The Boston Scottish Rite primarily uses an LED wall for the degree production backings. I had the opportunity to examine the effect on April 12 before my afternoon flight. My host went out of his way to take time from his full schedule to share both the building and his work.
The Boston Scottish Rite has only a few historic backdrops, ranging from the early to mid-twentieth century. The later versions are fairly crude traditions of standard themes, done in brilliant dye work. It really is an odd mix of painted elements. The theatre is located on the seventh floor of a building with architecture that is reminiscent of many Northern Masonic Jurisdiction Scottish Rite theaters, Gothic in feel.
I was anxious to see how well an LED wall worked in a historic venue. There can be many short-term benefits to embracing digital scenery before the system becomes obsolete and/or irreparable. Scene changes require no stage crew and the subject matter is limitless, with endless possibilities for backings during degree productions.
However, I recognized that the use of digital images in lieu of historic scenery could result in an overall loss of scenic illusion on the stage. Until I saw the LED wall in Boston, I was unsure as to the extent. There is increased realism for the backing and more flexibility of subject matter, but there is something missing from the stage aesthetic. It is as if the soul of the stage has disappeared, with the space being transformed into something entirely different.
There are a few things to consider when contemplating a switch from traditional painted scenery to digital imagery for Scottish Rite degree productions.
LED walls are fantastic for many things, but the technology is racing so fast that they become obsolete in a relatively short period of time. This nuance of technology is frequently not fully understood by those purchasing a new system. Often the Masonic clients have lived with their historic scenery and stage machinery for decades, and they expect a new system to last just as long. This is especially pertinent if a substantial amount of money is being spent on an entirely new system.
A parallel could be made with much older adults who consider the purchase of a computer as an investment, not a short-term appliance that will soon have to be replaced as technology continues to advance. The same can be said with motorized line sets, lighting systems, and any other digital systems; at some point they will need to be replaced as they will not last for an extended period of time. Many modern components for the stage with computer systems and software cannot last for decades, as technology races forward, thus making replacement parts often unavailable when the need for a repair occurs a few years down the road. At some point the technology will need to be repaired or replaced. As we experience with many other appliances in our home, it may not be possible to get the necessary replacement parts if our specific the model is no longer being produced as better versions are available. Does the client realize that their new technology has a proverbial shelf life and that the entire system will soon need to be replaced?
Regardless of the ease of use, or anticipated life expectancy of an LED wall, its mere presence is incongruous with the visual aesthetic established by historic costumes and properties. What made the traditional painted illusion so successful was that the selection of scenery, props and costumes where selected as a part of a unified visual whole; one intended to be illuminated in a very specific way. To overcome the brilliancy of the LED screen as a backing, I would be curious to see how bright the front light needs to be during degree productions.
A few digital images that the Boston Scottish is using for their LED wall is identical to that used by the Fort Worth Scottish Rite. The photographs originated from a scenery collection produced by Don Carlos Du Bois, representing the Great Western Stage Equipment Co. of Kansas City. The stage compositions are vibrant and very characteristic of the mid-twentieth century. As projections, there is a tendency for fading and a loss of detail. I again noticed this on the USITT Expo floor when looking at a rear projections screen placed next an actual backdrop. The dark areas weren’t as dark as they needed to be. There is a lack of overall contrast, and everything seems to be a just little too light. At the time, I considered how well a rear projection screen would work for degree productions, with performers being placed in front of so much light.
Now the digital images of historic backdrops on an LED wall are even brighter. The spacing between individual LED lights is based on the viewing distance. Just as scenic art painting techniques fall apart as the viewer nears the backdrop, so do individual LED lights that relay the overall image; the farther away the audience is, the greater spacing between the lights. This is why they work so great for rock concerts in auditoriums that seat thousands of people. At the Boston Scottish Rite, the LED wall reads best from the back row of the auditorium, not from the first few rows. It is almost too much technology for the relatively intimate space as you near the stage, let alone step onto the stage.
Now, let’s consider the overall experience of degree participants, after all, that is a major consideration when altering degree work practices. An LED wall creates an entirely different environment for the stage performer. Stepping onto stage in the midst of a fully lit historic scene is magical. You are encompassed by brilliant color and detail, becoming part of the scenic illusion. In the short time that I stood next to the LED wall in Boston, my eyes hurt. The brilliancy for the screen overpowered the entire stage and was very distracting.
The same can be said for the audience experience as you are watching degree work in front of an LED wall. There is a distinct light spill from the image on the screen and I would be curious to see how much front light on the performers is necessary. Just as dimly lit stages cause visual fatigue for the audience, so do brilliantly lit compositions, especially if you are ten feet way.
I am curious to see how long this system will last in Boston and hear about the Scottish Rite degree participants’ experiences.
To be continued…
