, taken when they documented the drops a few decades ago. Prior to my departure I created a drop inventory based on the slides.

One of the slide images by Lance Brockman.

In addition to the slides, I knew that Toomey & Volland sold scenery to the Richmond Scottish Rite in 1920. From 1920 to 1921 the Richmond Scottish Rite enlarged their existing building and renovated the stage area. This meant that the Richmond Scottish Rite either acquired a new collection from Toomey & Volland or purchased additional settings for their existing collection. Regardless of what was purchased in 1920, the entire scenery collection was moved to a new building by 1968.
The move meant that the collection was possibly reduced at this time. In the case of the St. Paul Scottish Rite, their move to a new building meant that the collection shrunk in size by one-third. For example, if a setting consisted of a leg drop, cut drop and backdrop, either the leg drops or cut drops were removed, effectively reducing the number of line sets required in the new space. This same thing may have happened in Richmond; meaning that the excess scenery was thrown out during the move, or it was tucked away somewhere in the building.Within ten minutes of arriving at the Richmond Scottish Rite, I had answers to many of my questions. There were only 49 lines hanging in the air, and most of the original sandwich battens had been removed; replaced with jute webbing at the top and pipe pockets at the bottom. Heaving a sigh of relief, I contacted Rex and explained the situation. Over the course of the day I shared photos with him and began to plan for the future move.

Scenery by Toomey & Volland for the Scottish Rite Theatre in Richmond, Virginia.
Scenery by Toomey & Volland for the Scottish Rite Theatre in Richmond, Virginia.
Scenery by Toomey & Volland for the Scottish Rite Theatre in Richmond, Virginia.
Scenery by Toomey & Volland for the Scottish Rite Theatre in Richmond, Virginia.
Scenery by Toomey & Volland for the Scottish Rite Theatre in Richmond, Virginia.


Because of the limited number of drops, there was more time to play with lighting while documenting each scene. All was fun and games until the Secretary mentioned that there were about four drops tucked away above the stage left storage area. No problem. I was ahead of schedule and would have ample time on Sunday afternoon to unroll the drops, as well as fully documenting the unique rigging system. When I arrived at 8AM on Sunday morning, I asked to see where the four rolled drops were stored…

…and this is when everything changed.


There were many, many more drops stored above the properties room, stage left. Unfortunately, they were beneath a dozen lighting instruments, chairs, and storage racks. This was not a simple hand-them-down-and-unroll-them project. In a glance, I knew that this would tack on an extra day, and it would be dirty work. Now cataloguing a collection of hanging scenery is an entirely different task than lowering and unrolling drops that have been compressed for a few decades. First of all, there is a dirt factor. Within minutes of handling rolled drops that are a century old, your clothes, hair, neck, face and hands are covered in black soot. The drops require gentle handling or clouds of dust float everywhere. Needless to say, I was not appropriately dressed for the task at hand, nor was the crew.
This project required many hands, and there were five of us: Michael Powers, Richard Finkelstein, Bridgette Dennett and Sarah Phillips. Bridgette and I handed down the drops to Sarah (on ladder), then Michael and Richard. After a few drops, I realized that we needed a sixth person, so I tracked down Paul, our Scottish Rite host that morning. Thank goodness he was willing to help. The addition of Paul meant that Sarah was able to stay on the ladder, while Paul, Michael and Richard placed drops on the stage floor. Slowly, and carefully, the drops were placed from the upstage wall to mid-stage; twenty-five in all.

Rolls of scenery by Toomey & Volland for the Scottish Rite Theatre in Richmond, Virginia.
One of the drops that was stored above the properties room at the Richmond Scottish Rite.
One of the drops that was stored above the properties room at the Richmond Scottish Rite.

Meanwhile…

The stage lights had also malfunctioned, so while Michael was dealing with that issue, Bridgette, Sarah and I unrolled each scene. Richard photographed each piece from the top of a ladder, as he able to adjust the skewed perspective. While he was doing that, I climbed halfway up the ladder to photograph entire composition, then took detail images from the floor, catalogued the scenes, and labeled each drop for transport. Several top battens were broken, which meant it was not an easy unroll and re-roll task. However, we finished the project by 6PM.

Tomorrow, Richard, Michael and I will finish documenting the remaining scenes that are still hanging. Michael and I depart on Tuesday for the two-day drive home. It has been a challenging, but delightful time, as we have had the opportunity to photograph the settings under various lighting conditions. I will return to my blog “Tales of a Scenic Artist and Scholar” next week.


To be continued…

Travels of a Scenic Artists and Scholar: Thalian Hall’s Scenery Collections

Thalian Hall at night.

For over a week, I have focused on the scenery produced for the Thalian Hall in Wilmington, North Carolina. Dozens of scenes were delivered from 1858 until 1909. This history is similar to thousands of other nineteenth century theaters across the United States, not accounting those that were lost to fire. Scenery was repeatedly delivered to entertainment venues in the 19th century as managers sought various ways to attract the public, drawing audiences in with painted scenes. Then, as now, the audience expected to see something new and exciting. Here is a brief recap of the scenery delivered to the Thalian Hall from 1858-1909.

Russell Smith painted the original drop curtain and first set of stock scenery in 1858. By 1871, Smith’s original scenery was touched up by local artists.

The original 1858 Russell Smith curtain.

A decade later, in 1881, new scenery by Wilmington artist Ernest V. Richards was purchased at an expense of $247.00. Little is known of Richards beyond a few advertisements that he placed in Wilmington newspapers. Richards’ ran a “scene, fresco and sign studio” located on the “corner of Front and Princess streets (up stairs)” in Wilmington (Wilmington Morning Star, 21 Nov. 1888. Page 1). His newspaper advertisement noted, “All commissions in Art Work promptly attended to. Special designs in Christmas Cards and Advertising novelties.” By 1889, Richards expanded his service to include “Stained and Leaded Glass,” providing estimates and designs for church and house windows, with “matching and repairing a specialty” (The Wilmington Messenger, July 24, 1889, page 5).

In 1895, E. V. Richards again touched up the drop curtain and scenery at an expense of $53.80. This would be his last project for the theater, as William F. Hamilton was selected as a scenic artist to design and paint new scenery for the stage. In 1896, W. F. Hamilton converted the original painted curtain by Russell Smith from a roll drop into a fly drop. He also painted a new drop curtain and four new sets of scenery for the theater. In addition to working as a scenic artist, records indicate that Hamilton “completed a few other necessary improvements.” Transforming a roll drop into a fly drop suggests that a fly loft was added. Hamilton returned in 1899 to paint another drop curtain for the opera house.

On August 28, 1904, “Wilmington Morning Star” the stage was enlarged ten feet and scenery was again added to the stock. Records indicate that new scenery was delivered by C. N. Garing of Garing Scenic Studio painted new scenery. Garing was a lesser-known scenic artist who worked throughout the Carolinas. On September 5, 1905, the “Wilmington Morning Star” reported that new scenery was painted for the venue and “many new appointments added.” Little is known of Garing, by in 1907, he was living in Atlanta, Georgia (The Alamance Gleaner, 11 July 1907). That year, he was awarded the contract to paint stage scenery for the new opera house in Graham, North Carolina. As a side note, Garing’s brother was the well-known musical director A. J. Garing who worked at the New York Hippodrome (1918).

In 1909 after the renovation, all of the old scenery on stage was replaced with all new versions from New York. On August 5, 1909, the “Morning Star” reported “Yesterday a special scenic artist from New York city arrived and is now at work planning the full equipment of new scenery for the theatre, including a handsome drop-curtain, and will also map out the pretty interior decorations…the electric equipment of the theatre is also to be the most elaborate…The scenic artist will also direct the work of the interior decoration for the theatre, and is one of the best men in the business, representing a well-known northern studio.”

On August 20, 1909, the “Morning Star” included, “The painting of the scenery is fast progressing at the theatre, and today a handsome front curtain reached the city from the north, through there will also be a fine painted one here, this giving the theatre two curtains.”

When considering the amount of scenery delivered between 1858 and 1909, it is shocking to see that only two pieces remain – the original drop curtain and a book flat. However, looking at historic venues nationwide, this is a significant find. Many nineteenth century theaters have no painted remnants from their past, especially something that was delivered when the venue opened. Tomorrow will be my last post on the Thalian Hall and I will look at the last restoration of the 1858 drop curtain. Over 150 years, this curtain was “touched up” and “repaired” numerous times, each with the original paint. The most recent repair to patched and water-damaged areas incorporated the use of oil pastels.

To be continued…

Travels of a Scenic Artists and Scholar: William F. Hamilton and New York Studios in Wilmington, North Carolina

Nineteenth century scenic artists relied on satisfied clients; this not only helped secure future contracts but also guaranteed repeat customers. William F. Hamilton created scenery for the opera house in Wilmington, North Carolina, during 1896 and 1899. He was linked to the 1909 production of scenery too.

On August 25, 1896, the “Wilmington Morning Star” included the following announcement on the first page:

“Improvements at the Opera House.

“Mr. W. F. Hamilton, scenic artist and stage manager of the Standard Theatre, New York city and his assistant arrive in the city to-day to paint things in general in the Opera House. The present roll-curtain will be converted into a drop curtain, and a new drop curtain will be added. Four new sets of scenery will be painted and other necessary improvements in this line will be made. The theatrical season of 1896-97 promises to be the most successful for many years. The house will open with ‘Jim, the Penman,’ on the 7th of next moth.”

A few years later, Hamilton returned and the “Wilmington Morning Star,” reported “Mr. S. A. Schloss informed a representative yesterday that he had just closed a contract for a new drop curtain for the opera house, to be painted by Mr. W. F. Hamilton, the celebrated scenic artist of the Star Theatre, New York City. Mr. Hamilton was in Wilmington about two years ago and most of the finest scenes now at the Opera House were painted by him” (10 Oc. 1899, page 1).

And then there was his connection with another installation. The opera house underwent a significant renovation in 1909, with the installation of the current proscenium arch, measuring 32’ by 26.’  The work was completed under the direction of commercial lessee S.A. Schloss. In a local newspaper article Schloss explained that he was planning to restore and rehang the original drop curtain.

When I visited Thalian Hall this spring, Tony Rivenbark shared another piece of scenery found tucked away at the theater that looked to date from the early twentieth century. Sitting at the top of a backstage landing was an old book flat. It depicted a wood scene and was intended a masking, or a wing, for the side stage.

The New York Studios stencil on the Thanlian Hall flat in Wilmington, North Carolina, ca. 1910.

A painted detail from the New York Studios flat.

Backside of the New York Studios flat at the Thalian Hall in Wilmington, North Carolina.

Backside of the New York Studios flat at the Thalian Hall in Wilmington, North Carolina.

The New York Studios flat at the Thalian Hall in Wilmington, North Carolina.

The New York Studios flat at the Thalian Hall in Wilmington, North Carolina.

Amazingly, there was a studio stencil on the back of the flat, New York Studios. New York Studios was the eastern affiliate of Sosman & Landis of Chicago, started by David Hunt during the first decade of the twentieth century. In 1910, newspapers verified their increased presence in New York, describing scenery produced by “the well known New York and Chicago artists, Sosman & Landis” (The Times, Streator, Illinois, 14 Sept. 1910, page 5). New York Studios was incorporated on April 8, 1910, and lasted until its dissolution on Dec. 15, 1939.

An ad for The New York Studios from 1927.

In 1904, Joseph Sosman and David H. Hunt convinced Thomas G. Moses to return to Sosman & Landis in Chicago, effectively ending his partnership with Hamilton. Moses fostered many theatre connections along the eastern seaboard after establishing Moses & Hamilton. The success of the from 1900-1904 proved an asset to Sosman & Landis upon his return.

The New York Studios stockholders in 1910 included David H. Hunt, Adelaide Hunt, Edward Morange, Henry L. Rupert, and W. E. Castle. Like many firms, they operated under the name prior to incorporating.

Hamilton continued to work for New York Studios until he permanently moving to San Francisco to focus on Shrine Circus scenery and other large spectacles during the early 1920s. A “Variety” article from November 9, 1921 noted Hamilton’s continued connection to New York Studios that year, while also working for local firms. Under the heading “Hamilton’s Special Events,” the article commented, “W. F. Hamilton, formerly of the New York Scene Painting Studio, came to San Francisco to prepare the scenic equipment of the recent Shrine Circus.” In San Francisco, Hamilton also found work at Flagg Studios.

To be continued…