Travels of a Scenic Artists and Scholar: The Drop Curtains of Thalian Hall in Wilmington, North Carolina

Many theaters forget their past. Fire, hurricanes, tornados or renovations can destroy artifacts that were never documented in the first place. Painted scenes and machinery are removed, stored, or disposed of at some point and then forgotten. When considering the amount of change that happened to Thalian Hall over the past 150 years, one has to believe that this drop curtain keeps reappearing for a purpose.

Changes made to the theater since it opening in 1858 were documented in a paper, written and compiled by Isabelle M. Williams in 1976. There is also a wonderful book and numerous articles written by D. Anthony Rivenbark about the theater. Much of the information below is from the research of these two authors.

In 1858, Russell Smith received $200 for the drop curtain, a bill paid by five businessmen in Wilmington, North Carolina.

In her paper, Williams notes that major revisions to the theater took place at Thalian Hall in 1867-9, 1881, 1900, 1904, 1909 and 1938. She wrote, “It was remarkable that Thalian Hall has endured it all …” The renovations made over the decades were substantial, but it was the continuing delivery of scenery to the venue that really intrigues me the most.

In 1858, the original proscenium was described as 30 feet high and a little less in width, with a stage area measuring 42 feet by 57 feet. It is believed that the original width of the proscenium was actually 28’ wide by 22’ high, making the drop curtain’s 29’w x 23’h measurements noted on the preliminary drop curtain sketch reasonable.

At the time of installation, it was common for a theater to include a painted grand border; this often occupied the top third of the proscenium opening. A painted grand border and painted side tormentors reduced the proscenium opening for a much more intimate staging. However, if the painted grand border, torms, and drop curtain were removed, the large proscenium opening could accommodate other forms of entertainment, such as aerial acts.

The current remnant of Smith’s original drop curtain was constructed with vertical seams, very similar to the backdrops manufactured at the Sosman & Landis studio in Chicago. The drop curtain panels measure between 26” and 27” wide. There are eleven full panel sections and two partial panel sections, in addition to the two fabric extensions that were added to each side at a later date. The total width of original painted fabric that still remains is approximately 27’ wide. The original edges of the drop, complete with leather rings rope guides, were retained and shifted; with a fabric insert in between the final panel, cut in half to extend the overall width of the drop curtain.

Williams further writes that by 1900, the “curtains” surrounding the drop curtain were replaced, as plans called for a new proscenium and grand drapery. At the time, the term “curtains” often noted painted pieces, while “drapery” described hung fabric that was not painted. It is likely that the original painted tormentors were replaced with actual draperies, thus necessitating the original drop curtain to be enlarged. Also, the Thalian Hall stage was altered “to give more room for scenery.”

There was also another drop curtain installed at Thalian Hall by William F. Hamilton. On October 10, 1899, “The Dispatch” reported, “Mr. A Schloss, the lessee of the Opera House has closed the contract for a new drop curtain for the Opera House. It will be painted by Mr. W. F. Hamilton of the Star Theatre of New York City. William F. Hamilton is the same scenic artist who I have previously written about; the one who partnered with Thomas G. Moses and formed Moses & Hamilton in 1900. The studio produced scenery for opera, Broadway and Coney Island from 1900-1904. Moses & Hamilton set up their new studio at Proctor’s 125^th Street Theatre, a variety theatre in New York City that included a scene room. They also rented paint frames at two other theaters. When their partnership ended, Moses returned to Sosman & Landis while Hamilton stayed in New York.

Hamilton was no stranger to Wilmington. In 1896, The “Wilmington Morning Star” reported, “Mr. F. C. Peckham, of New York, assistant to Mr. W. F. Hamilton, scenic artist and stage manager of the Standard Theatre, arrived in the city yesterday and will commence work on the scenery and a new drop curtain at the Opera House (Wilmington, NC, 26 August, 1896, page 1). It was not uncommon for a venue to include more than one drop curtain; a front drop curtain (landscape composition surrounded by ornamental frame and painted fabric surround), an advertisement curtain (sponsored by local businesses), and an olio curtain (for entr’acte pieces, such as short musical numbers between melodramatic acts); these would all be termed “drop curtains” to accompany the remained of painted settings. Drop curtains could also indicate painted backings, what we consider backdrops now.

J. Constantine provided another drop curtain and two scenes. Constatine was from the Grand Opera House in New York in 1900. The constant trickle of scenery into the theater is not unusual at all. Unfortunately, we do not know the exact compositions for any of the drop curtains painted besides that of Russell Smith. Consantine’s two additional settings, however, were described somewhat. The new scenery included an interior parlor setting with fourteen pieces and a street scene with borders (Star, May 8, 1900, page 13). I interpret this description to mean that the interior parlor scene included fourteen interchangeable flats that were lashed together, a standard interior box set for the time. The street scene included a backdrop, wings, and sky borders. That year, the stage was also remodeled to make room for the additional scenery, necessitating the purchase of new stage machinery at an expense of $740.

By 1904, there was a mention about a change in the proscenium, with the stage being enlarged by 10 feet. This did not include the proscenium opening, just the actual backstage area.

The original Russell Smith drop curtain was finally taken down and stored in the attic when a new front drop curtain arrived from New York City in 1909. The proscenium opening was not listed in Julius Cahn’s Official Theatrical Guide as being 35’ wide. A renovation of this sort, often demands new scenery or the refurbishment and expansion of existing scenery. The well-known Russell Smith curtain could have been enlarged and hung for sentimental purposes on an upstage line, or simply stored and replaced; it is not clear of the exact inventory and line sets at this time. Something prompted the removal of the curtain after the renovation in 1909.

By 1932, however, the original drop curtain was discovered in a storage room of Public Library. Smith’s work again appeared on stage in 1938 when it was hung for a brief period of time before returning to storage. At this point, records indicate that it was stored on the stage and subsequently damaged, with the top third being destroyed. Some accounts note that wheelbarrows were rolled across the top while it was on the floor, causing the damage. And the drop disappeared again before rediscovery a few decades ago.

It is astounding that this curtain survives at all, let alone is still hanging at all in the original building.

To be continued…