While looking for images of F. W. Heine, I came across the July 22, 1886, issue of “Bad Lands Cow Boy.” The article described the “Battle of Atlanta” cyclorama that was on exhibit in Minneapolis, Minnesota. I was fascinated with the history of my hometown, so I took a little time to read the entire article. Near the end of it, the author highlighted William Wehner and the American Panorama Company artists. It described how Wehner visited all of the panoramas of importance in Europe and then selected “a staff of the most competent war painters to be found in that country.” The leaders of his exceptional painting team were foreign professors F. W. Heine and August Lohr, “whose previous accomplishments entitled them to be entrusted with the great task which had been laid out.” Heine and Lohr’s artistic staff included “eighteen of the best war painters of Europe, largely from Munich, Dresden and Vienna.” There were artists specializing in landscapes, portraits, figures, and horses. They left their homes to come work in Milwaukee. Most never returned. The fact that the paint staff of the American Panorama Company was mainly composed of foreign artists could not have gone unnoticed, especially by scenic artists in Chicago.
I think scenic artists from all over the country watched, waited, and then acted out against their new competitors. Wehner’s artists arrived in Milwaukee on May 13, 1885. Five months later there was a Scene Painter’s Show in Chicago highlighting American scenic artists. On October 12, 1885, there was the first exhibition of Water Colors by American scenic artists from all over the country. It stands to reasons think that they were defending their turf against this perceived onslaught of immigrant labor. There would never be another Scene Painter’s Show of that generation’s work.
John Moran supported their cause when he submitted an article about the Scene Painter’s Show for the “Art Union, a Monthly Magazine of Art” (Vol. 2, No. 4, 1885, p. 85). The American Art Union was “a society of American Artists, including representations of all the different schools of art” that was “organized ‘for the general advancement of the Fine Arts, and for promoting and facilitating a greater knowledge and love thereof on the part of the public.” The 1884-1885 Board of Directors included D. Hentington (Pres), T. W. Wood (Vice President), E. Wood Perry, Jr. (Secy.), Frederick Dielman (Treasurer), W. H. Beard, Albert Bierstadt, Harry Chase, Harry Farrer, Eastman Johnson, Jervis McEntee, Thomas Moran, and Walter Shirlaw.
In a previous post about the Scene Painter’s Show I included Moran’s entire article. I am going to include it again as it can be read now with a much different perspective:
“The Scene Painters’ Show. Chicago, October 12th, 1885
The first Exhibition of Water Colors by American Scenic Artists has been open free to the public for some weeks past, in this city, and the eighty-four examples hung on the walls of Messrs. Louderback & Co.’s galleries include some praiseworthy and valuable works. Such a collection proves that the broad pictorial treatment requisite for adequate stage effect does not incapacitate a man for the finer and more delicate manipulation essential to good aquarelles, and shows, moreover, a healthy progressive spirit among scenic artists. The name of Matt Morgan has long been gratefully familiar to us, and he is represented by diverse and facile contributions. “Alone in the Forest Shade” (1), shows lumbermen with their load descending a wild ravine flanked on either side by towering pines. The feeling of solitude and gloom is forcibly conveyed and the tree forms and foliage broadly yet carefully handled. “The Lost Comrade” (27), and “Waiting for Death” (14), are strong and weird aspects of prairies life, the former representing a horseman, lasso in hand, who has come upon the skeletons of a horse and rider among the pampas grass, and the latter a bull calf standing over the moribund body of a cow, striving with futile bellow to keep advancing wolves at bay. A nude figure, “The New Slave” (71), standing expectantly against a rich low-toned drapery, is exquisite in drawing and color and charmingly beautiful in suggestion. Mr. Walter Burridge runs the gamut of landscape figure and decoration and is good in all! His “Spring” (9), “Autumn Leaves” (39), and “Old Mill” (49), are deftly washed-in landscapes, true to nature and aerial in quality, while “My Assistant” (16), a study of behind the scenes life, and a “Ninety Minute Sketch” (83), of his friend Mr. Ernest Albert, show character and a nice sense of texture. Mr. Ernest Albert’s “Winter Twilight” (12), is full of sentiment of the season and excellent in composition, and his “October Morning” (31), “moonrise” (40), “Sunset” (79), and “Autumn” (80), are severally individual as transcripts and prove his mastery over the vehicle he uses. “A Decorative Flower Piece” (84), by the same artist, groups of roses, pansies and forget-me-nots in a most artistic and harmonious manner. “Nobody’s Claim, Col.” (65) and “Near Racine, Wis.” (76) By Mr. Thomas G. Moses, are among his best examples and are freely treated and with fidelity to locale character and sky effects. Mr. Albert Operti gives us some reminiscences of his Lapland tour in 1884, which are realistic and worthy, and Mr. J. Hendricks Young, “A Busy Day on Chicago River” (38), which together with the local bits by Mr. Moses, Mr. C. E. Petford and Mr. Burridge, is of historical value as it is skillfully painted. “Rats, you Terrier” (59), by the same hand, is a “snappy” and bright treatment of a dog’s head and fully catches the spirit of the English. Mr. Henry C. Tryon’s “Source of the Au Sable” (34), powerfully conveys a sense of somberness and grandeur, and though ample in detail loses nothing of the vastness and breadth, which such a landscape motion calls for. Other works deserving of notice are Messrs. George Dayton, Sr., George Dayton, Jr., the late L. Malmsha, C. Boettger, Chas. Ritter, H. Buhler and John Howell Wilson, whose “Country Road” (76” is especially fresh, verdurous and bright. It is to be hoped that this is only the forerunner of many like exhibitions and it marks a decided growth in the national art spirit.”
On June 29, 2017, (installment #131) I wrote, “This wasn’t just a group of artists linked by a common style or profession – this was statement made by a closely-knit community of passionate individuals. They shared their work, their lives and their passion for painting.” Now I understand that this could have been more than a mere statement; it was creating a united front to battle a potential threat to their future livelihood. Not until this moment had I considered that the Scene Painter’s Show of 1885 was a calculated response to the arrival on twenty foreign scenic artists who worked for the American Panorama Company, having only arrived a mere five months earlier. I honestly don’t know if any other scenic studio in the United States could rival the size of the American Panorama Company’s staff in 1885; certainly not the Sosman & Landis studio.
To provide a little more context for this event, it was also the same year that Moses left the Sosman & Landis Studio to form a partnership called “Burridge, Moses & Louderback.” J. D. Louderback was the Chicago art dealer who hosted the Scene Painter’s Show. Walter Burridge had extensive experience painting panoramas that included work with Phil Goatcher on “Siege of Paris” (1876 Philadelphia Centennial World Fair) and a “Battle of Gettysburg” panorama. He understood cycloramas and would soon design and paint the “Volcano of Kilauea,” a monumental success at the 1893 Columbian Exposition.
Two groups of artists: one crossing the Atlantic to paint scenery, the other showing what America already had to offer.
To be continued…
