At the same time the American Panorama Company was opening their studio in Milwaukee, Sosman & Landis were building another scenic studio in Chicago on Clinton Street. Early in 1886, the Sosman & Landis artists moved into the space. There, Thomas G. Moses and David A. Strong would complete their first project – a panorama of General Grant’s Trip Around the World (see installment # 215). Strong was much older and considered part of the Dusseldorf School of painting (see installments #127-128). This would be Sosman & Landis’ main studio for four decades. In 1886, Thomas G. Moses, Edward Loitz, Henry C. Tryon, John H. Young, Hardesty Maratta, Ed Morange and were all part of the paint staff. Charles S. King was the Soman & Landis stage machinist while C. D. Baker was their electrical engineer. Wehner’s panorama staff included at least twenty people in 1885, with the majority being new immigrants.
I want to stop and take a quick glance at the talent employed by William Wehner for his American Panorama Company as well as some other Milwaukee Panorama artists from that same time. Milwaukee panorama painters were quite a diverse community. Although not all were foreign, many hailed from distant lands and few would return to their homeland after the projects ended.
Immigrants still bring various skills and assets to our country that help it continue to grow and evolve. That was as true in the nineteenth century as it is now. The Milwaukee panorama artists contributed their talents as our country expanded from coast to coast. Foreign artists became part of the fabric that shaped American art and entertainment.
Below is a list of the Milwaukee panorama artists listed at the Museum of Wisconsin Art (MOWA) website. These are names that I have compiled and go beyond the tidy little bundle of “panorama artists” placed in MOWA’s panorama category. In some cases, MOWA gives a brief biography for the artists and in other cases nothing is known beyond a name. Some are not even listed as a panorama painters, yet they were pictured as working in the American Panorama Company in 1880s pictures. It would take some exhaustive research to compile more that this simple list below and I am well into Gene Meier’s territory at this point.
Below, I have included the panorama artists place of birth, place of death. To see the names together with a brief snap shot of their origins highlights the diversity of the group and validates why the United States has often been referred to as the great melting pot. It has always been an asset to our country.
There is a lot to comment on, but what surprised me the most of all was the mention of women, specifically Amy Cross, Amy Boos (Tesch), Mary Grover and Eileen Henrietta Collins. This is a significant dent in the workforce and more than just the lone wife of daughter helping out. They are not the only women scenic artists that I have been noting and tucking away in a separate document. There will be a post in the very near future about females in this predominantly male world. Also, keep in mind as you read the list of panorama artists below that Thomas G. Moses (1856-1934) grew up in Sterling, Illinois and worked from 1873-1934.
There is much more information pertaining to each individual artist, but it is important to see them as a whole and imagine their role in various panorama projects. I have also attached images of art by some of the above mentioned artists. Most were pulled from art auction websites and listed as “sold.” However, it is really quite something to look at their work as a whole and think about all of that talent working in one building. This goes far beyond an artist or two painting a Masonic drop. Each artist brought something unique to the project.
Friedrich Wilhelm Heine (1845-1921) from Leipzig, Germany and died in Milwaukee http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/friedrich-wilhelm-heine/profile-65.aspx
Otto Dinger (1860-?) Born in Dusseldorf, Germany. Death location is unknown. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/otto-dinger/profile-954.aspx
Paul Wilhelmi (1858-1942) Born in Dusseldorf, Germany and died in Detroit, Michigan. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/paul-wilhelmi/profile-3528.aspx
Wilhelm Schröter (1849-1904) from Dessau, Germany, and died in Karlsruhe, Germany http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/wilhelm-schroeter/profile-147.aspx
Louis Kindt (1832-1923) Born in Baden, Germany and died in Chicago, Illinois. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/louis-kindt/profile-1809.aspx
Gustav Wendling (1862-1932) Born in Buddenstedt, Germany. Location of death unknown. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/gustav-wendling/profile-3483.aspx
Bernhard Schneider (1843-1907) Born in Lüneburg, Germany and died in Cedarburg,Wisconsin. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/bernhard-schneider/profile-146.aspx
Karl Hubert Frosch (1846-1931) from Altshausen, Wurttemburg, Germany, and died in Munich, Germany http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/karl-hubert-frosch/profile-1200.aspx
Otto Wilhelm Joseph von Ernst (1853-1925) from Dusseldorf, Germany, with no death location. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/otto-wilhelm-joseph-von-ernst/profile-1076.aspx
Herman Heinrich Albert von Michalowski (1860-1903) from Berlin, Germany and died in Chicago. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/herman-heinrich-albert-von-michalowski/profile-2349.aspx
Conrad W. Heyd (1839-1912) from Bavaria, Germany and died in Milwaukee. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/conrad-w-heyd/profile-68.aspx
Richard Lorenz (1858-1915) Born in Voigtstedt, Germany and died in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/richard-lorenz/profile-96.aspx
Albert B. Richter (1845-1898) Born in Germany, but no location of death information. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/albert-b-richter/profile-2789.aspx
John C. Fery (1859-1934) from Strasswalchen, Austria, and died in Everett, Washington. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/john-c-fery/profile-45.aspx
August Lohr (1842-1920) Born at Hallein near Salzburg, Austria. Death location is unknown, but Mexico is suggested. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/august-lohr/profile-95.aspx
Theodor Breidwiser (1847-1930) Born in Vienna, Austria and died in Vienna, Austria. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/theodor-breidwiser/profile-625.aspx
George Peter (1859-1950) from Vienna, Austria, and died in Milwaukee. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/george-peter/profile-122.aspx
Pierre Joseph Brouchoud (1815-1892) from Le Chable, Switzerland, and died in Mischicot, Wisconsin. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/pierre-joseph-brouchoud/profile-7735.aspx
Franz Biberstein (1850-1913) from Solothurn, Switzerland and died in Milwaukee. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/franz-biberstein/profile-18.aspx
Gustave Higgins (1863-1909) from Sweden and no death location. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/gustave-higgins/profile-7698.aspx
Harold Hall (1865-1932) from Oslo, Norway and died in Seattle, Washington. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/harold-hall/profile-59.aspx
James R. O’Neill (1833-?) from Ireland with no death location. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/james-r-oneill/profile-3636.aspx
Franz Edward Rohrbeck (1852-1919) from Saxony, Prussia and died in Milwaukee. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/franz-edward-rohrbeck/profile-138.aspx
Thaddeus von Zukotynski (1855-1912) Podolia, Russia (Russian Territory) and died in Chicago. His name was also spelled Tadeusz Zukotynski. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/thaddeus-von-zukotynski/profile-3618.aspx
Edward R. Tyrrell (no dates) from Melbourne, Australia and no death information. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/edward-r-tyrrell/profile-3308.aspx
Robert Schade (1861-1912) from Tarrytown, New York, and died in Milwaukee. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/robert-schade/profile-141.aspx
Theodore Russell Davis (1840-1894) from Boston, Massachusetts and died in Ashbury Park, New Jersey. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/theodore-russell-davis/profile-902.aspx
John Franklin Waldo (1835-1920) from Chelsea, Vermont, and died in Los Angeles, California. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/john-franklin-waldo/profile-181.aspx
Thomas Gardner (1857-1933) from Plano, Illinois and died in Milwaukee. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/thomas-gardner/profile-1226.aspx
Amy Cross (1856-1939) from Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and died in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/amy-cross/profile-867.aspx,
Frank Enders (1860-1921) from Milwaukee, Wisconsin, and died in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/frank-enders/profile-41.aspx,
Amy Boos (1851-1935) from Milwaukee, Wisconsin and died in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/amy-boos/profile-577.aspx
Andrew Alexander Forbes (1862-1921) from Waukesha, Wisconsin and died in Lampoc, California. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/andrew-alexander-forbes/profile-5746.aspx
William Feld (no dates, birth or death information). http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/william-feld/profile-7699.aspx
Feodor von Luerzer (1851-1913) no birth or death information. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/feodor-von-luerzer/profile-2186.aspx
Charles Clayton Minor (1856-?). There is no birth or death information about Minor, but he also worked with Thomas G. Moses. http://www.wisconsinart.org/archives/artist/charles-clayton-minor/profile-6091.aspx)
There are other panorama artists mentioned in MOWA, but without any pertinent information, and include, Johannes Schulz, Julius Ernst Peege, Mary Grover, Robert F. Gilder, Mrs. C. H. Eileen Henrietta Collins, Josephus Farmer, and Edward J. Herman.
To be continued…
Joseph Pierre Birren panorama diary
May 16,1882
First began art study with C.C.Minor at 70 Monroe Street, Chicago//JPB was an panorama artist for Reed & Gross of Chicago/Englewood 1885-88, and went to Australia with Reed & Gross to set up and maintain 1 rotunda in Adelaide,1 rotunda in Sydney and 2 rotundas in Melbourne. I have been in contact with his granddaughter; I have a xerox copy of his round-the-world diary
Paul Wilhelmi originally painted panoramas for Heine and Lohr, but he subsequently went to Chicago to paint panoramas for Reed & Gross of Chicago/Englewood. Wilhelmi went to Australia with the Reed & Gross studio where they erected and maintained rotunda panoramas; Sydney had 1 rotunda, Adelaide had 2 rotunda and Melbourne had 2 rotundas
Michaelowski removed to Chicago and resided at the Lambert Tree Studios in the 1890s. He knew Ellen Houser Rankin Copp (1853-1901) who sculpted the statue of Pele for the KILAUEA VOLCANO PANORAMA exhibit at World’s Columbian Exposition, who also resided at Tree Studio. Michaelowski died of TB and his widow returned his ashes to Berlin[]see CHICAGO TRIBUNE February 29,1896 p.6 Artists Give A Big Reception /Tree Studio Building Thronged with Friends of the Occupants (Michaelowski and Copp listed)[] see CHICAGO TRIBUNE February 23,1896 p.27 Where Art Is Queen Of All /Some Phases of the Bohemian Happiness in the Tree Studio Building[illustration: INTERIOR OF MICHAELOWSKI’S STUDIO]
Theodore Russell Davis (1841-1894), campaign artist for HARPER’S WEEKLY during the Civil War, designer of the White House porcelain service for President Hayes administration, and artist who led the Heine & Lohr crew on their panorama trip to Chattanooga and Atlanta. The contribution of TRD cannot be underestimated. In effect he was the nationally known publicity agent for the Wehner/ Heine & Lohr studio. His article in ST NICHOLAS December 188 “How A Great Battle Panorama Is Made,” is the most quoted how-to article about 19th century rotunda panorama ever written, found in newspapers coast-to-coast, and too in Australia. See: ST NICHOLAS July 1889 “How a Battle is Sketched.” See COSMOPOLITAN June 1892 General Sheridan’s Personality (documenting an incident Sunday August 15,1886 at Panorama Place, Chicago when Sherman and TRD visited BATTLE OF MISSIONARY RIDGE & LOOKOUT MOUNTAIN panorama by Wehner/Heine & Lohr); see COSMOPOLITAN January 1893 Grant Under Fire;see COSMOPOLITAN December 1891 With Sherman In His Army Home;see THE ART AMATEUR 1894, Notes From An Ocean Studio; see THE LADIES’ HOME JOURNAL December 1889 Presidential Entertainments in the White House;see THE ART AMATEUR December 1880 The White House Porcelain Service; see UNITED STATES PATENT OFFICE for TRD designs on the porcelain service. William Wehner was in the high-end glass-and-porcelain business in Chicago. TRD had a 5 year “window” in his contract to receive royalties for his china service patents. When TRD worked for Wehner, Wehner would place a battle panorama ad in the newspapers, and on the same page there would be an ad in a high-end glass-and-porcelain establishment announcing the ROAD SHOW of the White House Porcelain Service by TRD. WHAT IS REALLY INTERESTING is that in recent years THE ANTIQUES ROAD SHOW once was held in Milwaukee, and a relative of Wehner had received a trunk from an Old Aunt ,Wehner’s daughter Ida (1873-1975) that contained some of the TRD White House Porcelain. The relative pretended she did not known anything about the porcelain. David Lackey interviewed her. Wehner’s wife was nee Elisabeth Stuetze of Milwaukee
and her father was Gustav Adolph Stuetze. I have much more info to share
THE WHITE HOUSE PORCELAIN SERVICE: Designs By An American Artist [Theodore Russell Davis], Illustrating Exclusively American Fauna and Flora (1879 Haviland & Co)
[] see OFFICIAL WHITE HOUSE CHINA 1789 TO THE PRESENT by Margaret Brown Klapthor (1999)
EXCELLENT information! Thank you for sharing, Gene Meier.
DEUTSCHAMERIKA by Mathilde Georgine Schley (Milwaukee: 1935)
[p.17] Die sogenannten Panoramamaler machten sich heimlich und um sie scharten sich Bewunderer und Schueler, und eifrig studierte man in den wie Pilze emporschliessenden Ateliers und Kunstschulen. Das Kunstwesen stand in voller Bluete,nicht nur in Milwaukee, wo man sich noch an die wohlbekannten Namen und deren Lebranstalten erinnert, sondern auch in Chicago, Cleveland, Buffalo und St. Louis war sie taetig.
[p.64] Dann kamen die Panoramamaler und waren in Milwaukee, Chicago, Buffalo,Cleveland und St. Louis taetig. Ein gewisser Wehner von Chicago wurde beauftragt, geeignete Kuenstler nach Amerika zu bringen. Das war in den achtziger Jahren und die Kuenstler hiessen Franz Rohrbeck und Hermann Michalowski von Berlin, Otto von Ernst, A.Lohr, F.W.Heine,F.Bieberstein, Richard Lorenz, Robert Schade und der heute noch fleiszige Museumsmaler Georg Peter.[]Mathilde Georgine Schley (1864-1941), is my great aunt. Tante Tilde studied with panoramist Richard Lorenz and Otto von Ernst. She appears in 10 photographs by panoramist Berhnhard Schneider (1843-1907) that were found in Cedarburg by Sue Birnschein and Christine Lajoice. Dated February 1888, according to the F.W.Heine diaries, the young people, dressed as peasants, pose before a unit of JERUSALEM ON THE DAY OF THE CRUCIFIXION, one of three made in the Wehner/Heine & Lohr studio in downtown Milwaukee. Tilde is the girl with the strap across her chest. This particular unit of JERUSALEM would be removed to Buffalo, and later London where it would be confiscated because of international copyright difficulties per panoramist Bruno Piglhein–a long story
A STORY OF THE CHICAGO FIRE by Rev. David Swing//Copyright 1892 Howard H.Gross
Roster of panorama artists: Salvador Mege (Paris), Edward James Austen (London), Oliver Dennett Grover (Chicago), Paul Wilhelmi (Milwaukee, Chicago),William Leftwich Dodge, Ernst Albert, Richard Lorenz (Milwaukee), Edgar S. Cameron, A.Fleury (Paris), C.H.Collins (Iowa, Illinois)
EXHIBITION CATALOG: Panorama, Battles of CHATTANOOGA, Cleveland Panorama Co., Cleveland, Ohio// The magnificent battle panorama of the Storming of Mission Ridge is the THIRD great canvas painted under the supervision of William Wehner,by the corps of artists which has made his studio on Wells street, Milwaukee, prominent throughout Europe and America. Mr. Wehner’s staff comprises twenty artists,each noted in his profession for ability in the branch of art which he makes his specialty. The chief artists, Professors August Lohr of Munich, and F.W.Heine, of Dresden, are well known and of high reputation, the former for his grand landscapes, the latter as a military painter of noted ability.Prominent among their assistants are Franz Biberstein, Wilhelm Schroter,Bernard Schneider,landscape painters; Th. Breidwiser, Herman Michalowsi, Franz Rohrbeck, Robert Schade and George Peter, figure painters; Johannes Schultz and Theo von Lurzer, arms and equipments,and Richard Lorenz, who confines his brush exclusively to animal painting.The studies for this panorama were made with painstaking care,and involved considerable outlay. A substantial lookout, or tower, was erected directly upon the spot from which General Grant directed the battle. here the artists sojourned for weeks,painting elaborate pictures depicting the landscape in every direction. Theodore Russell Davis, well known as the artist and correspondent of HARPER’S, throughout the war, was present with the sketch and notebooks used by him during the actual conflict, twenty years before. Ex-officers o both armies evinced a most cordial interest,and extended every possible assistance…THE MANAGER, Cleveland, Ohio, November 1,1886
EXHIBITION CATALOG: Panorama, Battle of ATLANTA, Detroit// The American Panorama Company’s MISSIONARY RIDGE, on exhibition in Chicago,was the initial painting from my panorama studio. The corps of artists who painted it,strengthened by the addition of a number of appreciated European artists, have executed the admirable panorama of ATLANTA. A thorough inspection of the best panoramas as painted for exhibition in Europe led me to select Prof August Lohr, of Munich, and F.W.Heine, of Dresden, to take charge of my panorama studio in Milwaukee. By birth an Austrian, in art a “Munich man,”he posses power and breadth of color, while in the tender treatment of sky and stance there is a reflex of his thoughtful mind. Prof Lohr painted the landscape of the panorama of the Battles of Weissenberg, St. Privat, Mars La Tour,and Sedan, which rank as the most excellent in Europe. In every way his equal is his co-worker and life-time friend, Prof F.W.Heine, the battle painter,upon whom the important work of composition and the labor attending the same devolves. These gentlemen work in concert,although each is independent of the other. Prof Heine,born at Leipzig,was educated at the academies of Leipzig and Weimar, in the campaign with the Prussian army in the Austrian war of 1866, attracting attention for both his personal courage and artistic ability. Throughout the Franco-Prussian war Prof.Heine braved danger to be present with his sketch book, witnessing the siege of Paris and the coronation of the Emperor at Versailles. His TRIUMPHAL ENTRY OF KING ALBERT INTO DRESDEN AT THE HEAD OF HIS TROOPS, a colossal painting, adorns the council chamber of the city hall of his native city. For the Duke of Brunswick he painted four mammoth battle pieces,representing heroic deeds of Brunswick artillery, infantry and cavalry, in the war with France. THE ARTISTS OF THE STAFF are: Bernhard Schneider, Wilhelm Schroeter and Franz Biberstein, landscape painters; Herr Zuckotinsky,Th Breidwiser,Franz Rohrbeck, Herman Michalowski and Johannes Schultz, figure painters; Richard Lorenz and George Peter, animal painters….For the historical facts in the panorama of ATLANTA I have had,as in MISSIONARY RIDGE, the advantage of the sketch and note books, as well as photographs and knowledge of my friend, Mr. Theodore Russell Davis,who is known to all veterans of the war as the campaign artist of HARPER’S WEEKLY…William Wehner, Milwaukee Studio, February 15,1887
EXHIBITION CATALOG: Panorama, JERUSALEM ON THE DAY OF THE CRUCIFIXION, Edward St. Music Hall Grounds, Buffalo, New York// Mr. William Wehner, the owner of the Milwaukee panorama studio, knew Karl Frosch, who was in charge of the Jerusalem expedition, and hardly waited for his return from Palestine before opening negotiations for all the material, together with the services of Mr. Frosch himself, for a cyclorama of Jerusalem to be painted in this country. Success finally crowned his efforts, and Mr. Frosch came over,bringing all the valuables gathered with him, for the purpose of submitting on canvas the holy city as it appeared on the day of the Crucifixion. In company with F.W.Heine and August Lohr, the composition was made and the great work executed by such prominent Munich artists as Franz Biberstein, Thaddeus von Zukotinsky, Bernhard Schneider, Franz Rohrbeck, Herman Michalowski, Georg Peter and others.
SAN FRANCISCO CALL April 16,1899 History and Art Beautiful in combination/Realistic Panorama of BATTLE OF MANILA [BAY]/ Perfect in Detail[] An entertainment of historic and artistic interest was opened by the INTERSTATE PANORAMA COMPANY for the people of San Francisco yesterday in the PANORAMA OF MANILA BAY at Central Park…For the purpose of preparing the panorama PIERRE N.BOERINGER went as special artist and commissioner to Manila,made a number of elaborate water colors of the landscape and took a series of photographs covering the whole sweep around the bay.From these views and sketches the panorama was painted mainly by AUGUST LOHR and FRANZ BIBERSTEIN of Munich, F.W.HEINE of Dresden and GEORGE PETER of Vienna.These artists are among the most eminent in their profession and have already won high repute for similar work in the artistic capitals of Europe. Much of the success of the marine portion of the panorama is due to W.A.COULTER,the well known marine artist of THE CALL,who gave valuable advice in the accomplishment of some of the technical difficulties of the drawing of ships,and to the officers of the UNION IRON WORKS, who, being builders of the OLYMPIA, assisted by furnishing plans of that model ship…
I live in St. Francis and worked for 6 years at the front desk of Milwaukee County Historical Society until I retired 4 years ago. Your website is magnificent. I am British and have friends who are visiting family here and were going to Cedarburg today. I told them about Bernard Schneider’s painting of the Milwaukee Exposition Center and looked him up briefly and found your website. I’ve written the name down now so I can gorge on your research. I was amazed when they moved the Battle of Atlanta to a new building by cutting in half and using a crane to drop it into the new building. I’ve only been to Atlanta once, in my 20s, and couldn’t have imagined anything historic coming out of that city, so if the virus ever recedes maybe I will get to see Clark Gable’s face on one of the soldiers after he said he thought he ought to be in it (a bit like William Shatner going to space out of a sense of self importance). Great that you are finding women artists. Other than the potential problems of working with men in the field, since many were German there might have been fewer problems than women had in the goldrush towns!
Keep up the brilliant work.
Juliet Hills
Thank you for your kind words, Juliet. Happy holidays!