Tales from a Scenic Artist and Scholar. Part 629 – The Cleveland Scottish Rite, 1909

Part 629: The Cleveland Scottish Rite, 1909

In 1909, Moses wrote, “The Dallas Masonic work came in early, so did San Francisco and Cleveland, Ohio.” That year, Moses also supervised scenery collections for Scottish Rite theaters in Kansas City, Kansas, Winona, Minnesota, and Atlanta, Georgia.

The Valley of Cleveland consists of a ten-county area in northern Ohio. The four Scottish Rite bodies included the Eliadah Lodge of Perfection, Bahurim Council, Ariel Chapter and Lake Erie Consistory. I have uncovered very little information about the building occupied by the Cleveland Scottish Rite before their move to their new home at 3615 Euclid Avenue. The previous Masonic Temple was built in 1883 and located at Superior Avenue and East 6^th St.

Of this first home for the Scottish Rite, the “Akron Beacon Journal” noted that eight Akron Masons received the 32^nd degree at the Spring Scottish Rite reunion in Cleveland (10 March 1910, page 4). The article reported, “The territory covered at this meeting is of northeastern Ohio. Several hundred are expected from the cities. Between 50 and 100 from Akron intend to go. There will be a class of 95 who will take their degrees up through the 32^nd degree.” The first Masonic Temple was obviously a sizable space.

Construction for the new Masonic building commenced during 1918. Interestingly, in 1919, Toomey & Volland scenic studio records indicate that they created scenery for the Cleveland Scottish Rite Temple. Ten years earlier, Sosman & Landis created the scenery for degree work in Cleveland. After 1915, it was not uncommon for Toomey & Volland to underbid Sosman & Landis on Masonic projects, especially in the Northern Masonic Jurisdiction. The Masonic connection provided by Joseph S. Sosman, of Sosman & Landis, disappeared when he passed away in 1915. Thomas G. Moses had taken over the company but was not yet a Mason.

The new Masonic Temple in Cleveland was designed by Hubbell & Benes, the same firm that designed the Cleveland museum of art in 1916. Home to many Masonic Orders, including the Scottish Rite, the massive Masonic structure covered 102,000 square feet of space, with a 2200-seat auditorium. Acclaimed for its acoustics, the Masonic Temple was once home to the Cleveland Orchestra for a decade, before their move in 1931 to Severance Hall.

As with many other Masonic buildings of this scope, declining membership after World War II and escalated expenses from deferred maintenance cause the Cleveland Masons to put their building on the market in 2017. The corporate secretary of the Cleveland Scottish Rite admitted that it cost $400,000 a year to maintain the building, “an outlay that would soon exhaust the operating endowment.” There is an article from 6, August, 2015 that includes some lovely photographs of the building. Here is the link to many of the attached pictures (https://www.cleveland.com/architecture/index.ssf/2015/08/landmark_masonic_auditorium_-.html).

Nearly one hundred years after construction began on the Masonic Auditorium in Cleveland, it was sold to a private developer. An affiliate of Arkansas-based Beaty Capital Group, Inc. paid only $725,000 for the complex on March 31, 2017. Cleveland’s Masonic building is listed on the National Register of Historic Places, the property is eligible for preservation funding including state and federal tax credits.

This is the same group that purchased the Scottish Rite in Forth Smith, Arkansas.

A subsidiary of the Beaty Capital Group, TempleLive (https://www.templelive.com/about/), also purchased the Zembo Shrine building in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania in 2018 (https://www.pennlive.com/news/2018/01/zembo_shrine_sale_shriners_ple.html).

In Cleveland, Fort Smith and Harrisburg, the Fraternity will never be able to afford the expense of constructing anything comparable. The materials and craftsmanship necessary to build these types of buildings are often no longer available. In Cleveland, the chandeliers are made from pieces of shell and hobnailed doors lead to the auditorium. The ones who lose are future generations of Masons who will never experience the space, or the physical sense of heritage. The buildings were planned and constructed by men with vision. It also takes vision to place Freemasonry in the context of today and contemplate how these venues can be saved. The winners in the end are those who are able to purchase these jewels for less than market price and turn a profit.

To be continued…